Is It Fair Or Unfair ?? - Page 2

It is unfair to an extent as the format of this show does not allow for much training since it is 11days non-stop thus Sumeet does the have added advantage of prior experience but they are all celebrities so should be acquainted with learning fast and performing. However, win or lose all the celebrities will benefit from the exposure of participating in a reality tv show. The show is like a simplified, short cut version of Jhoom India. Moreover, reality tv shows tend to bend the rules regarding a uniform standard of participants and judging as even NB3 allowed trained dancers to participate to let the show go on when it's original concept was to promote married celebrity couples who were non-dancers. The main purpose of the show is publicity for the channel so we should merely enjoy the show and trust the public to vote for the best.

Originally posted by: pardesi-mem

It is unfair to an extent as the format of this show does not allow for much training since it is 11days non-stop thus Sumeet does the have added advantage of prior experience but they are all celebrities so should be acquainted with learning fast and performing. However, win or lose all the celebrities will benefit from the exposure of participating in a reality tv show. The show is like a simplified, short cut version of Jhoom India. Moreover, reality tv shows tend to bend the rules regarding a uniform standard of participants and judging as even NB3 allowed trained dancers to participate to let the show go on when it's original concept was to promote married celebrity couples who were non-dancers. The main purpose of the show is publicity for the channel so we should merely enjoy the show and trust the public to vote for the best.

But in just 11 days what Public can decide😕😆..I agree its all about publicity😛...but the selection procedure for these Celebrity reality shows should hv some specific criteria😊..

Now Sumeet will keep getting full 10 in all the episodes and will reach the top two aaram se and others will hv to compete with a trained singer😃

Agreed... trained singer will have a little edge over the others... but the makers should think about it while selecting the contestants... it's not any of the contestants fault if he or she is trained... also when these actors sign for the show... they sort of agree to compete with rest of the contestants... so if Aman chooses to complain later... it holds no value according to me...

And about participating in other similar show.... no I don't agree... by that rule everybody should participate in any contest only once 😕 ... and if you win or are a runner-up in that then you can not participate in a similar contest again 😕

And if I remember correctly... I read somewhere long time back that even Apurva is taking training in singing... but I am not sure...

Originally posted by: purva

Agreed... trained singer will have a little edge over the others... but the makers should think about it while selecting the contestants... it's not any of the contestants fault if he or she is trained... also when these actors sign for the show... they sort of agree to compete with rest of the contestants... so if Aman chooses to complain later... it holds no value according to me...

And about participating in other similar show.... no I don't agree... by that rule everybody should participate in any contest only once 😕 ... and if you win or are a runner-up in that then you can not participate in a similar contest again 😕

And if I remember correctly... I read somewhere long time back that even Apurva is taking training in singing... but I am not sure...

really? woww, I was never aware of that.

hmm,
interesting questions arise and i enjoy u guys comments,focussing things on different prospects.
jyoti,u claim that it's not fair that a person who is more trained gets more points and spoils hard work of others,which is not fair.
let me tell u something, JUSTICE is a big word and i dont think anyone can do full justice anyway.if there is a fault,then it's not participants fault,as they signed the contract and came for competetion. yet,if you believe in fault then it could be SYSTEM'S FAULT.THE SYSTEM WHICH GIVES RIGHT TO ANY KICKED OUT CONTESTANT TO PROTECT ONE HE WANTS DESPITE OF ANY REASON OR FACT.LET US NOT FORGET THE MAIN AIM OF PROGRAM IS TO GIVE PUBLICITY TO CHANNEL.I THINK THAT OBJECTIVE IS FULFILLED AS PEOPLE LIKE U AND ME AND OTHERS R DISCUSSING WAT IS HAPPENING IS RIGHT OR WRONG.PEOPLE START WATCHING DRAMA ON COMPETETION,DISCUSS ISSUES,DISCUSS WAT IS FAIR AND WATS NOT...........Y (BECOZ WINNER WILL NOT GET ANY RECOGNIZED WORLD CLASS RECORD OF PERFECT SINGER).IT'S JUST FOR FUN AND ENTERTAINMENT AND PUBLICITY,THATS Y THEY KEEP RULES LIKE THIS. THEY WANT PEOPLE TO ARGUE AND IF THEY PLAY FAIR,THEN PEOPLE WONT DISCUSS ANYTHING OR THEY WOULDNT HAVE STORIES TO DISCUSS!!!
have u watched WWE wrestling and see how ppl cheat referees and 3,4 people beating some1 and the one who deserves winning looses. dont u think the referees dont know wats going on.it's all part of making ppl discuss and argue.like u have got a point jyoti to argue and make stories. in the end channel is benefiting.
i would say something for JUSTICE. in any singing contest show like sa re ga ma OR INDIAN IDOL. voting is not justice...and we have seen people became discriminated by supporting people from their states and countries, which is not FAIR becoz of voting some1 who deserves fails and the one who doesnt deserves SUCCEEDS.IT'S A PROFESSIONAL SINGING COMPETETION,but still NOT FAIR. and definition of fair means that all the participants having same background and same opportunities and exactly same amount of training from same professional peoples go in a SAME competetion. but thats not it, U NEVER WOULD SEE THAT HAPPENING.SO IN REALITY THERE IS NO JUSTICE. CHANNEL WANT MORE PUBLICITY AND WANT MORE ADS SO IT CAN EARN MORE.SIMPLE AS THAT.IN EXAMS SOME STUDENTS GET CHANCE TO CHEAT AND PASS AND SOME WORK HARD BUT DIDNT GET A CHANCE TO CHEAT AND FAILS WITH 1 MARK DIFFERENCE. IF THEY GOT THE SAME CHANCE,THEY WOULD HAVE CHEATED AND GOT 1 MARK.U C, NO JUSTICE.BUT THATS HOW LIFE IS.SO IT IS BETTER THAT U DONT TALK ABOUT FAIRNESS AND JUSTICE, BECOZ FRANKLY SPEAKING REAL 100%FAIRNESS AND JUSTICE DOESNOT OR VERY RARELY EXIST.

That was a wonderful analysis Syed..I m truely Speechless 👏 👏 😳

I agree with you Reality shows r just a means of earning money and trps ...u can't never expect Justice or Fair Results in such shows 😃

Sumeet was asked to participate because the channel knew that his participation can create controversies and jealousy among other untrained Singer participatns which can result in high trps for the channel 😉 ..So nothing is fair and unfair in such game shows and so lets just enjoy it ...irrespective of whatever mayb the the outcome 😉 😆 😃

thanx jyoti for giving such wonderful comments to me.........i'm just blushed. 😳 😳
meiney tu sirf apne dil ki sunii or keh dea and u know dil tu pagal hei. 😆