A conventional Daya/Dinah and non conformist Avni!

Apple_Amber thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1


Hello Friends!
How are you doing?
Liking the pace of Naamkaran! 😊

At an outset don't get perplexed about the name Dinah of the title! Its just my imaginary name for the Muslim Dayavanti of past who had to change her religion/or her mother had to due to riots and to hide illegitimacy of her being as termed by the sick society.What i actually want to charter is the choice of alternatives for selfhood and self actualisation from Dayawanti era to Avni/Asha.

Now she knows it all about Asha Avni and Aashish. What will be her decision and why? As we know Neela will get married to Ashish, but why wud Daya do that? To take revenge from society? Sadist pleasure?To make Avni undergo the same punishment like she underwent as a kid/youth? ''Niyam sabke liye ek hai''! Does that mean Avni too has to face the same mess as Daya did after losing her parents? Where is her younger brother? Was he killed by the Hindus/Muslims? Am still confused she was a Hindu or a muslim? If she is taking revenge from Asha that means she was a Hindu!

We have seen the enraged hurt Dayawanti while thinkin of her childhood! Seems as a kid she was same as Avni, but she had to compromise, and then she married some Gujrati man for ''Naamkaran''! Could anyone clear my doubt for whose Naamkaran she had to change her identity? To hide that she is an illegitimate child? Or to hide that her child Ashish was an illegitimate child of some muslim lover of hers who dumped her under some pressure or was a spineless character? May be the riot people burnt her parents alive as theirs might be an illegitimate relationship or was an inter cast wedding?

Am perplexed about the scene in yesterday's episode, the neighbouring friend of Asha, seems she cant conceive, am scared for Asha's baby! Will the lady take Asha's baby with some twist? Hope it doe snot happen!

In the precap they showed Ashish tells Asha that his mom knows it all.Is it some plot by Dayawanti ? Sure it is! The The lady is gonna sacrifice her child to pay off the debts of Hemant bhai and Ashish will follow her to pay off his share of dues to hsi mom! May be Dayawanti will strike a plan to make Ashish hate Asha? May be she will be ready to adopt Avni but not Asha (as part of some evil trick to create rift between Ashish and Asha) Asha will never give Avni to Ashish and Neela or she should not. There might be a small track about it happening under Asha's fear for Avni's future, but endgame will be Asha Avni! as the show is about Naamkaran and it wont glorify patriarchy!

Avni/Asha will get scared initially to face the brave new world after Ashish leaving them, but lateR they will live life at their own terms. Asha wont get married like Dayawanti did, she would rather give Avni her own name.Isn't AVNI enough?

What will Asha do for her livelihood? Will she keep depending on Ashish for her living? I think she will start acting! And of course we will get to see Asha working in Ashish directed film but wont care anymore about him emotionally! Ashish will start getting inspired again 😆and neela wud get jealous! 😆😆

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

1k

Users

2

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

anonee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I am unable to follow your logic because your premise is imaginary. This is because you write:
At an outset don't get perplexed about the name Dinah of the title! Its just my imaginary name for the Muslim Dayavanti of past who had to change her religion/or her mother had to due to riots and to hide illegitimacy of her being as termed by the sick society.What i actually want to charter is the choice of alternatives for selfhood and self actualisation from Dayawanti era to Avni/Asha.


Apple_Amber thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Anonee, the premise is imaginary because its yet to unfold in the serial what went wrong with Dayawanti? What she had to suffer? Was she a muslim like Asha and became Hindu after wedding?

Something is common between Asha and Dayawanti or Avni and Dayawanti and we are yet to know whats that! May be Dayawanti too had to struggle for her 'naamkaran' and she succumbed to society with HEMANT'S help but Asha will play it differently!

Hope it makes sense now! I prepared this post based on the spoilers about Dayawanti's past.There was a buzz that she will try to create problems for Avni!
anonee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Apple_Amber

Anonee, the premise is imaginary because its yet to unfold in the serial what went wrong with Dayawanti? What she had to suffer? Was she a muslim like Asha and became Hindu after wedding?

Something is common between Asha and Dayawanti or Avni and Dayawanti and we are yet to know whats that! May be Dayawanti too had to struggle for her 'naamkaran' and she succumbed to society with HEMANT'S help but Asha will play it differently!

Hope it makes sense now! I prepared this post based on the spoilers about Dayawanti's past.There was a buzz that she will try to create problems for Avni!


Thank you for the clarification!

I think Dayaben was a victim of riots and her house and all her possessions were burnt by muslim extremists! This made her a young, penniless widow with one infant, one toddler and a 6 year old Ashish. They lived by the roadside - until Hemant Bhai came by and offered them shelter!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".