Why should Rudra die? - Page 6

Originally posted by: Minionite

Oh my god I haven't been called by that username in a long time. By the way, my name is Shreya. 😊

Hi Shreya, nice to see you again after the EDT forum.

Originally posted by: Rein123

That way even Maya’s unborn child shouldn’t have died as it was innocent, Maya’s mom shouldn’t have ended up in the mental asylum as she was innocent, her father and brother shouldn’t have died either as they were innocent, Myra shouldn’t have died either since she was innocent too but they she still died. Whether Rudra is innocent or not , if he is to die he will die. And no even in fictional stories people don’t live or die because they deserve to or live on because they are innocent, there is no requirement to keep a character alive just because they are innocent or they deserve to live a happy life ahead. If the cvs want to kill Rudra they can do it at the end, same way if they want to kill Maya and keep MJ alive they can, or if they can even bring Rishi back to life. If the story demands a character’s death to engage a viewer with the story that is exactly what the cvs will do whether you like it or hate it.

Of course they didn't deserve to die an untimely death, that's why Maya is taking revenge, if their death was a truth, a force of nature, something which just happens why would Maya take revenge? 🤦‍♀️

I am not forcing them, I just gave an opinion that I don't think Rudra should die in the end because I see why would they kill MJ or Maya, I don't see why would they kill Rudra? It's in writer's hand, I just gave my POV

Originally posted by: NoraSM

Of course they didn't deserve to die an untimely death, that's why Maya is taking revenge, if their death was a truth, a force of nature, something which just happens why would Maya take revenge? 🤦‍♀️

I am not forcing them, I just gave an opinion that I don't think Rudra should die in the end because I see why would they kill MJ or Maya, I don't see why would they kill Rudra? It's in writer's hand, I just gave my POV

It’s because that is the theme of this season as narrated by Rudra himself. If they don’t kill Rudra then they can’t kill Maya either. Maya May have been wrong in abetting Rishi’s suicide however her dying won’t be the punishment for that either, in fact if I’m not mistaken, wasn’t she already punished for it with Myra’s death at MJ’s hands?

Originally posted by: Rein123

It’s because that is the theme of this season as narrated by Rudra himself. If they don’t kill Rudra then they can’t kill Maya either. Maya May have been wrong in abetting Rishi’s suicide however her dying won’t be the punishment for that either, in fact if I’m not mistaken, wasn’t she already punished for it with Myra’s death at MJ’s hands?

They can kill Rudra, They will kill Rudra or they don't kill Rudra

My point of view in this matter is that Rudra should not die as he deserves a happy life, he should not pay for Maya and MJ's sin with his life.

Myra dying is not a punishment for Maya, Myra and Rishi lost their lives, not Maya

Originally posted by: Soulfuldream

Rudra isn't dying...infact I feel he will be the one who will kill Maya...

Afterall his Sukoon Maya will become his dard...

So like the Oracle Rudra spoke .. he will destroy her because Maya ain't stopping now...

She is definitely not going to get herself to meet his eye when Rishi's death comes out in the open...because she was wrong.. so so wrong...

MJ and her truth has nothing for her to be ashamed of... infact I am all with her for the revenge she is asking for...

nope this will not happen. In season 1, arjun killed maya. I don't think cv's will show the same kind of ending. i have a feeling this time ending will be unique and interesting. 😛

Originally posted by: NoraSM

They can kill Rudra, They will kill Rudra or they don't kill Rudra

My point of view in this matter is that Rudra should not die as he deserves a happy life, he should not pay for Maya and MJ's sin with his life.

Myra dying is not a punishment for Maya, Myra and Rishi lost their lives, not Maya

Well Maanvi died! Yes Rudra shouldn’t pay for what MJ did to Maanvi and what Maya did to Rishi.

Maya will be punished for making Rishi commit suicide however death will not be that punishment either. It’s probably going to be losing Rudra where he begins to hate her until he learns the truth about MJ.

Rudra deserves a happy life, but doesn’t Maya deserve the same?

Maya losing Myra wasn’t punishment then why did Aditya pray for Maya to lose the one she loves and is close to her? Hasn’t Maya already lost enough people who were innocent? Yet she should continue suffering for getting back at the Roys and giving them a taste of their own medicine?

Originally posted by: Rein123

Well Maanvi died! Yes Rudra shouldn’t pay for what MJ did to Maanvi and what Maya did to Rishi.

Maya will be punished for making Rishi commit suicide however death will not be that punishment either. It’s probably going to be losing Rudra where he begins to hate her until he learns the truth about MJ.

Rudra deserves a happy life, but doesn’t Maya deserve the same?

Maya losing Myra wasn’t punishment then why did Aditya pray for Maya to lose the one she loves and is close to her? Hasn’t Maya already lost enough people who were innocent? Yet she should continue suffering for getting back at the Roys and giving them a taste of their own medicine?

Maanvi didn't die, Maanvi has changed her identity to Maya, She is very much alive.

I don't know what will be Maya's punishment for killing Rishi, Rudra leaving her would be her punishment for taking away Rudra's light ie Rishi, that's for hurting Rudra not for killing Rishi, what Aditya said was from his and Rudra's perspective, he wanted Rishi's murderer to lose someone so close to understand how THEY felt, Myra dying has helped Maya get this happy life with Rudra, Maya did not care to give Myra a proper funeral, how is it similar to what Rishi was to Rudra?

MJ will suffer for killing people around Maya and everything he did to her, Maya should suffer for killing Rishi, as simple as that, I am not going to justify murder here

Originally posted by: NoraSM

Maanvi didn't die, Maanvi has changed her identity to Maya, She is very much alive.

I don't know what will be Maya's punishment for killing Rishi, Rudra leaving her would be her punishment for taking away Rudra's light ie Rishi, that's for hurting Rudra not for killing Rishi, what Aditya said was from his and Rudra's perspective, he wanted Rishi's murderer to lose someone so close to understand how THEY felt, Myra dying has helped Maya get this happy life with Rudra, Maya did not care to give Myra a proper funeral, how is it similar to what Rishi was to Rudra?

MJ will suffer for killing people around Maya and everything he did to her, Maya should suffer for killing Rishi, as simple as that, I am not going to justify murder here

Yes Maanvi has died, from the way i see it, she is dead, her innocence died the day MJ dropped her of in some pool of dirt assuming she died. No one’s justifying murder. The point is Maya has suffered enough and she still is, otherwise she wouldn’t have bothered taking revenge. Once she pays the price for making Rishi commit suicide she should also be able to get a happy ending of her own.

@bold given Maya’s reach and contacts I bet she would have taken care of Myra’s funeral. She wouldn’t leave Myra alone judging by how she tried to rush towards her dead body in a distraught state of mind. That’s another thing that it hasn’t been showed yet. So yes she is the same to her as what Rishi was to Rudra. That way even I can say that Rudra and the Roys didn’t care much about Rishi given by how they were celebrating Rudra’s pre marriage ceremonies and rituals right after he died.

Originally posted by: Rein123

Yes Maanvi has died, from the way i see it, she is dead, her innocence died the day MJ dropped her of in some pool of dirt assuming she died. No one’s justifying murder. The point is Maya has suffered enough and she still is, otherwise she wouldn’t have bothered taking revenge. Once she pays the price for making Rishi commit suicide she should also be able to get a happy ending of her own.

@bold given Maya’s reach and contacts I bet she would have taken care of Myra’s funeral. She wouldn’t leave Myra alone judging by how she tried to rush towards her dead body in a distraught state of mind. That’s another thing that it hasn’t been showed yet. So yes she is the same to her as what Rishi was to Rudra. That way even I can say that Rudra and the Roys didn’t care much about Rishi given by how they were celebrating Rudra’s pre marriage ceremonies and rituals right after he died.

There are numerous types of death, if we are taking account of end of innocence then MJ is dead too, the human in him is dead. Manvi is alive and Maya is Manvi

Can MJ pay the price of whatever he did to Maya and have a happy ending of his own?

Is it okay to kill people because you had a bad past? Everyone has a bad past, some have it worse but it doesn't mean they will get sympathy even after ending lives, MJ killed Manvi's innocence and Maya killed Rishi, He didn't want to commit suicide in first place, she didn't help him in it, she tricked him to commit suicide. She lied to him, trapped him in her love and ended his life, why was MJ wrong for doing this to Maya but Maya isn't for doing this to Rishi?

They showed Maya did not pick up Myra's dead body, I am not going to assume that she used her contacts when they didn't show it. Rudra and Aditya scene in this week's episode proved how important Rishi was for Rudra and Aditya.

Anyway, Maya killed Rishi, why did Myra pay for Maya's wrongdoings? Is it that easy to get rid of murder charge then kill everyone in MJ's family, let him live, it doesn't work like that, yes?

Originally posted by: NoraSM

There are numerous types of death, if we are taking account of end of innocence then MJ is dead too, the human in him is dead. Manvi is alive and Maya is Manvi

Can MJ pay the price of whatever he did to Maya and have a happy ending of his own?

Is it okay to kill people because you had a bad past? Everyone has a bad past, some have it worse but it doesn't mean they will get sympathy even after ending lives, MJ killed Manvi's innocence and Maya killed Rishi, He didn't want to commit suicide in first place, she didn't help him in it, she tricked him to commit suicide. She lied to him, trapped him in her love and ended his life, why was MJ wrong for doing this to Maya but Maya isn't for doing this to Rishi?

They showed Maya did not pick up Myra's dead body, I am not going to assume that she used her contacts when they didn't show it. Rudra and Aditya scene in this week's episode proved how important Rishi was for Rudra and Aditya.

Anyway, Maya killed Rishi, why did Myra pay for Maya's wrongdoings? Is it that easy to get rid of murder charge then kill everyone in MJ's family, let him live, it doesn't work like that, yes?

Can you please tell me where exactly did anyone say that Maya was right to make Rishi commit suicide or that it is ok? Of course she was wrong. The only difference between MJ and Maya is that MJ is as wretched as he used to be years ago, no change in his overall disposition, while Maya on the other hand is only retaliating back for what he did to her with the intention of ending it once she is done with him.

Coming to why Myra paid for Maya’s deeds? It’s because she chose to do so, she did it willingly by her own choice, she did it as a sacrifice so Maya can live on and get the happiness she deserves. That alone defines the kind of relationship they had, which is no different from that of two sisters. Hope that answered your question.

About MJ paying the price plus mending his ways and then getting a happy ending, why not? Do people that have paid for their crimes by serving time in prison or any other way not deserve a fresh start in life? Are they supposed to live in pain and agony for eternity?

If MJ is dead then how can Maanvi be alive? Yes there are many kinds of deaths and here both of them are dead, only thing is one dead person (MJ) killed a living one (Maanvi).