Meghna is interfering in Naina's life - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

2.6k

Users

11

Likes

86

Frequent Posters

malikakas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: sgc68


I am glad that Vishal was professional and maintained patient confidentiality. The only person who should have shared this information with Sharda is Naina. I also feel that Vishal thinks Karan's condition is curable and therefore is working with Naina on this.


The problem with patient confidentiality is that there is then a conflict with Vishal's role as brother. As an aside, this is why doctors shouldn't treat family members to begin with because conflicts of interest do arise. But initially Vishal was consulted as a brother who happened to be a doctor. He was never Karan's doctor.


The fact that he chose to uphold doctor-patient relationship is fine but that also means that Meghna can't be expected to fully trust that Vishal would do right by Naina. By not opening this issue earlier.. he already hasn't done right by her. He may not push Naina to leave Karan because that may be unhealthy for Karan etc.


If Vishal knows that Karan's condition is curable but he hasn't yet related that to Meghna... then how can we expect Meghna to buy into the logic of Vishal's choice?


The problem with Vishal, in this scenario, is that he's not written as a real person.. but more as a plot device. His choices aren't a result of logic or personal characteristics but purely based on what's needed for the plot. Which unfortunately makes the show less interesting.
Edited by malikakas - 8 years ago
malikakas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: adhyakumarijha

Well would like to add one point gone are tge days when meghna was the reason of naina being in the marriage in naina s own words "jab sr hogayi tab se yeh shaadi uski shaadi thi" and naina didn't told meghna because she knew about her di s reaction she knew that meghna will not listen to anyone or understand anything she will even not consider the fact that now naina is happy with karan and he means a lot to her naina is not in this marriage because of meghna so yes meghna should over this "my guilt my fault" mode and look things from naina s perspective she is happy with karan

Love or no love but one thig that naina is very sure from thr beginning that she is happy with karan

And that is what matters about love thing nairan can handle it by themselves

But Naina wasn't happy in the beginning and even then she didn't reveal it. So how can you trust Naina when she is saying she is "happy" now? Naina specifically told Meghna.. that she didn't reveal it because she didn't want it to affect Meghnal's relationship. I honestly wish she hadn't said that because after that I can't see how Meghna is going to get over the guilt.


Maybe Naina is not lying to Meghna now about being happy but she could be deluding herself in order to keep the peace just to find a way to survive? As an extreme example, there are cases of stockholm syndrome where kidnapped victims fall in love with their captor and they actually resist attempts at rescue. I am not saying that is happening here. But my point is just because someone is saying something in a pressured scenario doesn't mean its accurate or healthy. But when you remove them from the situation they may realize they were getting caught up in something that didn't make a lot of sense or for the wrong reasons. Karan's a really nice guy.. Naina may feel a lot of guilt for feeling like she wasn't happy.


The way Naina asked God for her to decide.. I don't think Naina had truly made up her mind about what she wanted to do about the marriage. I think initially she wanted that relationship as refection of her mother's swabhiman. She didn't reveal Karan's hostile attitude because she didn't want it to affect the peace. So even when she found about his illness, disturbing the peace was never an option. I don't think she thought too much about it and just plunged in to see how she could help him. They got close during all that but I don't think she considered what their long term future was. But I think now she has to. Continuing in a limbo relationship like that is not healthy for either of them.


Leaving NaiRan to figure out the love thing doesn't make a lot of sense to me... because you don't need to be married to enjoy a friend's company. If NaiRan got divorced, they could still spend time together. But she would also have the chance at a normal life. If she's not in love with Karan, then its actually a win-win.

Edited by malikakas - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".