Originally posted by: Mrs.Peanuts
I have researched into Islam's history and there is an excellent view of Islam and the Golden Age .While Europe Catholic Church was persecuting heretics for pursuing knowledge in other side knowledge was being preserved esp.witn creation of library ,Universities. When Ghenghis Khan attacked Baghdad he destroyed all the libraries ,and partly how it is believed why there is such a differences and mess with in a religion itself.I think like how Christianity with after going through blood shed etc with ending signing of Treaty of Westphalia in 1631.I think Islam word just needs to go through reformation overall like Christianity did.
Middle East is chaotic and full of conflict because one big reason is Treaty of Versailles where Widrow Wilson failed.
It was the British who created Whabism along with Monarchs to segregate and influence Saudi Arabia by creating differences so that is how Whabism rose .
Good intelligent post. Btw I dont remember was it you who once went after me for something and I got angry? Was it something to do with sexuality? I am sorry I am not remembering. Maybe it happened during Bigg Boss.
I am sorry my friend...I ran out of posts. I have to ration things here. Distribute my posts all over the day so that next day I have available slots available at all times. So when i post 3-4 i run out of slots for hours. That is what happened.
Summary
- Imagine and Justmoi pointed towards Games of Thrones
- Flame and Flip Flop engaged in debate in well civilized manner without getting personal
- RTH aka return to hades again proved that she is still and easily the best debater here on this forum. She is a special person in her own way.
- Some members pointed towards sex slave issues but provided no solid reference
- Resident evil was here briefly as well
- Some members objected that its a movie
- Sunflower presented points in very balanced and proper manner
- Hawas Ku Pujari made random points about Khilji's portrait.
- There were some random members pointing towards why should Bhainsali show Khilji in good light
- Heisoberg graced us well and made a big catch that Hippo is a bigot.
- Briahna pointed towards cowboy boots
- Dhakkan has some questions about the poem
- mz giglez honored this topic with her presence
- Betty then came her and said a lot by not saying a lot or was it the other way around
- Theekhi Mithai entered. She was concerned where this forum is heading. She was in pain at the current status of this forum. She is a sensitive soul
- Betty is still doing something
- Piya made a innocent observation
- Followed by flame of darkness who was surprised at my expectations
- bikerider followed up on earlier points that why are we taking this even seriously
- Big one entered. Blue ice. Forum's most famous and popular member. She participated in her custom fair and balanced manner. She is not fan of Bhainsali but she defended Bhains in his depiction of Jauhar.
- Pallavi aka Pallu observed ranveer the clown in Khalibali ho gaya main ...
- Hot dog noted that he or she has not seen the movie
- Fivestars i.e. you entered and pointed to good looks of real Khilji
- Rager came ..gave her one liner and ran away..did not answer my question which is fine
- here4reviews basically shut up the total argument of documentary vs movie
- Some member u..bitch came and joined chorus of Hippo is a bigot.
- flipflop is debating and particpating
- hasini - real samrat ashoka approved this post
- Flame and Mithai are in some dicsussion
- Justmyself entered and appreciated the scholar Hippo with return thanks from Hippo
- Zandu appears again...after quietly reading the topic. He presented few shayrs and mahawras from his patori...wrapped up in tanz and digs.
- A behuda, besharam, badmash, batameez, buzdil MID who could not post from real ID abused members and religion
- Minzpie appears again ..looking lost like Betty
- We are reminded again about picture of Khilji. Dont know what was going on there
- NumbuMirch enters...remembering her old jaamana...she was upset that how come khilji character got famous then raja ratan or whatever his name was
- Malka-e-Bahais made an intelligent post with good khulasa
- Mithai is getting worried that topic is out of hands and should be banned. RTH does not agree
- Zaandu is now coming in open
- Heiso is back..well he was never gone.
- Betty and Mizie exchanged some posts...lost vs lost = lost squared
- cory is here and presented a point
- RveerRoa is next ...concerned for Ranveer
- Zaandu and one more member are dancing at success of the movie. its like someone dancing at seeing a bond of water in desert.
- The behuda troll takes alvida
- Hydro a respected member observed that Khilji was cruel
- Mrs Peanuts gave us gyaan on Islam, Moghuls, Mongols.
- Fivestar asks for khulasa
- Flip responds
- RTH shares some links
Overall conclusion are two fold
- Hippo stands by his point that a) SLB distorted history and b) motivation was political.
- Opposite claimed that Hippo is a Muslim and a bigot and therefore he started this topic. He is in pain that why was Khilji shown as bad and Raju Ratan was shown as good. Hence Hippo as lost it and gone crazy.
Lol..I hope this summary which is more longer than the chapter...this abstract that which is longer than the article was helpful. lol
Edited by hippopotamus - 8 years ago
Seher Hone Ko Hai
13