If kal ho na ho song was made today, would it be a hit or a flop??

So was listening to haareya, ik vaari aa and gerua on my iPhone and then kal ho na ho started playing. It is such a Different genre to the other two that was just wondering that if it was made today for say a Shahrukh movie like JHMS would it have been a hit song or would it have disappeared into oblivion??

it would be hit because its only bollywood song beyond any boundries it is still fresh now and it would be rememberd till bollywood exist but other tradiotnal love songs like chote chote raaten lambi hojate hain would have been flop as today youth listen to fast yay kind of music only

Originally posted by: iambest

it would be hit because its only bollywood song beyond any boundries it is still fresh now and it would be rememberd till bollywood exist but other tradiotnal love songs like chote chote raaten lambi hojate hain would have been flop as today youth listen to fast yay kind of music only

True it's transcendental. But my personal opinion is it wouldn't have worked for this generation

It'd have been a hit for sure!! Melody is timeless :)

It would have been a hit! It still makes me cry!😭 SRK was so ahmazing as Aman. <3

Would have been a sure shot hit even today. Awesome lyrics, good music, great rendition..what else does one want?

It's one of my favorite songs! ❤️

i think a huge hit, blockbuster even, movies like kal ho na ho r not made these days, its a movie that has everything, comedy, romance, drama all in perfect proportions, plus a great star cast and wonderful music

Originally posted by: Angel-likeDevil

It'd have been a hit for sure!! Melody is timeless :)

..but not a hit with me, because I don't like songs that make me sad

I guess.. but khnh isn't really a sad song, is it?? More of a life song I suppose.. 😉

Originally posted by: Serendipity..

It would have been a hit! It still makes me cry!😭SRK was so ahmazing as Aman. <3

Yes one of the best roles of SRK. Miss SRK in those roles. Whenever KKHH comes on tv and that line comes - dance? No music Wala scene.. my heart always skips a beat. Why the hell movies like those don't get made??

Originally posted by: MithiBani

Would have been a sure shot hit even today. Awesome lyrics, good music, great rendition..what else does one want?

It's one of my favorite songs! ❤️

Mine too ❤️
The best song ever in terms of being simple yet so effective. And what lyrics - kudos to Javed Akhtar Saab!