I agree. I was like 😲😲 when he got 91%. I mean he was nowhere near Rohanpreet, let alone be able to surpass him. It certainly isn't fair, he keeps choking at key moments. The thing is, I can even understand nervousness causing him to choke, but after the wall raised, I thought he'd be okay, there'd be less pressure and he'd perform better. But no! He choked even after that and he forgot almost the entire antara and part of the mukhda too! I don't know how the judges were being so encouraging - it really does look like favoritism at this point. I don't see other singers being given the benefit of doubt like this!
As for Hoshiyaar, his performance wasn't good today. He may have sung on a lower scale than he's used to, but he should have been firm about singing in the pitch he's accustomed to. He's had 3 bad performances, so I really think it's fair he was voted out.
The top performances for me today were Harmony chorus and Rohanpreet. The Akhtar Brothers are technically perfect but somehow I wasn't that moved by their performance. Mamta was good too, but the theatrics in the last part lost her some points with me.