Bigg Boss changing course: Portraying Sid as the villian? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Pain-in-ur-Neck

Why did Hina get so much hate?! Was she genuinely annoying chudail type or was that her game plan? ... She comes off very weird in her IVs bitchy type!

Although, I didn't like her in that season. But she had the strong personality. She was good in tasks and yes sometimes she used to overboard, also, editing team was hell bent in proving her vamp, she many times never had control on her words because of which almost whole TV industry bashed her. She was the most hated then but at some points she did speak strongly against the biasedness and stuck to her words, favouritism towards Shilpa too made her gain sympathy. That's why Hina doesn't say openly who she likes this season. She says that it's all about portrayal and editing. They will make one look negative or positive like they want.

Paras and Sid have all evil vibes in secret room !

They were like two Villains giving evilishs smirks and preparing to be more nasty !!

I think you are right !!

Originally posted by: randomfancrics

I highly doubt if channel will support Asim, I wish they will be fair, too much manipulations.

But for a fact, from season 8 I realized whoever went to secret room NEVER won the show. So this may be an indication Shukla MAY NOT win this season. Winner might be between Rashami and Asim if this is true. But among the three I see Shukla is having the highest chance even according to twitter, but if I see this forum and insta then its Asim who has the highest chance but he never made it to ormax and ormax somehow gets the winners always right. So this season its really confusing to say that who will win this season. If I refer to past trends its either Shukla or Rashami who has the highest chance. Asim has to play very carefully now, more than Shukla/Rashami it may prove costly for him if he makes a mistake

What about Sana's chances ?

Originally posted by: chirpyhapibird

What about Sana's chances ?

Sana may go finals but surely she wont win. Sometimes I doubt if she will even make it to Top 4.

Originally posted by: Chotimotipsycho

I liked your points but I feel makers are playing a very confused game here.

The makers by now are aware that the audience is divided into two groups! Sid and Sana fans on one hand and Rashmi and Asim fans on the other. Not saying they are mutual. But Rashmi and Asim fans both probably dislike Shukla the most. And Shukla fans probably dislike Asim and Rashmi the most.

The fan wars have drawn the line. The neutrals will have shifting allegiances. If you notice both Sid and Asim in the last 3 weeks have been shown in both good and bad light. Some of their soft and human moments have been shown, and some of their very bad moments have been show too. The fact neither Has been bashed directly on the weekends is another sign- that makes aren’t taking a side just yet. Asim has looked less wrong and that’s why he’s been ignored and Sid hasn’t been spoken to properly because his violence has been too much.

This one week is crucial. But I feel, makers aren’t trying to make Sid or Asim look like villains( but they want the audience to choose) but they’re definitely making Rashmi the heroine in all this. Her whole arhaan thing and arhaan still saying stupid stuff about Rashmi is only going to benefit her in gaining sympathy.

I feel Asim vs Sid will be used whole season( fans will feel the narrative is against the other although eventually BB will make Asim the villain if they have to pick one) but the makers idea is to Rashmi the most sympathetic in all this.

Hm well put. Its totally true that both are handled carefully at the editing/subtle level. Good and bad moments are highlighted. BUT, not at the Bigg Boss/Salman level at all. Shukla has once again showed clear, intentional violence, and now its gotten to the point where its not even mentioned directly. If things were even, this entire weekend should have been a huge Shukla bashing for repeating the violence totally unprovoked, but instead, the Arhaan thing was given all the attention and everybody else's violence was brought up just to check the box. For this reason, I kinda feel like the show is sorta throwing up their hands and just going with Shukla as the bad guy. Waise bhee his fans are likely to support anything he does anyway.

But ya, I do agree with you though, that if ANYONE is actively made the hero in all this - its Rashmi.

Originally posted by: NepaliArtist

Hm well put. Its totally true that both are handled carefully at the editing/subtle level. Good and bad moments are highlighted. BUT, not at the Bigg Boss/Salman level at all. Shukla has once again showed clear, intentional violence, and now its gotten to the point where its not even mentioned directly. If things were even, this entire weekend should have been a huge Shukla bashing for repeating the violence totally unprovoked, but instead, the Arhaan thing was given all the attention and everybody else's violence was brought up just to check the box. For this reason, I kinda feel like the show is sorta throwing up their hands and just going with Shukla as the bad guy. Waise bhee his fans are likely to support anything he does anyway.

But ya, I do agree with you though, that if ANYONE is actively made the hero in all this - its Rashmi.

yup! I think the problem is the makers aren’t able to move from their pre decided narrative of making the season all about Shukla and making him the Hero.

Whatever said and done, Shukla would have been the unchallenged winner and he might still be but this season wouldn’t have been spicy and so engaging if they didn’t have a contestant like Asim. Complete surprise package hai but this Sid vs Asim rivalry inspires strong emotions in fans of both sides which is exactly what BB is exploiting for their TRP’s.

Sid was never a hero he was always a villain they portrayed him as hero the problem happened when asim started getting public support as asim stood against sid for his self respect and did not follow chanel narrative of being with sid can make you win the show he had genuine respect for sid and it was always asim who use to control sid of getting too violent .Sid and Paras are both alike they both are egoist and bully people saying asim had used sid it is sid whose anger was being controlled by asim.They bought vishal too for being against sid but he became phuski bomb paras had given up because of bashing only asim and rashmi had guts to stand up against sid as vikas gupta said its fight between chanel and contestants not between contestant in season tedah bully are being supported more as everything is ulta the more bashing you get by chanel the more support you will get from public paras ,mahira and sana had spoiled there game by being with sid as they though salman are thinking people are loving them but more there negative sides are coming out losing support.Paras game was good when he was against sid .

Originally posted by: S2590

Sid was never a hero he was always a villain they portrayed him as hero the problem happened when asim started getting public support as asim stood against sid for his self respect and did not follow chanel narrative of being with sid can make you win the show he had genuine respect for sid and it was always asim who use to control sid of getting too violent .Sid and Paras are both alike they both are egoist and bully people saying asim had used sid it is sid whose anger was being controlled by asim.They bought vishal too for being against sid but he became phuski bomb paras had given up because of bashing only asim and rashmi had guts to stand up against sid as vikas gupta said its fight between chanel and contestants not between contestant in season tedah bully are being supported more as everything is ulta the more bashing you get by chanel the more support you will get from public paras ,mahira and sana had spoiled there game by being with sid as they though salman are thinking people are loving them but more there negative sides are coming out losing support.Paras game was good when he was against sid .

True, that's exactly what I mean. He was portrayed as a hero despite being a villian. But something about the way he is shown in the secret room, laughing, high-fiving etc with Paras while watching others feels deliberately villainous. Like they are somehow throwing their hands up and just showing him as he is now.

He looks villain only to his haters who look Arhaan as a hero

Like how they are bashing him for Asim’s injury which was caused by Arhaan in Kuan task and BB hide it when he fainted . Ismein bhi Sid ka fault 🤔🤣

It's still up in the air. With still so much time left, their narrative will change based on how the game is going and what the audience wants.

At this time, I think Rashmi is being favored too. It's weird how they were making her life tough and suddenly Salman shows to care for her. His reason of talking about Arhaan is because he proposed on TV. Shitty reason to tackle this whole thing. They are cashing on her popularity. I bet they would have let her go the first time if she wasn't so popular.

Shukla - they really can't make him the hero. They have tried so hard but he just doesn't have it in him. With that kind of I am always right attitude - it's impossible. Cannot take any criticism. His bathroom monologue made no sense. He treated Asim and co like shit. Asim depended on him but don't let Shukla fool you. He treated him as his subordinate and not a brother like he claims. The guy can't think beyond himself - no one is asking him to do chaplusi. All he has to do is be cordial and respectful to others.