Because DD was gay...

Eh, just adds to the complexity of Dumbledore's character, that there's just so much we don't know about him. Give's more depth to DD's past.

Assuming homosexuality is considered the same as it is in our world then one can even say that it gives a reason (a basis) for him doing the things that he did. To accept those who are unaccepted for simply being different which was in DD's nature; perhaps his own orientation contributed to that. To feel the pain of un-acceptance (whether he was out or closeted) perhaps led him to reflect others pains and fears as well.

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

I personally think there wudnt be much difference even if Dumbledore wud have been a Hetero... 😛 about the Grindelwald thing, i will say it wasnt much necessary...and Grindelwald cud have been shown as a female dark wizard.

No offence, but i persoanlly don't like this idea... 😳 😳

Sorry if i offended anyone. 😛

well dats my point

Originally posted by: tukz_REmix

hmm....grindy was female na den mst probably DD wud hav nvr returned to his right mind..or probably ariana wudnt hav died....cuz normally gals r like dat nat...dark or white....normally dey wont go n quearrel like dat n blow away d house...she wud hav killd or injured DD secretly u no...n dat wud hav PROBABLY chnged d stry😳

well dats my point

Maybe....😕But i personally dont support this thing, so i cant side with any of u.....sorry ...😆

PS: no offence to any member who supports this...😳

Originally posted by: *Jane*

Eh, just adds to the complexity of Dumbledore?s character, that there?s just so much we don?t know about him. Give?s more depth to DD?s past.

Assuming homosexuality is considered the same as it is in our world then one can even say that it gives a reason (a basis) for him doing the things that he did. To accept those who are unaccepted for simply being different which was in DD?s nature; perhaps his own orientation contributed to that. To feel the pain of un-acceptance (whether he was out or closeted) perhaps led him to reflect others pains and fears as well.

Maybe u r right in some way.....(and ur logic is also very good...)but i think it can be shown in many other ways. Can't it be shown that DD was a warewolf? or any other kind of thing that might make him "unaccepted..."?😉

No offence, but i personally dont support this thing...u know what i am saying (dont u?) I consider it as a crime (sorry, dont get offended plzzzz😆) and i always thought DD to be 100% pure white...so according to my opinion, i was kinda shocked knowing it....

PS: (i am tired of writing "PS"😆) plzzz dont get ofended with wat i write.😃

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

Maybe u r right in some way.....(and ur logic is also very good...)but i think it can be shown in many other ways. Can't it be shown that DD was a warewolf? or any other kind of thing that might make him "unaccepted..."?😉

No offence, but i personally dont support this thing...u know what i am saying (dont u?) I consider it as a crime (sorry, dont get offended plzzzz😆) and i always thought DD to be 100% pure white...so according to my opinion, i was kinda shocked knowing it....

PS: (i am tired of writing "PS"😆) plzzz dont get ofended with wat i write.😃

Just because you say not to get offended (like three times) does not mean I haven't been. Feelings cannot be stopped simply because the author of the offending material said not to feel offended.

Why is being a werewolf any different from being gay? Why is it more acceptable for a person to be an outcast (which is the weirdest logic I've ever heard) as a werewolf (according to you) than it is for a person to be an outcast for being gay. Exactly what is wrong with being gay?

Sorry....double post....😳

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

I have no intention of starting a fight....but let me tell u, if u get offended, thats completely ur fault. Its a PUBLIC DISCUSSION FORUM, and being a member here i have every right to express my views freely, unless i use any IRRATIONAL language....and as far as i am concerned with, i havent....so whats there to get offended?😉If u do get offended, then i will request u to NOT join a public discussion forum, because when u join it, u should always keep this in mind, that there will be people of various tastes. choice, and never will there be any single person having the same mentality.😛

And jane, plz i request u again to mind what u say: why u need to use terms like "wirdest logic i have ever heard"???

And about ur last question i will say visit this links, u will definitley understand why i dont support it...here are the link (do visit it):

http://www.narth.com/docs/whitehead.html

😛

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

I have no intention of starting a fight....but let me tell u, if u get offended, thats completely ur fault. Its a PUBLIC DISCUSSION FORUM, and being a member here i have every right to express my views freely, unless i use any IRRATIONAL language....and as far as i am concerned with, i havent....so whats there to get offended?😉If u do get offended, then i will request u to NOT join a public discussion forum, because when u join it, u should always keep this in mind, that there will be people of various tastes. choice, and never will there be any single person having the same mentality.😛

And jane, plz i request u again to mind what u say: why u need to use terms like "wirdest logic i have ever heard"???

And about ur last question i will say visit this links, u will definitley understand why i dont support it...here are the link (do visit it):

http://www.narth.com/docs/whitehead.html

😛

GUYZ...GUYZ...GUYZ...

wen i strted this topic tht time i told dont fight on homosexuality..if u wana fight plzz pm each other..also,the topic is bt,HOW DD IS GAY AFFECTS THE STORY n not how it affects you..and NO sorry for offence..also,this is a PUBLIC DISCUSSION FORUM,NOT PUBLIC FIGHTING FORUM..

P.S.-http://www.narth.com/docs/whitehead.html article was interesting..