NAIDL (Season1) VS Laado2 (Season2) - Page 2

My 2 cents

1. Yes the pace is a bit slow, I would hope it puicks up a bit as the show will need to keep up our interest . It seems the adverts are far too long and each day we have about 2-3 scenes and then episode ends

2. Characterisation is a bit patchy & illogical - in fact glaringly so. Nothing to do with the acting, just the script & story.
- eg I cannot believe that a girl from Delhi could think its safe to wander around any city, town or village alone at midnight. The CVs need to make this plausible at the moment it is interfering with my appreciation. This is no comment on Avika - she's doing a good job as far as the role has been drawn. I can feel her pain for her sister and for the unknown girl who was humiliated but it just does not make sense - any normal girl nowadays will know it is unsafe to roam alone at midnight. No matter how idealistic she may be, she has seen the tragic end of her sister and the other events, how can the character not have any common sense - or is it just to feed the public a few romantic lollipop scenes? then Y tells her this is not yr Delhi its Veerpurr...as if Delhi is safe
- How is it possible that Yuvraj who is such a sensible mature sort of person has no clue what is going on around him? In all these years does he not know the nature of these people? Seems implausible.
Also if his family is ruling Veerpur they would be expected to able to curb any lawlessness of this sort. If they do not, it implies they are either part of it or much weaker than they pretend.

3. Compared to the original NAIDL the story is a bit thin. There is one topic (Jhanvi) and not yet enough variations around the theme or depth. The focus is a bit more on drama than substance.
Maybe its because they are stretching the story too much at this time with long ad breaks and short scenes.

Originally posted by: velvetscarf

My 2 cents

1. Yes the pace is a bit slow, I would hope it puicks up a bit as the show will need to keep up our interest . It seems the adverts are far too long and each day we have about 2-3 scenes and then episode ends

2. Characterisation is a bit patchy & illogical - in fact glaringly so. Nothing to do with the acting, just the script & story.
- eg I cannot believe that a girl from Delhi could think its safe to wander around any city, town or village alone at midnight. The CVs need to make this plausible at the moment it is interfering with my appreciation. This is no comment on Avika - she's doing a good job as far as the role has been drawn. I can feel her pain for her sister and for the unknown girl who was humiliated but it just does not make sense - any normal girl nowadays will know it is unsafe to roam alone at midnight. No matter how idealistic she may be, she has seen the tragic end of her sister and the other events, how can the character not have any common sense - or is it just to feed the public a few romantic lollipop scenes? then Y tells her this is not yr Delhi its Veerpurr...as if Delhi is safe
- How is it possible that Yuvraj who is such a sensible mature sort of person has no clue what is going on around him? In all these years does he not know the nature of these people? Seems implausible.
Also if his family is ruling Veerpur they would be expected to able to curb any lawlessness of this sort. If they do not, it implies they are either part of it or much weaker than they pretend.

3. Compared to the original NAIDL the story is a bit thin. There is one topic (Jhanvi) and not yet enough variations around the theme or depth. The focus is a bit more on drama than substance.
Maybe its because they are stretching the story too much at this time with long ad breaks and short scenes.

Yes I agree with you. Most implausible thing happened was when Yuvraj asked Jhanvi to run instead of he himself facing them. On other occasions he never hesitate to stop the criminals.

Originally posted by: velvetscarf

My 2 cents

1. Yes the pace is a bit slow, I would hope it puicks up a bit as the show will need to keep up our interest . It seems the adverts are far too long and each day we have about 2-3 scenes and then episode ends

2. Characterisation is a bit patchy & illogical - in fact glaringly so. Nothing to do with the acting, just the script & story.
- eg I cannot believe that a girl from Delhi could think its safe to wander around any city, town or village alone at midnight. The CVs need to make this plausible at the moment it is interfering with my appreciation. This is no comment on Avika - she's doing a good job as far as the role has been drawn. I can feel her pain for her sister and for the unknown girl who was humiliated but it just does not make sense - any normal girl nowadays will know it is unsafe to roam alone at midnight. No matter how idealistic she may be, she has seen the tragic end of her sister and the other events, how can the character not have any common sense - or is it just to feed the public a few romantic lollipop scenes? then Y tells her this is not yr Delhi its Veerpurr...as if Delhi is safe
- How is it possible that Yuvraj who is such a sensible mature sort of person has no clue what is going on around him? In all these years does he not know the nature of these people? Seems implausible.
Also if his family is ruling Veerpur they would be expected to able to curb any lawlessness of this sort. If they do not, it implies they are either part of it or much weaker than they pretend.

3. Compared to the original NAIDL the story is a bit thin. There is one topic (Jhanvi) and not yet enough variations around the theme or depth. The focus is a bit more on drama than substance.
Maybe its because they are stretching the story too much at this time with long ad breaks and short scenes.

that's y I told Avika is awesome actress and she is doing great job cvs not utilize her character that's y she look little weak if cvs give powerful scene to her then she act like that

Yeah! Many things are implausible in this season.. What is putting me off is lacklustre Haryanvi which the characters are speaking. Dialogue writer must be changed. I remember Raghuvir Shekhawat wrote dialogues for first season.Barring Meghna , who is Haryanvi, none is speaking good Haryanvi.. There is no rustic feel even in village settings. Rituraj is not pulling that rustic feudal Haryanvi effectively. Only Preeti Khare & Daksh are OK in that family.

Originally posted by: Sweet_Krishna

Yeah! Many things are implausible in this season.. What is putting me off is lacklustre Haryanvi which the characters are speaking. Dialogue writer must be changed. I remember Raghuvir Shekhawat wrote dialogues for first season.Barring Meghna , who is Haryanvi, none is speaking good Haryanvi.. There is no rustic feel even in village settings. Rituraj is not pulling that rustic feudal Haryanvi effectively. Only Preeti Khare & Daksh are OK in that family.

I am watching show only for Meghana Malik. Only she is the USP & strength of this season 2.

Atleast there are some people who agree to what I wrote.
I also observed their weird haryanvi accent but forgot to compare it in my anallysis. I wonder how can writers, directors make such silly mistakes. Atleast they must watch season 1 and see how perfectly each character spoke haryanvi.

Pls guys let them do their work every character in season 2 doing great it'll take time to get familiar with story n characteristics I haven't watched season 1 but I can say here the aura n time has changed totally n I do understand ur convo on it but pls be with a show ,, I'm not defending anyone only I wanna say that it's very easy breezy to leave our comments or suggestions about show or cast !!!!but it takes really gusts n lots of hard work to perform !!!!' We r here on this forums to enjoy the group convo so be with it ,,,,,Thanks n sorry if I hurt
anyone

Originally posted by: HarryAustralia

Pls guys let them do their work every character in season 2 doing great it'll take time to get familiar with story n characteristics I haven't watched season 1 but I can say here the aura n time has changed totally n I do understand ur convo on it but pls be with a show ,, I'm not defending anyone only I wanna say that it's very easy breezy to leave our comments or suggestions about show or cast !!!!but it takes really gusts n lots of hard work to perform !!!!' We r here on this forums to enjoy the group convo so be with it ,,,,,Thanks n sorry if I hurt
anyone

No one is stopping them from doing their work. You need to watch season 1 to understand this post. And as I mentioned previously too that Laado 2 is best among all other shows currently airing. But when compared to Na aana Iss Des Laado, it has lot of flaws. So this is just a comparison post as the subject indicates.

Plz tell me Anushka an janyvi both r Rasiya's (Raghav an Siya) child ?

Originally posted by: Krilovad

Plz tell me Anushka an janyvi both r Rasiya's (Raghav an Siya) child ?

Coz NAIDL Rasiya's 2 child an they r girl child ... so i think .

i was NAIDL 1 watch not watch 2 part .. now i watch .

I don't think they are Rasiya's daughters. Or may in this season they might show that they are their daughters. But in season 1 their daughters were Diya and Jhanvi.Diya died and Jhanvi took Ammaji's position and Ammaji's avtar to resolve all the social issues. Even Ammaji was shown as positive character in the end.
But here they have assumed that Ammaji was negative all the time when she lived in Veerpur previously. So I think this season is just a desperate attempt to revive the magic of NAIDL with no connection to season 1's plot except Ammaji's character.