Performances Discussion Thread !!Finale Week!! ❤️ ❤️

Lizzie

@SoupyTwist

Alumni

35

+ 34

Posted: 8 years ago

#51

Looking at the song choices and the lacklustre performances in the finale, I can't help but feel the other contestants had kinda given up. It seemed a foregone conclusion that Hemant would win and no one even wanted to try and compete.

It's true Hemant was probably the best in terms of ability, but the scores in the earlier episodes proved that he could be beaten. The votes in the finale seem suspiciously low to me.

1

Reply

Quote

lissa007

@lissa007

Explorer

6

Posted: 8 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett
Looking at the song choices and the lacklustre performances in the finale, I can't help but feel the other contestants had kinda given up. It seemed a foregone conclusion that Hemant would win and no one even wanted to try and compete.
It's true Hemant was probably the best in terms of ability, but the scores in the earlier episodes proved that he could be beaten. The votes in the finale seem suspiciously low to me.

I wouldn't say they had given up. Vishnumaya and especially Rohanpreet had chances to win. But both of them didn't choose the right songs in my opinion. As far as the votings are concerned, Vishnumaya deserved more % than Rohanpreet in the second round. And her having a tie with Rohanpreet does seem very suspicous, I won't be surprised if we find out it was rigged so they could do Rohanpreet vs. Hemant.

1

Reply

Quote

Lizzie

@SoupyTwist

Alumni

35

+ 34

Posted: 8 years ago

#53

Originally posted by: lissa007

I wouldn't say they had given up. Vishnumaya and especially Rohanpreet had chances to win. But both of them didn't choose the right songs in my opinion. As far as the votings are concerned, Vishnumaya deserved more % than Rohanpreet in the second round. And her having a tie with Rohanpreet does seem very suspicous, I won't be surprised if we find out it was rigged so they could do Rohanpreet vs. Hemant.

@Bold: That's exactly why I say they'd sorta given up. They didn't choose finale-worthy songs. Neither did Zaid who'd be doing so well all through the show. It seemed like the stage was set for Hemant to win and the rest were just tagging along for the ride. No one gave "takkar" to him and we've seen that they were more than capable of it. Maybe if the Akhtar Bros were in the finale, we'd have seen some tough competition for Hemant, at least in terms of the singing- not sure about the votes since they've been getting low votes for the last few epis. But even that considered, I think all of them, including Rohanpreet have done better than they did in the finale.

Reply

Quote

pallavi

@behindyou

Sparkler

32

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: lissa007

I wouldn't say they had given up. Vishnumaya and especially Rohanpreet had chances to win. But both of them didn't choose the right songs in my opinion. As far as the votings are concerned, Vishnumaya deserved more % than Rohanpreet in the second round. And her having a tie with Rohanpreet does seem very suspicous, I won't be surprised if we find out it was rigged so they could do Rohanpreet vs. Hemant.

exactly finale looks too feeka, hemant was lyk their ustaad ...everyone from my family and friends were sure of hemant winning... he was way ahead than them but song selection disappoints me a lot ...atleast they could try to give takkar to hemant wd superb song selection... a party number from vishnu could be game changer... she was getting typecast with shreya ghoshal songs and rohan wd romance songs🥱

Reply

Quote

lissa007

@lissa007

Explorer

6

Posted: 8 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett

@Bold: That's exactly why I say they'd sorta given up. They didn't choose finale-worthy songs. Neither did Zaid who'd be doing so well all through the show. It seemed like the stage was set for Hemant to win and the rest were just tagging along for the ride. No one gave "takkar" to him and we've seen that they were more than capable of it. Maybe if the Akhtar Bros were in the finale, we'd have seen some tough competition for Hemant, at least in terms of the singing- not sure about the votes since they've been getting low votes for the last few epis. But even that considered, I think all of them, including Rohanpreet have done better than they did in the finale.

Oh true! I wonder why they chose these kind of songs 😕 They have been so much better in the earlier episodes! There really was no "takkar" I really wished Akthar Bros would have been in Top 3. Performance wise they would have been really good. But what is done is done I guess.

Reply

Quote

Lizzie

@SoupyTwist

Alumni

35

+ 34

Posted: 8 years ago

#56

Originally posted by: lissa007

@Bold: That's exactly why I say they'd sorta given up. They didn't choose finale-worthy songs. Neither did Zaid who'd be doing so well all through the show. It seemed like the stage was set for Hemant to win and the rest were just tagging along for the ride. No one gave "takkar" to him and we've seen that they were more than capable of it. Maybe if the Akhtar Bros were in the finale, we'd have seen some tough competition for Hemant, at least in terms of the singing- not sure about the votes since they've been getting low votes for the last few epis. But even that considered, I think all of them, including Rohanpreet have done better than they did in the finale.

Oh true! I wonder why they chose these kind of songs 😕 They have been so much better in the earlier episodes! There really was no "takkar" I really wished Akthar Bros would have been in Top 3. Performance wise they would have been really good. But what is done is done I guess.

The finale itself was so underwhelming! No brouhaha, no grand stage, no guest stars or singers! 😕 The other reality shows hype up the finale so much! Also, I thought they'd recall some of the older contestants and have them perform, but apart from Harmony Chorus, no one came! 😕

Reply

Quote

709927

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

#57

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett

Oh true! I wonder why they chose these kind of songs 😕 They have been so much better in the earlier episodes! There really was no "takkar" I really wished Akthar Bros would have been in Top 3. Performance wise they would have been really good. But what is done is done I guess.

The finale itself was so underwhelming! No brouhaha, no grand stage, no guest stars or singers! 😕 The other reality shows hype up the finale so much! Also, I thought they'd recall some of the older contestants and have them perform, but apart from Harmony Chorus, no one came! 😕

They had the one and only Sindhu tai and the Brijbros...no need for anyone else. 😆

Plus the format itself is TRP gold with the live voting and all the other drama...like tied scores and decimal differences! For example, ideally, the positions should have been determined by cumulative performance scores from the first and second round to be fair but then where's the TRP-raising sweat-inducing drama? They put all the pressure on the second performance so the audience would be equally anxious for their favorites. I was on the edge of my seat...hoping for miracles! 😆

1

Reply

Quote

naq5

@naq5

Rocker

26