Did Karishma have more successful career than Kareena? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Tippy-top

Karishma has one good movie to her credit unlike her sister.

Dil to pagal hai.

I would have said Zubeidaa, she had more to do there

Is it a joke? How can you compare Karishma with Kareena?

Kareena is a fcking LEGEND !

Originally posted by: Sashay01

Kareena for sure

Kareena has started making smarter choices in her second innings. Also the times have changed where scripts are more diverse. Hence a longer career even into her 40s

I think Lolo should invest in better management who can give her good advice- why did she do that weird Ekta Kapoor show last year? But I think she seems happy with her kids and financially secure so maybe it suits her.

Yeah Karisma needs a smart manager - she still looks amazing, she could do so much more work! S She was nice in Mentalhood as well - it was a nice show, I thought it would be all about Karisma being a super mom but Sandhya Mridul and Shilpa Shukla were amazing in it as well.

If success means popularity, then Karisma in 90s >>> Kareena's whole career.

Kareena despite working with all A-listers, in big budgeted products and having a longer career span, never became a crowd puller.

Originally posted by: desigal90

Kareena's more successful; longer career, still working in A list films. No comparison.

exactly

karisma's career crashed as a leading lady after 12 years..from 1991 to 2003..2003 itself was bad with movies like baaz..following which she had 2 disastrous comebacks in 2006 and 2012..so mainly a 12 years career..

kareena in her 12th year..(2012) had 4 releases..EMAET..Agent Vinod..Heroine..Talaash

all different roles..acclaimed performances..very much at top of her game..top slot A list actress

in terms of relevance and longevity..kareena in her 21st year has A list movies lined up as lead..double the career span of karisma..there is no comparison..kareena would beat many esp when it comes to career span as an A list leading lady

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

If success means popularity, then Karisma in 90s >>> Kareena's whole career.

Kareena despite working with all A-listers, in big budgeted products and having a longer career span, never became a crowd puller.

Ki and Ka, Veere Di Wedding did did not have any bigger starts and were hits. She was the "big" star in both of them. Which Karisma film was a crowd puller where she was a bigger star?

Originally posted by: desigal90

Kareena's more successful; longer career, still working in A list films. No comparison.

This thread reminds me of NKapoor...😆

Originally posted by: Tippy-top

Karishma has one good movie to her credit unlike her sister.

Dil to pagal hai.

DTPH was a normal movie...nothing great about it except my Shahrukhwa❤️

What about JWM and Omkara and Chameli and the iconic Poo of KKG......sorry don't mind the ands..lol

https://www.instagram.com/p/BzIWBo7F2qm/?utm_source=ig_embed&ig_rid=d0321557-2558-4a8a-a96c-dd76a8b7267f

Karishma

Kareena

Aye Khuda Tu Bol De Tere Baadalon Ko

Aye Khuda Tu Bol De Tere Baadalon Ko

Mera Yaar Hass Raha Hai Baarish Ki Jaaye

Yaar Hass Raha Hai Baarish Ki Jaaye

Originally posted by: desigal90

Ki and Ka, Veere Di Wedding did did not have any bigger starts and were hits. She was the "big" star in both of them. Which Karisma film was a crowd puller where she was a bigger star?

Queen and Tanu Weds Manu Returns didn't have any bigger stars and were also Hits. Does that make Kangana a crowd puller?

Veere Di Wedding and Ki and Ka were word-of-mouth films. Worked because of good word of mouth. Ki and Ka wasn't even a clean Hit and Arjun Kapoor's star value was almost equal to Kareena in it. Same like Jab We Met.

Still these films were not a big box office success to make Kareena a crowd puller.

Nope, Karisma has no Hits where she was a bigger star, because she worked at a time when films weren't specifically made for female actors. But she's the bigger star because she can be credited for her big Hits unlike Kareena. One Raja Hindustani is enough to make her a bigger star than Kareena.