...Jes... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
This question is haunting me for long now. WHY? I am referring to Naina being quiet about the bet issue. I know they had to put this aside to let the story flow but somewhere it is totally injustice with a character like Naina.I agree in Mt. Abu she said to Sameer that she mistook him but she didn't confess that she knew who was the real culprit and that is her own brother. but why? One hand she says she never lies to Sameer, but hiding this truth, this grave truth which not only caused additional fall out with his mother but also could have caused him his whole career. How would CVs ever be able to justify Naina keeping mum about this?

At least for once she should have mentioned the truth. She is adamant on not forgiving Sameer for playing with her emotions, fair enough! But how would she forgive herself for causing a student this much defame and shame? I don't get the explanation by CVs here. NO matter if they show Sameer and Arjun resolving their issue, the harm was done by Naina. Even if now she spouts the truth out in the heat of the moment, it's not applicable. Somewhere CVs have confused the character.

Do share your views guys. I am really blank about any scenario happening honestly.

PS: If anyone is new to this topic, then my question was not if CVs literary forgot this😆 I meant the whole possible angle that could have been created by CVs on the issue which they missed out. In my eyes, Mt ABu was the place where she should have confessed the whole truth, which also would have worked as a great push ffor Sameer to carry on the bet instaed of his growing feelings for her. And then with his mother incident finally he breaking down. If he knew all the truth, not half truth. then this recent tracks would have worked genuinely,not this much drama was needed. Then SamAr bonding also would have looked genuine, but now as he doesn't know the truth somewhere still the issues is hanging but in my eyes this issue should have been taken care of much before. I feel they have not thought of this angle and taking the drama way thinking it would work better. thats it.. Cheers!
Edited by ...Jes... - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

3.2k

Users

26

Likes

234

Frequent Posters

mehraan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Hahaha..Jes i finally c u mke a post on the issue that u hve been harping on the forum.contnously😆...First like to clear that v had discussed this numerous time before but no conclusion ..its the same thing n i think the Cvs hve easily let it go...
I agree on this aspect as this thing isnt goin well with me either...I always thought if seriously there was nvr a bet issue n if Samina were genuinely in luv then...N if Sam cme to know later on that she safeguarded the truth to hid her brother...Would not his trust be broken ? N would he let it go...wud he be tat forgiving? Cos its jus not a small matter but the whole question abt his future,reputation n character...I think he would hve broken up with her,anyone would do!!!!...Right now the situation in the show is as that Cvs have conveniently played this down by dumping him with the full blame as he has placed the bet...so his situation or opinions doesnt matter or even exist cos he is in luv ...🤢..He is a guilty party n so he should forgo the insult that was meted on him cos he broke a gals heart!!! Seriously !!!.Wat about him then ????? So he should suffer in silence n take all the hittings n gaalis at free of cost...🤢

.!In all this i dont like the trust Bashan that is being sunged by Naina...Its called a hypocrisy...Its always said practice what u preach n that too it shud start at home...I had always pinned with the hope that this gal will open her mouth not cos she loved him but cos she was always firm in her righteousness n with strong beliefs,principles ...

For once if this matter comes out...I dnt want Sam to forgive this easily ..i want him to question her about the double standards...n the trust gyaan she often throws here n there!if HIS lie has hurted n broken her ...then that lie would also hve destroyed his life!I t almost severed his ties with his mom n his reputation at school...THANGOD Nanu is a trustee ...otherwise kab ka expelled ho chuka tha ye...!
Edited by mehraan - 7 years ago
Bombaysunshine thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I guess this has been purposely ( hopefully) saved for later date. Maybe one of the catalyst in triggering Naina to forgive Sameer. She has now been acting high handed due to her pain and hurt, maybe when she calms down and introspects this may and should come up as one of the reasons to forgive him or Sameer makes her realise this point that to err is human. Just hopefully. A sure shot character flaw here, but if it's justified later nothing like it.
Edited by Bombaysunshine - 7 years ago
DevyaniRP thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I agree totally! But along with Naina, Arjun should feel sorry as well. Both the siblings have done grave injustice to Sameer. If Sameer has realised his blunder, Naina should also understand the gravity of that situation. Hiding the truth is Supporting the crime! Naina is biased. The entire family father, brother and Naina herself caused lot of harm to Sameer. It is a big reason of origination of the Bet saga! For personal grudges , out of inferiority complex, Rakesh always troubled Sameer! None can tolerate abuses and remarks about family values without any reason. You just can't take anybody for granted, there will be repercussions. So this is must that Naina realise that she has also committed a sin which could have spoiled someone' s life. Sameer was maligned and got negative reputation and got punished for nothing becoz of her. He suffered for the crime someone else had committed. This is really surprising why Naina couldnot hear her conscious when she is in love with Sameer! She was also not blind! Her love may be pure but not selfless! Trust me or not true love, though rare - forgives, true love never want revenge, never curses. B ur she cursed Sameer to live with his guilt. Sameer faked love according to her but she loved him truly na! As a character I find Sameer much stronger than Naina! You will see Sameer, after knowing the truth will forgive Naina!
Edited by DevPK - 7 years ago
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Somehow I still think this is going to come up at a point in the next phase. I have a feeling after Sameer helps Arjun he is going to reveal it by himself to sameer... I think Sameer will help Arjun get back to cricket and finally Arjun will understand sameer good nature. He may realize how much he was influenced by his fathers prejudice about Sameer's status... to me that would be the logical time for Arjun to confess how he gets pressure down by his father to perform and what he did to become headboy.

I also wish Sameer questions then And makes her see a mirror... that act could have destroyed his life, what would Naina do then? Does she not feel guilty at all for letting an innocent person be charged of this crime just so her fathers d brother are safe? Why her double standards? I hope this will make her realize that people are not perfect... grave mistakes happen but one needs to forgive... and hope she also seeks his forgiveness... they can make a fresh start then.
...Jes... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: mehraan

Hahaha..Jes i finally c u mke a post on the issue that u hve been harping on the forum.contnously😆...First like to clear that v had discussed this numerous time before but no conclusion ..its the same thing n i think the Cvs hve easily let it go...

I agree on this aspect as this thing isnt goin well with me either...I always thought if seriously there was nvr a bet issue n if Samina were genuinely in luv then...N if Sam cme to know later on that she safeguarded the truth to hid her brother...Would not his trust be broken ? N would he let it go...wud he be tat forgiving? Cos its jus not a small matter but the whole question abt his future,reputation n character...I think he would hve broken up with her,anyone would do!!!!...Right now the situation in the show is as that Cvs have conveniently played this down by dumping him with the full blame as he has placed the bet...so his situation or opinions doesnt matter or even exist...He is a guilty party n so he should forgo the insult that was meted on him cos he broke a gals heart!!! Seriously !!!.Wat about him then ????? So he should suffer in silence n take all the hittings n gaalis at free of cost...🤢

.!In all this i dont like the trust Bashan that is being sunged by Naina...Its called a hypocrisy...Its always said practice what u preach n that too it shud start at home...I had always pinned with the hope that this will gal will open her mouth not cos she loved him but cos she was always firmed with her righteousness n strong beliefs,principles ...

For once if this matter comes out...I dnt want Sam to forgive this easily ..i want him to question her about the double standards...n the trust gyaan she often throws here n there!if this lie has hurted n broken her ...then that lie would also has destroyed his life!I t almost severed his ties with his mom n his reputation at school...THANGOD Nanu is a trustee ...otherwise kab ka expelled ho chuka tha ye...!

Oh Yes Meher,finally I am out of the trauma that I went through after Monday epi.😭😆 I wanted to make posts but here were already enough good posts,so I indulged in reading instead😆

Oh,I hardly seen any discussion on this, maybe de to me not being regular - yes all the points you said! It is just so not done. I am angry with Naina's character not with Sameer honestly. What Sameer did was wrong, though triggered by Agarwal family only, still he silently takes up the beating and humiliation just for this. but now he needs to retaliate. Enough!

And Naina as a character has many other flaws according to me. When she used to trust that too was blindly and now again she has turned blind. Well,I guess it can be still justified saying the teenage factor, with age she will also mature. Not exactly flaws. but how she hide the truth was a sincere flaw. Yes, the scenario you mentioned if the bet was not there, Sameer should have broken up with her. Even still, when they will be together, I want the same as you said, he needs to question her. He too is betrayed by her but he doesnt know it yet. Thats not done.

Dil todna gunah hai, mann liya.. par kisi ki zindagi barbad karna bhi gunah hi hota hai, that too when you know the truth. Naina ne bhi soch samjah ke thande dimag se uski zindagi barbad kar di.😕(assuming if nanaji was not a trustee) I don't get this double standards. Actually she is way more flawed as a character than Sameer. ANother big problem with her character is that she has a fix role model in chacha ji, this somehow limits her thinking and makes her follow him in every manner. but even chachaa ji has done so many mistakes, specially feeding to Rakesh's ego is the biggest one.
Edited by ...Jes... - 7 years ago
Sakshi607 thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 9th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: aardhan

Somehow I still think this is going to come up at a point in the next phase. I have a feeling after Sameer helps Arjun he is going to reveal it by himself to sameer... I think Sameer will help Arjun get back to cricket and finally Arjun will understand sameer good nature. He may realize how much he was influenced by his fathers prejudice about Sameer's status... to me that would be the logical time for Arjun to confess how he gets pressure down by his father to perform and what he did to become headboy.

I also wish Sameer questions then And makes her see a mirror... that act could have destroyed his life, what would Naina do then? Does she not feel guilty at all for letting an innocent person be charged of this crime just so her fathers d brother are safe? Why her double standards? I hope this will make her realize that people are not perfect... grave mistakes happen but one needs to forgive... and hope she also seeks his forgiveness... they can make a fresh start then.

I completely agree with this. I hope the makers do this. Naina should know that her brother and she herself are also responsible to some extent in sam wanting to take revenge. I dont justify his bet but bro and sis hiding the truth triggered the bet. Naina should be shown the mirror that sameer is wronged by her and she is guilty for this.
...Jes... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Bombaysunshine

I guess this has been purposely ( hopefully) saved for later date. Maybe one of the catalyst in triggering Naina to forgive Sameer. She has now been acting high handed due to her pain and hurt, maybe when she calms down and introspects this may and should come up as one of the reasons or Sameer makes her realise this point. Just hopefully. A sure shot character flaw here, but if it's justified later nothing like it.

I know this will happen later. but what Sameer did with Naina is a totally different aspect, tough provoked by Naina and her family only.but just think if it was not Sameer,what would have happened with the student? Not everyone's grandpa is a trustee, To do right thing, one doesn't need to be in love. what I dont like is how Cvs will counter both mistakes in future and cancel out it. It doesn't go in parallel for me to cancel out. Naina and her family almost destroyed an innocent student's career. Naina has done very wrong and no way it should be dealt this way, She has betrayed him too which caused so much on his family grounds as well. This flaw can never be justified acc to me, she sincerely needs to accept her mistake and realize how some of her ideologies are so wrong, she sounds hypocritical for this.
PritiSC thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
I personally feel CV's have not forgotten this...this will surely come but at right time point when it is badly needed and then Naina will shattered
May be during-

1. When Naina acceptance of Sam back in her life
2. During there marriage

I strongly feel the first one because Arjun will play a major role here to clear the differences between them...but trust me Naina ko bhi ek jhatka chahiye that too before she accept Sam again back in her life

Abhi aise ho raha hai...like usko sab galat hi dikh raha hai...because of one sharth...

Your views please
DevyaniRP thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Another thing strikes me why Naina doesn't realise the truth that Sameer's feeling and apology is genuine. If Sameer had to take revenge, he had to malign her character, he got a golden opportunity when found in her room. It is much bigger achievement than making her tell I LOVE YOU. But he not only saved her from everything, again got punished for no fault. Can't idealistic Naina realise this? Will CVs show anything about it.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".