Naina as a character has many flaws

braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Please a request

Don't start bashing me just by the title and have patience to read through the post as I genuinely wish to analyse the character Naina so far in the show.😊
Hope I can justify the title to this post😊

Disclaimer: these are just my thoughts on her character so far and I still love both Sameer and Naina and i love YUDKBH still😃

So let me start from the beginning😉

Naina is a girl who probably lost her mother when she was too young and her family...mainly her Chacha and Chachi have brought her up. They have never been shown to discriminate amongst their own daughters and Naina... more so I can say that they both have given her the love that she needed from her own parents. They even trust her and support her much more than Preeti👏

Regarding Preeti... she has been a sister cum friend to Naina since childhood much before Swati became her friend (it was mentioned again and again that dus saal ki dosti Naina when Swati was angry with her). So practically Naina's first friend cum sister is Preeti...😃

Now one fine day a boy enters her life whom she likes from the very first looks at him... kind of love at first sight for her which all of us would like to mention that as her crush😛
Never was Sameer interested in her before the bet started but she was head over heels for him... she saved him during the cigarette incident, while actually they were not even friends.😊

Then came the head boy competition in which Sameer was competing with her own brother... she still went and taught Sameer so that he can become the head boy... she in teaching him forgot that this might lead to her brother losing the competition and her father being angry with Arjun... she just thought of her own crush that time.

Then during the key incident...she saw key falling from his pocket and she went and revealed everything without knowing the truth...when it was her father's reputation...which almost led to his expulsion and start of this nonsense bet😳

When later she came to know that he is innocent and real culprit is her brother...she never went and told him or her father that Arjun stole the papers... she should have atleast told Sameer that who is the one who actually stole the papers...at that point her brother was important than Sameer😳

Next incident...Romeo and Juliet play... she was desperate to play Juliet but when she was angry with Sameer for stealing the papers, she withdrew her name and Swati got a chance to be Juliet...But once she came to know about his innocence she tried to play Juliet even without thinking once about Swati who had worked so hard for this role
She again placed her so called love above her friendship.

She never told Swati about her growing friendship with Sameer despite knowing that she too likes Sameer... its only after Swati herself comes to know that she tries to manao her...and then she decides that she wont go to Mt Abu if Swati isn't going... I agree that she was hesitant to tell her but if she really trusted her...she would have told her😳

Swati helped her get a permission for the trip (she is a true friend actually)... but what about Preeti?
She was ready to skip her trip for Swati as she was angry with her for hiding her relation with Sameer...but Preeti...she has been her sister cum friend since childhood....Never did she try to get a permission for her too... she was only happy that she would be getting time to spend with Sameer...( maybe she too wanted that she doesn't go so that she doesn't come to know about Sameer....I might be wrong here and I want to be wrong😊) That again meant that she thought only about her and her time with Sameer while she totally ignored Preeti once again.😔

In Mt Abu also...she brought Sameer inside their room without even thinking once about Swati and her reputation...do you as a friend don't have the responsibility to take care of your best friend's respect and reputation? Sorry I don't take such an act from anyone...whatever blind love you are into... a girl's self respect is the most important😃

After coming from Mt Abu...Preeti has been on the recieving end of all her anger and tantrums...she is in a shocked state...agreed...but being in a heartbroken state and anger doesn't provide you the right to hurt your loved ones... what was preeti's fault in this?
If you are really angry with someone...go to him and give him a thappad and vent out your anger on him... the people who love you dearly... they are worried and you should think once about them😊

She bashed Preeti with words like...teri fenki hui sorry...and all that... she should have gone to her and atleast given her a hug...maybe that helped her as well...her anger could have been calmed down with the love of her sister

So for me I feel that Naina as a character is the one who always keeps her thoughts, wishes and opinions above everyone else... we all have been saying that she is much mature as compared to Sameer...but while I was contemplating after the episode yday...I realised that everytime she has behaved as if she and only she herself that matters to her... no one else... not even one incident where she kept anyone except Sameer above her own self😳

P.S. Sorry for the long post😳

Edited by braveheartdoc - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

98

Views

7.5k

Users

38

Likes

271

Frequent Posters

braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Along with this I also wish to say that all of us have our own flaws and we need to accept our relationships along with one's flaws and thats what love is all about😃
No human being is perfect in this world and this post isn't intended to hurt anyone's sentiments... its just to bring out the various instances where she placed herself above everyone else😊
Anmol333 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Awesome post 👏
Very good analysis 👏

I'll say one thing about teaching Sameer for exam, she was in dilemma what to do ? In that her ChaChaji helped her by saying she should teach Sameer and it's upto him how he learn from her. She had thought of it.

And about going mt. Abu without Preeti was something where she ignored her, how much Preeti was excited to go.

And I'll say Naina many times put Sameer above everything, and think about herself only many times.
sweet_tehs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
You have pointed out all points which are very valid...
I agree with on this..
U just brought out in words but the pointers u gave had me thinking about those whenever those tracks were up..

I haven't seen yesterday's episode yet but I'm sad to know she mistreated preeti in this manner..

Yes I agree the way Preeti has always been there for Naina it has not been the same the other way round...
Especially the permission for the trip never once did she try for Preeti the way she brought up the topic so many times for herself.


braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Anmol333

Awesome post 👏

Very good analysis 👏

I'll say one thing about teaching Sameer for exam, she was in dilemma what to do ? In that her ChaChaji helped her by saying she should teach Sameer and it's upto him how he learn from her. She had thought of it.

And about going mt. Abu without Preeti was something where she ignored her, how much Preeti was excited to go.

And I'll say Naina many times put Sameer above everything, and think about herself only many times.


@red...she as a sister should never have such a dilemma... she knew her brother since the time she remembers herself... but Sameer... kitne din huye the use school mein aaye huye😕

@blue...Sameer also was placed above everything only when she was happy with him... that means indirectly she thought of herself only na... because uske liye Sameer uska pyaar hai and wo uske liye sab kuchh karti hai...to baaki sab jo usse pyar karte hain... unke baare mein nahi socha na...😔
braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sweet_tehs

You have pointed out all points which are very valid...

I agree with on this..
U just brought out in words but the pointers u gave had me thinking about those whenever those tracks were up..

I haven't seen yesterday's episode yet but I'm sad to know she mistreated preeti in this manner..

Yes I agree the way Preeti has always been there for Naina it has not been the same the other way round...
Especially the permission for the trip never once did she try for Preeti the way she brought up the topic so many times for herself.



Thanks a lot Tehseen...I'm so happy to see you agreeing to me... i have always loved Naina as being a mature girl...but yday i went into the show so far and these are what came to my mind... thats why i made this post... we never gotta see an incident when she has helped Preeti or Swati...the way they have helped her😳
TereLiyeMINU thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
A very good critical analysis 👏 True! Naina has placed her self vested interests above other relationships.But somewhere I find that this is what is real.Many teenagers just think of them,their love and their world together.Family and friends are ignored till the relationship gets through a rocky phase.Not that they cut off from family but they remain present physically only.And about Preeti at receiving end of Naina's anger and frustration,I 100% relate to it.My cousin sis had a terrible break up and she just was in such fury and rage,she behaved in the weirdest way.My family could not understand why she had suddenly become so irritated and frustrated and all her vexations came over me.It was tough time handling her but then that's what siblings are for.If Preeti would have known about Sameer's affair it would have been much easier for Naina to find a shoulder to cry upon. Good job dear 👏
braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sweet_tehs

Hello girls how r u both?


I'm good Tehseen😃
How about you?
spate22 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
I agree she is a little selfish but aren't all teenagers selfish ?!! They don't think about their actions!! I think it's pretty normal!!


Shreya
sweet_tehs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: braveheartdoc


I'm good Tehseen😃
How about you?


All good..
U wake up so early and make a post here too😆😉


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".