NAIDL (Season1) VS Laado2 (Season2)

811134 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
This is a long post. Thanks in advance for your patience. Do share your views, please.

The only Indian serial I ever watched continuously was Na Aana Iss des laado. Because there has not been a single Indian Drama that reached up to that level of quality and standard. Even though Balika Vadhu too was based on a social issue but it was slow and had some similar features to those of saas-bahu and kitchen politics Dramas. NAIDL had pace and action. Everyone loved the villain Ammaji. Even at last (Late night) slot of 10:30 PM, it used to be at the top of TRP chart. After it ended, Colors might have realized its value and craze and brought it back as Laado - Veerpur ki Mardani. Everyone who had seen NAIDL got excited to see the same action and Ammaji. I was one of them but till now I have been disappointed by Laado2. From last one month, they are just teasing for things to happen in future but nothing substantial has happened (apart from Jhanvi's death). Channel/Production want to recreate the magic of NAIDL but they are failing on so many levels to understand what actually was Na Aana Iss Des Laado and how it was presented. I have compared both these seasons (Though I don't consider them as seasons) on the basis of some factors :

Ammaji: The most beautifully written powerful character on Indian television is without any doubt that of Ammaji. Meghna Malik played this character with shear brilliance. Surely most TV actors/actresses must have been ashamed of their work after seeing Meghna Malik playing Ammaji. She set an example. She was the reason people watched NAIDL. That's why when Laado 2 came, everyone got excited because of Ammaji in it. But creative team has not done justice with this character this time. They have made the character weak and are not showing any actual action by this character even after so many days. But still due to Meghna Malik's brilliant acting skills, only thing shining in Laado2 till date is Ammaji.I hope in future, creatives and writers use the power of this character properly. In short I want my old Ammaji back.

Pace: Things happened at lightening speed in NAIDL. They did not show that it would happen this week and that week. They used to show the unexpected with such a fast pace that you did not get bored. But in Laado2 they are just teasing that something will happen this week that other will happen that week. But in the end, they are showing nothing. Though it's pace is faster than other serials but not as great as that of NAIDL. Also, I don't understand why Colors spoil the whole episode before starting the episode by telling what is going to happen in it.
Music: Background music was the beauty of NAIDL. From the title song to Ammaji's background music, everything was epic. In Laado2, producers/creatives have ruined this beauty. Ammaji's BG music is good but not that much epic like that in NAIDL.

Cast: I never saw such a great cast in any other serial as that in NAIDL. There were so many top-notch actors like Meghna Malik (Ammaji), Sonal Jha (Sheela Chachi), Anand Goradia (Gajendra), Tarun Anand (Joginder),Madhurjit Sarghi (Santosh), Harish Verma (Avtar), Aman Verma (Bhanu Pratap), Sheeba Chadha (Bajri), Kannan Arunachalam (Dharmveer Chacha ). Though Meghna malik shined most with brilliant acting skills and brilliantly written character. Every character had importance and was given proper screentime. That also created the craze for watching Ammaji because she was not shown frequently. But in Laado2 apart from Meghna Malik, Dakssh Ajit Singh, Gulfam Khan and Shaleen Malhotra (to some extent), I don't see any good actor being brought in. Every other actor looks so B-grade. Rituraj's acting as Balwant looks so forced and character description does not fit his physical appearance. Avika does not seem to have learned much from her experience but she is still young and has a long way to go. So overall Laado2 disappointed us with the casting. Keeping more characters/Actors from NAIDL may have helped to increase the interest.

Storyline: In NAIDL they had already shown Ammaji turning into a positive person. Also, Ammaji had granddaughters (more than 20 years old.One of them died). She had other family members too.But in Laado 2 they have just assumed that portion of her life when she was negative and ignored that fact that she already had a family. No other family member is shown. This looks weird. But as Ammaji's fans, we are fine with that as long as they entertain us with Ammaji's action.

Costumes: See the episodes of NAIDL and you can clearly see the Haryanvi attire of all the characters perfectly fits the setup. But it looks weird in Laado2. Their choice of colorful clothes (at least the dupatta) for Ammaji does not look as classic as that in NAIDL.

Camera Visuals: In NAIDL it was a delight to see any dramatic scene with such nice camera angles and directions. Visuals used to be so much poetic. That made NAIDL stand out of the crowd.

To understand what I am talking about in the whole post, see the full video below (Especially the title song) from Na Aana Iss des Laado: When fights were fought with swords and entries were made while riding the horse😊:

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6wn4TfB3G8[/YOUTUBE]

Edited by naidlaado-3 - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.4k

Users

9

Likes

34

Frequent Posters

ck1234 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: naidlaado-3


Cast: I never saw such a great cast in any other serial as that in NAIDL. There were so many top-notch actors like Meghna Malik (Ammaji), Sonal Jha (Sheela Chachi), Anand Goradia (Gajendra), Tarun Anand (Joginder),Madhurjit Sarghi (Santosh), Harish Verma (Avtar), Aman Verma (Bhanu Pratap), Sheeba Chadha (Bajri), Kannan Arunachalam (Dharmveer Chacha ). Though Meghna malik shined most with brilliant acting skills and brilliantly written character. Every character had importance and was given proper screentime. That also created the craze for watching Ammaji because she was not shown frequently. But in Laado2 apart from Meghna Malik, Dakssh Ajit Singh, Gulfam Khan and Shaleen Malhotra (to some extent), I don't see any good actor being brought in. Every other actor looks so B-grade. Rituraj's acting as Balwant looks so forced and character description does not fit his physical appearance. Avika does not seem to have learned much from her experience but she is still young and has a long way to go. So overall Laado2 disappointed us with the casting. Keeping more characters/Actors from NAIDL may have helped to increase the interest.



totally disagree with this part... all the cast of season 2 is good... they all are established actors & popular too... Avika & Shaleen jodi have nice chemistry... Meghna malik as usual superb... the actress playing shaleen's sister is so cute... 😃
HarryAustralia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Laddo 2 is extremely superb n doing good too n all the cast absolutely comes into the frame really well
Avika and shaleen chemistry just fire wohooo we love the way season 2 is going
By the way it's hard to make everyone happy on the earth
And makers know very well how to get the things done
ruhi1985sheetal thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Agreed ck1234 and Harry Australia we can't make everyone happy and about star cast Avika Shaleen her sis every character gud in rheit place in first season ammaji negative we can't compare from season 1 ammaji in season 1 already powerful lots of goons and villagers scared from her and in this season she left her power 20 years back and take time to become powerful from last time this time no support nothing and here in last season siya main lead her age is more then avika here Avika playing role of 20 21 age girls and I think girls behave like t his how she acting in this show and I think u didn't know in past on both shows she got lots of apprications and Shaleen more powerful actor then Aditya redzee from first season
Edited by ruhi1985sheetal - 7 years ago
811134 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Your replies indicate that you have not properly followed NAIDL. Someone who has seen it from start to end can understand the gravity of what I have written.
I think what I wrote in braces after Shaleen name has hurt you guys. Sorry for that. And I agree that he is better actor than Aditya redij and that is why I included his name & not Aditya's. But look closely every scene to know why I wrote what I wrote in braces. He is improving day by day and this is his first regular daily soap.
And cuteness has to do nothing with acting skills.
Rituraj is a good actor as compared to most others but he does not fit in this role. Watch Ammaji from season 1 and Balwant from this season . See how she played a villain's role and how he is playing. I am not saying that they have to play similarly because roles are different. But meghna Portrayal of a villain was more believable than Rituraj's portrayal.
And I don't know which other established actors are you talking about. One does not become established by doing more amount of work but becomes by doing quality work.
For Avika, I analyzed her acting skills by considering the amount of time she has been in this Industry. Her portrayal of Anandi was good.She got appreciation for that because of good acting at that young age. Sorry I don't think her SSK role was that much noteworthy. In Laado may be the creatives are not utilizing her skills properly.
You guys have mentioned about chemistry but I have not compared it anywhere because chemistry has been good in both seasons.
No doubt Laado2 is way better than all other shows currently airing.But you guys have been naive to ignore the fact that I have done this analysis by comparison with NAIDL.
I hope that in future makers improve in all the departments I have mentioned. By doing that atleast they can make most of us' happy if not everyone'.
suhanakkt thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
I dont know why compared both season and actor .1st season was definitely great but most of the ammaji's son was villain .even main lead raghav was also behaving with siya like a villain their marriage life was not a happy and he sometimes even just stand when ammaji and her son was humiliated her.it took long time to made raghav positive provably thats why trp was high as trp aunty always like to see siya was humiliated by her sasural.
Season 2 is different time has been changed so story is also different with positive ammaji.actually she turned positive on S1 but with same and some new cast and here totally new genaration so definitely will be new cast.show just has been started it will take time .about casting i dont think they have poor casting i agree with some member as they mention shaleen is more powerful actor then S1 male lead.for me rituraj was doing great i dont found anything seems forced.
About avika i thing she is doing good job and i believe she will give more powerful performance if her character sketch written strong.

S1 when started all of the actor wasn't really that much great but by the time they did great.S1 also took a leap after raghav siya die they had lot of new genaration and those also criticized by fan .
I agreed S1 BG was really great but i will say give it more time and be patience and it will be great if we dont compared both season because each season has different story to tell.

811134 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: suhanakkt

I dont know why compared both season and actor .1st season was definitely great but most of the ammaji's son was villain .even main lead raghav was also behaving with siya like a villain their marriage life was not a happy and he sometimes even just stand when ammaji and her son was humiliated her.it took long time to made raghav positive provably thats why trp was high as trp aunty always like to see siya was humiliated by her sasural.

Season 2 is different time has been changed so story is also different with positive ammaji.actually she turned positive on S1 but with same and some new cast and here totally new genaration so definitely will be new cast.show just has been started it will take time .about casting i dont think they have poor casting i agree with some member as they mention shaleen is more powerful actor then S1 male lead.for me rituraj was doing great i dont found anything seems forced.
About avika i thing she is doing good job and i believe she will give more powerful performance if her character sketch written strong.

S1 when started all of the actor wasn't really that much great but by the time they did great.S1 also took a leap after raghav siya die they had lot of new genaration and those also criticized by fan .
I agreed S1 BG was really great but i will say give it more time and be patience and it will be great if we dont compared both season because each season has different story to tell.



See my last reply. We replied at the same time.
Atleast you agree to some aspects in your last para.
suhanakkt thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: naidlaado-3



See my last reply. We replied at the same time.
Atleast you agree to some aspects in your last para.


I do agreed some aspects but as i said just wait and see what this season want to tell us .
I think meghna malik is really a great performers then even villain thats why u feel that way .
This is also great opportunity for avika also because in ssk her character was simple but here is different and strong so now everything is on cvs and directors hand lets see how will they use her talent.
suhanakkt thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: naidlaado-3



See my last reply. We replied at the same time.
Atleast you agree to some aspects in your last para.

lovesick23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Honestly about pace I would like to say that this one month was just a buildup into what is going to happen in the future. In the previous season they were showing what amaji already did to girls in her village but here they are making space for what she is going to do for the girls. So I bet the pace will improve as the story moves forward. About actors I find avika lacking maybe because she is crying half the times and doing reckless stuff the other times. Between two very mature people (ammaji and yuvraj) her character looks immature! Otherwise others I find satisfactory and honestly not everyone can act like meghnaji so maybe not putting her as a barometer might help!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".