Is this a JOKE? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.5k

Users

6

Likes

108

Frequent Posters

J-chan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: luvakanksha

Yeah and the best situation would have been swara faking a stomach ache, Sanskar taking her to hospital then, at last swara revealing sanskar that u know I had no ache I was faking it and swasan having a good laugh. 😆

Had it been stomach ache, they would have called the doctor home, no?😆
BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: luvakanksha

Yeah and the best situation would have been swara faking a stomach ache, Sanskar taking her to hospital then, at last swara revealing sanskar that u know I had no ache I was faking it and swasan having a good laugh. 😆


I know right!! That would have been perfect. 😆 😆 😆

Sanskaar would have been like "Waah Mrs Maheshwari, aap toh kaafi achi acting kar lete ho"😆 😆 😆
BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: J-chan

Had it been stomach ache, they would have called the doctor home, no?😆


If she is acting for stomach ache, she can just act to fall unconscious 😆 😆
Ho gaya!! She can go to hospital. You dont know? SR has different rules for hospital. 😆 😆 Ragini with the stab wound didn't even stay in hospital for more than 1 hour 😆 😆 😆 And Swara goes to the hospital with this and stays over night 😆 😆 😆 Do you see any logic? 😆 😆 😆
Edited by .IamShonali. - 9 years ago
DivineDarkness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
Well not that I'm supporting self harming but situation kind of demanded that.. Swara had to injure herself so she could stay in hospital over night so faking stomach pain or headache won't help. And she saw how person who had heart attack and person who was stabbed were denied hospital. So she had to take extreme step and she know her husband really well she knew he will make sure she stays in hospital.. Well Swara for one harms herself than harming others. Cv's tried to show that quality of Swara esp when they are planning the upcoming poison and slap dramas. This was also to show difference between sisters.
BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: DivineDarkness

Well not that I'm supporting self harming but situation kind of demanded that.. Swara had to injure herself so she could stay in hospital over night so faking stomach pain or headache won't help. And she saw how person who had heart attack and person who was stabbed were denied hospital. So she had to take extreme step and she know her husband really well she knew he will make sure she stays in hospital.. Well Swara for one harms herself than harming others. Cv's tried to show that quality of Swara esp when they are planning the upcoming poison and slap dramas. This was also to show difference between sisters.


Leki, I understand Swara's reasons completely. And I get what she did and why she did it. I also understand the time crunch part coz she wanted to catch the nurse as soon as possible coz there were chances that nurse might have disappeared if dadi would have interfered and warned the nurse. So I completely get the situation. And I really respect Swara for her unconditional nature towards her family. She will do anything.

But I still dont think this extreme step was required. Maybe I am being too emotional or over thinking about this. But I dont think it was a right thing to show. Yes, Swara doesn't believe in fakeness and so would definitely not fake anything just to gain sympathy. But in dire times like this, she has chosen to lie about stuff like her fake marriage with Sanskaar. Maybe stomach ache is not major thing. But there has to be other way. Directly cutting wrist.

And with Sanskaar, He will understand her definitely coz he knows his Swara more than anything. He might get mad at her for harming herself like this, but it is still for her and he cannot stay angry at her for more than 1 min. So I get it.

And yes, the difference between the two sisters has been coming out very nicely since this track started. Like Ragini will chose to fake pregnancy, but if it was Swara, Swara would have openly fought and challenged the samaj to save the child, with risking her life like this. And even she was getting blackmailed or Pari had some secret of her (which is not possible but just a scenario) Swara would have made sure Pari is saved and not let her die like Ragini did just because Pari had some secret of her. And even with the slap or poison which I already mentioned about in my post, Swara would rather chose to have the poison herself then give it to the family. So the difference is coming out very well.

I just felt cutting wrist was little too much. There could be some other way they would have shown it. But its already shown. There is nothing I can do about it other than saying that they could have executed this particular thing a different way
Edited by .IamShonali. - 9 years ago
DivineDarkness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: .IamShonali.


Leki, I understand Swara's reasons completely. And I get what she did and why she did it. I also understand the time crunch part coz she wanted to catch the nurse as soon as possible coz there were chances that nurse might have disappeared if dadi would have interfered and warned the nurse. So I completely get the situation. And I really respect Swara for her unconditional nature towards her family. She will do anything.

But I still dont think this extreme step was required. Maybe I am being too emotional or over thinking about this. But I dont think it was a right thing to show. Yes, Swara doesn't believe in fakeness and so would definitely not fake anything just to gain sympathy. But in dire times like this, she has chosen to lie about stuff like her fake marriage with Sanskaar. Maybe stomach ache is not major thing. But there has to be other way. Directly cutting wrist.

And with Sanskaar, He will understand her definitely coz he knows his Swara more than anything. He might get mad at her for harming herself like this, but it is still for her and he cannot stay angry at her for more than 1 min. So I get it.

And yes, the difference between the two sisters has been coming out very nicely since this track started. Like Ragini will chose to fake pregnancy, but if it was Swara, Swara would have openly fought and challenged the samaj to save the child, with risking her life like this. And even she was getting blackmailed or Pari had some secret of her (which is not possible but just a scenario) Swara would have made sure Pari is saved and not let her die like Ragini did just because Pari had some secret of her. And even with the slap or poison which I already mentioned about in my post, Swara would rather chose to have the poison herself then give it to the family. So the difference is coming out very well.

I just felt cutting wrist was little too much. There could be some other way they would have shown it. But its already shown. There is nothing I can do about it other than saying that they could have executed this particular thing a different way


Swara could have easily faked stomach pain or headache but the point is she wanted to stay in hospital over night. Take the case she could have taken something she is allergic to and could have got admitted in hospital for food allergy but then that will physically strain her and she won't be able to search that nurse. And she defo can't know to what extent her body will react. by cutting her wrist she did it such a way that it don't harm her much but do create a situation which allows her to find out what's happening.. yes she did harm herself which no way I'm supporting or agreeing but I do understand why she took this step.. Wrong it was no doubt about that but not surprising either.
BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: DivineDarkness


Swara could have easily faked stomach pain or headache but the point is she wanted to stay in hospital over night. Take the case she could have taken something she is allergic to and could have got admitted in hospital for food allergy but then that will physically strain her and she won't be able to search that nurse. And she defo can't know to what extent her body will react. by cutting her wrist she did it such a way that it don't harm her much but do create a situation which allows her to find out what's happening.. yes she did harm herself which no way I'm supporting or agreeing but I do understand why she took this step.. Wrong it was no doubt about that but not surprising either.



I understand you dont support the self harm issue and I am glad you agree to it like I do.
If there are what if, then there can also be a what if scenario of what would have happened if Swara would have misjudged the pressure and she would cut it deep? Its just a what if scenario like you gave for allergy. Swara isn't trained enough to know how much pressure one should apply. Yah I know I am talking about logic and logic doesn't exist in this show anywhere. But it was just a scenario I wanted to bring in. I am not saying I dont understand her or I want to bash her or saying she is out of her character. Thats not my stand. My only stand was, the step she took was way too extreme. There had to be some other way. Maybe sprain your leg? Maybe some other health condition that requires you to stay. If cvs can manipulate the stab victim to stay home right after the operation and be great the other day, I am sure it would have been very easy for CVs to manipulate a health condition and show her in the hospital then show this.
sumeetadeb thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#28
@shonali.totally agree with u promoting self harming is not good.also i agree with u there is more way to execute the plan of going to hospital.even cvs can try to show that swaras hand was cut badly not wrist.the impact will be the same. even self harming or suicide is promote in earlier time also.ragini was tried to do suicide two times even under the influence of ragini laksh also harmed himself.though evrey time situation was differen.i am never like the idea suicide. ps.meaning of love nd swasan is same for me

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".