Daredevil's advocate and Avni/Neil and AvNeil's wellwisher - Page 3

Naj, I feel the basis in which the whole track is built is little shaky. and Neil does come across as "being at fault". As for your reasoning of why Neil not telling her I have my reservations. But, I personally don't want to delve into who's right or who's wrong !! because like someone else mentioned here, the tracks in which both were together were even more stupid! I could hardly watch all those episodes. But right now this looks interesting! So if we could stop over analyzing and move on we can maybe enjoy the story forward!!! This whole Neil is wrong, Neil is right will be a one-two day thing. Tomorrow people will enjoy their tashanbazi and forget all about it! Me too!!!

Keeping aside the fact that who is right and who is wrong, I enjoyed the episode thoroughly and I can sense that coming episodes are also going to be exciting. In the previous track AvNeil were together but still I couldn't connect to it but in this track although AvNeil are separated, I find it more appealing.

Everybody cannot be right every time and that is what makes a story. Again it will be too early to judge Neil's action because we are yet to see what he did or didn't do for Avni in those six months and what is his opinion about what Avni has become in these six months. Over analysing the positive characters in a negative way will only spoil the mood of the story

Originally posted by: ILTHBEB

I maybe was truly waiting for your post today on regarding of neil as whole forum almost has been against neil's action in this tract. Very welly penned down.👍🏼

Few days ago there disagreement comments were exchanged between you n me in your post. Yes I was one of them who criticized n sometimes bashed neil left right n centre in juhi track as I felt his characterization was completely shown wrong way showing his exaggerated impulsiveness for juhi,blindly faith on her,no actions against her where he had scope to do many things. But frankly I feel old Neil Khanna has back in this track. I completely understand his helplessness . Vidyut's shrewd trap n the system of law have closed his every door of rescuing Avni. Yes he one matter has done that he never did its for the 1st time he has hidden his plan from avni. I think he intentionally does it that has been made avni fully rock in emotionally. N as his own punishment he has taken avni's deep misunderstanding ,distrust on him. I agree he could share his plan with her but cvs basically wanted a genuine separation between them not any show off separation like previous that's why no co operation of avni's in neil's plan this time. It's a new journey of avneil like prior post leap. Neil converted her once from ananya verma into avni khanna n same he has now made her ananya verma n in near future same neil will again convert her into avni khanna. This is the based of avneil's journey. They will start their journey once again newly as ananya n neo. Previous ananya was mysterious person to neil but this time neo will be mysterious person to ananya.

Many times neil's actions I felt wrong but the matter I never felt that neil never underestimated ananya verma n her qualities. He always impressed on her intelligence but only opposed her destructive avatar. It's also wrong that he never wants ananya verma. If ananya verma didn't touch his heart he would not enable to be neo.

I don't think it's ever a who's right who's wrong discussion. We love avni, we love Neil some of us prefer avni more, some Neil more, but all of us love their pairing. The actors playing them have done a great job. We all hated chuhi. All this overanalyzing is either because we really hate the track like with chuhi or it's because we have to kill time till the next episode! Also I really believe that very often when I lose hope with the show something nice someone says on the forum either give s me hope to bear the track or better, some forum ideas ends up happening on the show to salvage it. So that's my purpose to start or participate in discussions!

@Everyone

Yes I feel this time CVs wanted a genuine separation between AvNeil and though my post (as usual) comes as Neil's defense which in part is true, I maintain that I love Avni and I feel for her the most. My point was that if we can accept Avni with all her flaws and baggage, why are we not doing the same with Neil. Because if we go by intentions, both their intentions were good, even when their actions had strong consequences, so if we can understand one, why not the other. If u see clearly I never use any demeaning words for either of the two characters because for me both are wonderful people despite their flaws, and if people think I'm not with Avni and I'm more with Neil, then check whether I ever joined in any conversation against Avni, knowing well that a week ago she was criticized heavily even by people who were ardently supporting her, but I didn't post anything then despite having my reservations about the way she behaved and its consequences because I understood it was her past and her feelings taking over, the girl has been through so much, the scars left by the past are hard to erase, add to that her attachment to Mishti in whom she sees herself, Avni was an emotional wreck after the accident, she was completely transported to her childhood reliving it with the same pain and intensity and nothing is much more impactful than the experiences we live in childhood.

And my post wasn't to point out who is wrong and who is right, I said that each one of them took their decisions based on many factors (some are rational and some are emotional, ok add to that some from CVs to create drama), I just said why can't people see them as a unit, do dil ek jaan.

For this track to play this way and with this intensity or for some time, this was probably the only way, let's check the options : 1- If Neil mistrusted her and arrested her (which was going anyways to happen by him or by some other person -people ignored he was going to give his resignation-as in the show it was shown all evidence is against her, as I said logic wise I can't say, there must definitely be loopholes evidence wise) people would have hated him and said he doesn't know Avni and he never really trusted her etc 2- If he shared his plan with her, people would have found it repetitive and boring as it's yet another fake separation 2- If he was shown super intelligent and found clues, there wouldn't have been any track and Vidyut would have been sent behind bars or he would have run away and less scope for intensity or anything else rather another mission catch me if u can of Vidyut with no changing in AvNeil's dynamics!

So bottom line if u want to know why I always post from Neil's side of the story it's mainly because he is the one who usually faces the heat no matter how a track plays out, but when I do that I do it with full love for Avni and fully undertsanding Avni's side of the story but when I read some posts about Neil, I feel they are done ignoring his side of the story and considering only Avni's, now honestly u tell me if he is hypocrite, Naakabil, MCP, berehem and not a true lover, then why would anyone watch him or love AvNeil, these are enough reasons to stop watching and I did it for other shows when I felt hero was not hero!

Anyways drama wise and track wise, I think show is interesting and has scope for entertaining us and that's mainly what we look for : entertainment. Rest, it's just a show!

@Ashi_Naksh

Thank you😊

I feel Neil knew very well what was coming his way from Avni, when they were in the bedroom post she dozed off, he said that after what he will do, she will hate him, so he definitely knew she will feel bad and hurt and won't understand him

Yes what he did could go both ways, he should have thought of that, but I feel Neil somehow did it more to gain time and keep her under control for a while, he saw glimpses of the destructive/self destructive Ananya Varma so just to keep her under control and protect her from Vidyut till he gets evidence and gets his full focus on her only, he opted for this option. Let's see how efficient it would prove, I'm sure Avni/Ananya will give him surprises but then he is also Neo so..

I think this is another learning experience for both AvNeil, I for one want Avni to come stronger from this experience, I know it's hard given her misconceptions but had she developped the same ability as Neil towards the soulmate to see beyond the facade, that would have been wonderful, but I admit it's not easy given her past experiences, she has been betrayed by her loved ones many times (her dadi, her dad, her brother..!!) and once bitten twice shy. I want her to understand that when someone hides things from u, it hurts, I want her to put love above impulse. I want Neil to understand that yes at times people resort to harsh ways but at times things can backfire, so the person should be prepared to face the consequences.