If kal ho na ho song was made today, would it be a hit or a flop?? - Page 4

Yes because the words and composition is good... not taking away any credit from sonu and Shankar ehsaan loy..

This song is transcendental song!
It's My fav song of this movie! ❤️

Yeah.. It would have been a hit today also!

It would be a Massive hit!

Originally posted by: chahat4u

Just because today's youth likes easily forgetful melodies and voices. Doesn't mean everyone have same taste. Kal ho na ho is transcendental. Good melody, meaningful lyrics, deep and emotional, melodious voice. And yes, songs like Gerua and all are good, but superficial. But kal ho na ho is better, deep, and certainly not sad. Its about hope and how to live in present, live each moment to the fullest. Not how to be sad...live happily each moment, so much that when change occurs it leaves good memories behind and not regret.

Verdict: Hit for sure.

Agree 👏

I didn't ask about this song coz I'm a big fan of Sonu. Truth is sonu plays a very small role in making the song iconic. It's not a very difficult song to sing and certainly not a song which requires a lot of vocal prowess. It's a simple song with a deep and profound message with a simple tune. But the simplicity of the song is what wins hearts. You don't get to hear such simple songs now a days. That's why I thought of making this post. I'm glad most people feel the same as I do and like this song even today

Originally posted by: shal1983

Agree 👏

I didn't ask about this song coz I'm a big fan of Sonu. Truth is sonu plays a very small role in making the song iconic. It's not a very difficult song to sing and certainly not a song which requires a lot of vocal prowess. It's a simple song with a deep and profound message with a simple tune. But the simplicity of the song is what wins hearts. You don't get to hear such simple songs now a days. That's why I thought of making this post. I'm glad most people feel the same as I do and like this song even today

With that said sonu nigam has enhanced several songs and made them worth listening to...

Songs like what is your mobile number, tumse milke deka (main ho na) suraj howa matham (k3g) and saathiya(saathiya) zoobi dhoobi (3 idiots)

Originally posted by: shal1983

Agree 👏

I didn't ask about this song coz I'm a big fan of Sonu. Truth is sonu plays a very small role in making the song iconic. It's not a very difficult song to sing and certainly not a song which requires a lot of vocal prowess. It's a simple song with a deep and profound message with a simple tune. But the simplicity of the song is what wins hearts. You don't get to hear such simple songs now a days. That's why I thought of making this post. I'm glad most people feel the same as I do and like this song even today

^^^^ you are comparing arijit live performances with sonu live performances. No comparison there. Because arijit is off tune in many places. There is no one who can be compared to sonu when he sings live. But in a recording studio arijit also wood have done a good job I feel. Maybe not as good as Sonu but I love arijits rendition of Phir le aya dil. Kya emotions diye hai! Agree nowadays arijit songs very monotonous. But I feel it's the directors fault jo har song ko ek hi tarah gawate hain.