Why were the Malfoys forgiven??? - Page 3

NOOO!!!! I really mean it.... 😳

U r very good at explaining and convincing people Lakshmi....... 😳

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Just because someone likes a person, does it mean that he's becoming good???? I mean yes, its alright that u want draco to be happy, and he deserves to be happy coz he's good. but what about lucias and narcissa??? Maybe u like them too, but does that mean they are becoming good?😉

One doesn't have to like a character just 'cause they're good.
I like Voldemort and I think everyone would attest that Voldy darling was definitely not good. That's why I said personally.
I would never call them good because they were anything but, IMO.

What I want for them and what I think they deserve are two different things. I have already explained the reasons why the Malfoys did not go to Azkaban and they deserved to. Draco at least deserved to get some community service if nothing else.

Originally posted by: Mit's113

NOOO!!!! I really mean it.... 😳

U r very good at explaining and convincing people Lakshmi....... 😳

thanks yaar...I am glad I made my point clear..Its anyway interesting to see what others think..when ur view is challenged U get the tendency to ask urself abt the stuff and its a test of how strongly rooted ur point is in u...Helps u develop on ur views...😊

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Sorry, but i disagree. U are trying to say, that since there it is no chapter called "Lucias' tale", it means that he might have become good. But i disagree. If, it is nowhere written in the book that he became good (if there is no Lucias' tale) then who are u to say that Lucias became good???

U are trying to say that snape was also a deatheater and so was lucias, then why i only want lucias punished. then when i said that snape regretted what he did, u told that lucias might also have regretted what he did if there is only a lucias' tale chapter. BUT UNFORTUNATELY THERE ISNT ANY!!! and if there isnt any thing in the book written about lucias becoming or regreting, then how can u say that he really regreted, when J.K.R herself didnt write it????😕

I am no one to predict anything...
Acc To Chaos theory(Lolz Bringing science into this!😆) anyways...acc to this theory one cannot predict ANYTHING at all...
If I cant say that bcoz there is no other chapter concerning Lucius, it means he becums good, u too cannot say that he didn't change...
It cannot be just One way....

as for Lucius' Tale..OK Drop It...I mentioned That only to point out that Unlike Severus, we don't know really for certain what he went hru...
but there are various indications(not which one can quote) but which u can find if u read thru the lines that there is a Possibility that the Malfoys could be at the threshold of Redemption..

N I repeat..This is my PERSONAL view..I am not imposing my view on any one else...U are free to think the way u want to...U may feel he is really evil n all and I dont say U ARE WRONG..I only say I for one don't believe so...To each his own...

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm...... .........................may be u'r right....
Actually since we dont know that whether the malfoys became good or not, we cannot say anything at all about them being punished or not. 😛 😊

Exactly!!! Labib.

As we don't know what they did later, so, we have to take JKR,s word as to the fact that the Malfoys became good......😳

^^^true...lets stretch our imagination whichever way we want to...n it cums down to the same thing...that we dunno for certain nyway! 😊

Originally posted by: Mit's113

Hello!!! everyone....😳

(The Malfoys were not taken to Azkaban: according to JKR's interview)

i was just wandering that why were the Malfoys forgiven???😕

Why were they not taken to Azkaban???

Draco was very bad but still he was young and not as bad as a Death Eater....he was forced to become aDeath Eater by Voldemort...so, Draco could be forgiven....even Narcissa could could be forgiven because she helped Harry out of the Forbidden Forest(although it was to find for Draco in the Castle)....BUT Lucius was a EVIL and a VERY BAD Death Eater.... so, why was he not sent to Azkaban????

I my opinion, he should have sent to Azkaban....😕

What do u all think???😉

Because they are sneaky slimy _______________ (word not meant for underage children)😆😆😆

They wormed their way out of trouble :-p and told about how Narcissa lied to the Dark Lord about Harry not being alive after Harry survives the Avada Kedavra yet again in the Forbidden Forest!

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm...... .........................may be u'r right....
Actually since we dont know that whether the malfoys became good or not, we cannot say anything at all about them being punished or not. 😛 😊

I don't thin they became good....that would be like saying Voldemort's wearing swimsuits and rollicking on the beach and singing "It's a beautiful day...."🤣🤣

The Malfoys remained as they were....I'm certain coz it would be too much character manipulation to make them become saints or something...but I think they did tone down their pure blood mania one or two notches because JKR said something about it on Scorpius Malfoy being a better person than his father.

Malfoys were not evil, b/c they had some remorse in them ji. The whole thing JK portrayed as evil was those who carried no remorse, ie, Voldy. Evil is too strong a term for Malfoys, b/c they were cowards. Evil and good/bravery are words that are too strong to be attached to a person by their deeds b/c most deeds were done from favors to fear.

Malfoy did serve in the prision for a bit, and after that he may of felt of some sort of remorse ji. If it was not him, then Draco may have changed him for the 'better'. In HBP, at the end when Draco is to kill Dumbly 😭, she made it clear how Draco did not want to kill. He was bad in words, but in actions he was only afraid. Even in the last book, he actually showed some compassion to Goyle and Crabbe. When Draco finally saw Voldy at his power, he realized that he didnt like this. They did believe in the pure blood thing, but were tired of all the fear.

I agree at least Malfoy should have been punished in some way. I don't agree Narcy was selfish ji, b/c as far as I yaad, she asks Harry about Draco, and then he tells her. If she was selfish na, she should have told Voldy that Harry was alive after she got her info. But she didn't ji, she may have felt remorse. I think she wanted Voldy to die, and that is where her selfishness lay. She was tired of Voldy dominating her life.

Out of the three, only Lucius was bad to the core ji. But bad and evil are two different things. Evil is what Voldy and Belly were. They did not care what happened to anyone, even those who followed him blindly, and even if it was her husband/family. Lucius did care what happened to his family ji, and he was bad to the core.

Anywayz, I made no sense I think ji. Haye, Harry Potter...........lol

hey waz up wid bhoomi?y is she banned? 😕