Your opinion for this week's show - Page 4

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

I completely agree 😳 He was so so good on the show... Very genuine and yet so cute 😳😳😳

The highlights of the day (after Amir Khan 😳) were Anamika, Smita, Tanmay and Vibhore... 👏

I am getting an increasing feeling in every episode that Vasundhara gets more praises than what she deserves from the judges... I think the judges need to be more objective and need to judge all the kids just on the basis of their singing ONLY!

bravo jaya for voicing this👏...just shield urself from the (possible) brickbats 😉...i agree with u totally,had been feeling this for sometime too,but didn't voice it coz there are numerous Vasundhara diehards here 😆...Vasundhara is good,no doubt,but is she all that she is made out to be...i have my doubts.....

.As for the performances..Aamir (khan)was of course,the show stealer...👏.....I thought the best performance of the day was Anamika,followed by Tanmay👏.....Didn't like Smita's performance..song sung fully in falsetto,becoz of that she cldn't bring the fun elemnt well enuf in the song(just my opinion 😳)........Vibhore went off sur a li'l too often for me to enjoy the song fully.Rohanpreet.....again pitching problem,but good in parts...Aamir was good,song needed more feel and notes shld have been sustained better with more continuity and clarity in certain places.good nevertheless ..... Rohit.....excellent in parts,but not upto the mark in other parts......cld have done the mukhda a li'l better and put a li' more soul in the antara...still,very well rendered,considering that(i thought)..it was the most difficlt song sung of the evening.

just my 2 cents

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

She is a good singer. When she is supposed to get 95% she is given 99%. Vasundhara needs to sing Shreya Ghosal type songs next and prove to us the versatility if she needs to win this competition.

But I do not agree with you when you say Vibhore sang better. If you listen carefully you will see when Vibhore sings lower tone his sur become "kachcha". He needs to improve that area a lot more. He is very good when goes towards high tone. I hope he does not get eliminated in the round even. Please do not beat me up for this.

agree wth u on both points....well said 👏

If Vasundhara was not supposed to be no. 1 then who was supposed to be no. 1 and who was near to perfect in the chosen song on friday????? With everything, the song choice also plays a role(Tanmay is the most witty regarding this; he chooses those songs which can make an impact and those songs which he can carry off well) and the accuracy of singing..Sonu always gives importance to accuracy more than anything else. On Saturday, that was the reason why he told Vasundhara that she would have got a B+ if that day's performance was to be judged. It was not that Vasundhara sang bad on Saturday, but it sounded quite different from the original because of the difference in the style in which it was rendered. I don't think there was any bias in judgement for top 3. She deserved it. I agree it was an easy song but then to capture the mood of the song, to make an impact is what matters finally..Tell me any of you if you can, was there any flaw in her singing? but if you ask about anyone else's singing on that day, there were surely flaws(more than one). Did Vibhore deserved no.1 as someone said? Vibhore's voice has that kachappan, anyone can easily make out..What I've observed is that most of the time his singing lacks the finishing touch.
And why is the sympathy issue brought again and again??? Someone told vasundhara cried when she got less marks. It is not that she deliberately does that, it is because she is so much used to getting praises and being in the top 3 that a single negative remark is like a blow to her whereas others have been getting odd remarks, so they have become used to. And she didn't cry whenever she got less marks, she only cried once when it was the first time there were negative comments and that too, it was from both Sonu and Suresh ji.
I really feel pity for those people who think Vasundhara is being favored for her disability. If Vasundhara was not blind then also I would say that she deserves to be in top 3 in this competition more than anyone else. She and Aamir are the most matured singers of the lot.

Friday's epi was a LOT of fun! :) I enjoyed all the Bappida songs lol Too bad Bappida was missing and Sonu had to fill in hahaha! 😃

Saturday's episode was a lot of fun too! I LOVED the part where Sonu showed his school dairy to Aamir. It was such an enjoyable part of the episode.

Overall, I always look forward to Tanmay's performance. He is such a CUTIE!! :) Always cracks me up with something he does or says lol
Then Vibhore, Vasundra and Aamir.
Another reason I like watching these episodes is because of the judges. They are such a HUGE (read trillion times) improvement to the nautankis we had last time :)

Originally posted by: Rohan-1981

You are so flat wrong. Tanmay deserved to be No.1 on Friday but Sonu Nigam just sacrifised him for Vasundhara. This is an open secret. She is getting undue favour from the judges and I m sure she will get the undue supoort from from public too the way Divakar got. So plz. dont tell us she is the best. Anamika & Smita are better than her in girls & off course Tanmay & Vibhor are also better than her. Let me admit that she is lucky. I bet you she will cry again to get the sympathy vote if she gets the negative commnets from the judges. She didnt cried on Sat. because she was not being judges that day. Very claver kid for sure.

Now that is very assuming and unfair. Please don't make such a sweeping judgment of a child's character!
Vasundhara is a darn good singer. Her tayyari is excellent, she does need to work on her sur.
I personally thought that Vibhore sang well on Friday and deserved to be in top 3 just for that performance. But he lacks tayyari in general and does have to work on his kharaj notes. Even Rohanpreet was totally out of sur on Saturday(Mitwa song) and I was taken aback at the the A+s he got. I think Amir Hafeez was way better than Rohanpreet on Saturday.

Originally posted by: Rohan-1981

I was also taken a back when Vasundhara was declared # 1 insted of Tanmay. In the last 8 contestants she could hardly be 6 or 7. This is my judgement. Others can always differ from me.

Moreover, didnt she blackmailed SW for the marks? When he asked her how can they stop her from crying she replied by giving her good grades? Now you judge her character. Was not this black mailing? or you give me the anather word for this act.

the grades they give on board are different from what they give on paper... judges give them the A+ just to make them feel better and their final verdict is never 'black-mailed'....i'm sure they make mistakes in giving marks like they did last time w/ rohanpreet and aamir(on saturday's episode)...but i dont think the black mailing has ever worked on their judgement.