Award war gets ugly - Sonam's BFF Swara tweets

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

1044164

Suspended

Posted: 9 years ago

#81

Originally posted by: NightReader

Giant black rose! Seriously, i really want to know what she was trying to show through the slit? Such an awkward mess

Her iconic fashion sense.😉😆

Quote

Enycedoll

@Enycedoll

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#82

Originally posted by: pathaka
Okay...first of all to those saying neerja was carried on sonam's shoulders, let's clear the air...it was carried on Neerja's shoulders...she was the national hero people went to see and support...she was the one who's story people were interested in...she was the one people connected to...strictly speaking as a film...neerja could have been much better but people didn't care because Neerja's personality and aura eclipsed everything...
It's a case similar to the dhoni movi...sushanth didn't get the audience into the theatres, dhoni did...even if the film wasn't great...it did well because of the dhoni factor...(sushanth is a much better actor than sonam of course, but that's a different discussion)

When you make a film on a famous personality who is loved by everyone, it is bound to do well...sonam's biggest achievement was not ruining the movie...but no she didn't carry the film on her shoulders...shabanas performance and Neerja's heroic deed was what most people took away from the film...sonam Was good by her standards, which is nowhere near the best.

Coming to aalia, she was fab in udta Punjab. Best actress isn't someone who plays the sole protagonist in the film but someone who gives a good performance and makes a mark..even if the film has 2 other strong protagonists.

Your logic is somewhat flawed. You are discounting the appeal an actor has in pulling the audience to the theatre. It's through an actors performance that the audience is able to connect to the character being played on screen. Sonam playing Neerja had everyones attention from the start because it was a familiar character to the people, the fact she played it well helped the movie succeed.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

pathaka

@pathaka

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 9 years ago

#83

^^i would disagree...people went into the theatre fully aware of the story, who Neerja was, what she did and what she had been through...they were well and truly prepared to empathise and admire her character in the film...now same with Shabana's character...ofcourse people were prepared to empathise with Neerja's mother...the situation and the event itself greatly helped the actors connect with the audience since they have known the characters even before they saw the film...

But Sonam's triumph as an actor was "not being terrible" when people expected the worst out of her...Shabana's triumph was actually delivering the goods and ripping people's hearts out when people already expected her to be good anyways...that I think differentiates the good performance from the one that "didn't completely fail" ...both had characters that the audience was fully ready to empathise with but shabana managed to actually connect it to the people with her performance...sonam merely didn't make people cringe like with her previous performances...

Anyways...you are entitled to your opinion...btw..I love reading your posts...always very well thought out and articulate...

Edited by pathaka - 9 years ago

Quote

Don't worry, be happy.

@Ranbirrocks

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#84

If Sonam and Sallu get FF and Ranbir gets NA Toh forum will become a peaceful place. Let's all pray that these things happen 😆

Quote

.Iconoclast.

@.Iconoclast.

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#85

Keeping my bias aside (I despise Sonam's offscreen personality), they could've awarded Sonam too like the debut award. Sonam was good in Neerja. Alia was already awarded some new soch thing so why one more? Everyone knows these awards are based on popularity and connections still they want 'em. Even the ones who refuse to go; collect them later.

I don't think Rishi Kapoor deserves the award. Rajat Kapoor was much better. Even the guy who played Sonam's dad in Neerja.

Quote

Sabina

@Guguminti

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#86

Originally posted by: pathaka
Okay...first of all to those saying neerja was carried on sonam's shoulders, let's clear the air...it was carried on Neerja's shoulders...she was the national hero people went to see and support...she was the one who's story people were interested in...she was the one people connected to...strictly speaking as a film...neerja could have been much better but people didn't care because Neerja's personality and aura eclipsed everything...
It's a case similar to the dhoni movi...sushanth didn't get the audience into the theatres, dhoni did...even if the film wasn't great...it did well because of the dhoni factor...(sushanth is a much better actor than sonam of course, but that's a different discussion)

When you make a film on a famous personality who is loved by everyone, it is bound to do well...sonam's biggest achievement was not ruining the movie...but no she didn't carry the film on her shoulders...shabanas performance and Neerja's heroic deed was what most people took away from the film...sonam Was good by her standards, which is nowhere near the best.

Coming to aalia, she was fab in udta Punjab. Best actress isn't someone who plays the sole protagonist in the film but someone who gives a good performance and makes a mark..even if the film has 2 other strong protagonists.

Word 👏

Quote

1 ... 5 6 7 8 9

Award war gets ugly - Sonam's BFF Swara tweets - Page 9

Related Topics

Explore Topics