Does hatred from rival fandom affect an actor's movie??

Eggon_Snow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Wondering about this cause even Rishi K openly blamed Salman fans on twitter for sabotaging RK's films and several people here also contend that that RK's movies are unsuccessful cause he is hated by Salman, DP and now Katty fandom too. But if that was the case should not have other actors also suffered from the same plight?? Especially SRK and Salman who have the most bitter fandom wars or even Deepika who is loathed by almost every female actor's fans??
Isn't blaming a minuscule online fandom for failure of movies in a way shirking away from the responsibilty of bad script selection?? Or do you think fandoms are that powerful to make a hated actor's movie flop??


Edited by gatheringstorm - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.2k

Users

16

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail

Comedy Crew

Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Bakwaas!
No matter how much people 'hate/dislike' certain actors and actresses, at the end of the day,all depends on the trailer, songs and even marketing /publicity.

If the trailer of a rival actor's film is good and interesting, people are definitely gonna watch it.I myself has seen many movies of people I don't like.

Rishi Kapoor should blame his son's bad choices of films rather than the movie lover public who wants entertainment and wants to forget their lives problems for few hours.
Her-mion-e thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
No amount of blaming helps when its a matter of BO and reputation
DP openly blamed Ranbir for cheating in 2010..RK par bad boy ka image laga..But did that reduced his popularity? destroyed the reputation of being a good actor?? No not at all...There was Rajneeti, YJHD, Barfi, Rockstar..Either superhit or a performances praised sky high...
Ranbir was with Katy all the time..So Sallu's or his fan's wrath was there all along..Why these moves were not affected?? Even Besharam got bumper opening..
It anything gets the blame than it has to be RK's script sense or bad luck or timing..BV was a disaster in terms of everything...Tamasha would have worked if it was released even post Besharam..
People doesn't bother about bad things said about an actor when he is rising but the constant negativity affects when he is low..That's what is happening with RK now..Too much negativity is affecting his image now...
Look at Katy..She was lowest bottom of her career..but came back with Kala Chasma and how..Look at DP..She made even bigger comeback..Audience is always willing to give a chance provided the star himself is willing to dish out something interesting. RK needs to rectify his image and try his level best for ADHM before its too late
Eggon_Snow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
@Subha and Mione, I completely agree with you'll. Look at Kangana, everyone here, including me, had written her obituary after the HR fiasco but she goes and wins a NA and keeps on signing the best movies. If bad image in people's eyes was a criterion then a Kangana should also have suffered or even Salman for that matter. At the end of the day the quality of the movie and your connect with the audience determines success or failure of the movie IMO.
Like every actor has his niche, Salman has masala, Aamir has the relatively intelligent serious movie genre, SRK had romance, KR has her women oriented roles, Ranbir had his coming of age romantic comedies and dramas, Katty has her light fluffy roles.
I think actors departing from their core genre hits them the hardest and only if the movie is really exceptionally good like CDI was in SRK's case will the movie be successful. I think every actor should first find his genre which displays his strengths and is loved by fans and only then experiment but only with really good scripts. Like a Varun Dhawan can do a Badlapur and still come back to Dishoom cause masala is his bread and butter and only if his many core audience movies are successful can he embark on experimenting with other genres.

Some actors I feel are also unsuccessful cause they haven't been able to find that one genre which becomes eponymous with their name...this I feel is the reason behind failure of actors like Shahid and ABJr who have been all over the place.
Edited by gatheringstorm - 9 years ago
JaaniDushman thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
You know I hadn't thought about it before but reading your post I think it does happen to some extent !

In the last few years, Salman has gained like such a huge fandom, and the last few years SRK's films have not worked that well! Of course Ranbir has chosen bad scripts, I don't think the katrina & Deepika fans would be able to do much but salman fans can man! They are HUGE in number and Kind of crazy for bhai! (No offence to the fans on the forum, I'm talking about some of the ones in real life in India who even went to the extent of suicide if bhai didn't get free from charges!) ranbir- SRK films both aren't working as well as they are supposed to & we can see the common factor!

It doesn't work on Deepika! I'm going to be killed & this statement is going to be used everywhere on the forum for a while but yeah here it is- She is the only female star currently who is enjoying the kind of popularity like the Khan's, no I'm not talking about in number or she making a 40 crore opening day but popularity as much as a female could get in terms of the Khan's! So yeah she being hated by the other female stars wouldn't do much damage, same like how it wouldn't do to a Salman Khan!!


DISCLAIMER: THIS IS ALL AN OBSERVATION & I've said IT COULD BE true to some extent, it isn't necessarily true!
Also if you are going to state your opinion by calling me a basher or hater then refrain from quoting me!
Edited by Patronus - 9 years ago
Aweeeecute thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
lmao other than IF and twitter no one gives a damn
if salman dont get along with ranbir and
deepika with katrina

bombay velvet
barfi was offbeat but songs were chartbusters opening lagi

more than the star power its song which bring the audience not talking about khans
so stop giving credit to ranbir ranveer etc
they do have star power but not as much this forum audience thinks
rl bm openimg good because of rs and dp but the biggest credit goes to charbuster songs
kill dill opened poor
so did piku
JustMySelf thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
yes i think so.it does happens for srk salman amir movies.
we can always wait for the movie of the person whom we dnt like
to come on tv so why would i contribute to that person's box
office collection ?😆
Her-mion-e thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: JustMySelf

yes i think so.it does happens for srk salman amir movies.
we can always wait for the movie of the person whom we dnt like
to come on tv so why would i contribute to that person's box
office collection ?😆


Most moviegoer's are not rabid followers of some actor..Apart from Khan's and too some extent Akki and HR no one enjoys absolute stardom these days...So people like to watch good movies. If a movie is good enough for cinematic experience audience will go to theatre...

btw yes there are rabid fans who thinks the way you have mentioned but I dont think that affects movie business
JustMySelf thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: hermione82


Most moviegoer's are not rabid followers of some actor..Apart from Khan's and too some extent Akki and HR no one enjoys absolute stardom these days...So people like to watch good movies. If a movie is good enough for cinematic experience audience will go to theatre...

btw yes there are rabid fans who thinks the way you have mentioned but I dont think that affects movie business



i am a rabid fan..i have no shame abt that..
i dnt waste money to go watch salman amir movies..
neither do i like to go watch a srk movie..😆

n max ppl are like lambs..remember merry had a little lamb?😆
max are like that .its nt that they are interested in the movie that they go..
its rather that they have heard that their friends have gone n have liked it
so they too must follow the Shepherd..😆

KhanSinghKumar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
not really, it might affect 1-2 crs in total... but lifetime of a movie like bombay velvet or besharam cannot be attributed to fandom hatred...rishi kapoor talks stupid here
Edited by KhanSinghKumar - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: WhipCreamThong · 2 months ago

Why does lead actor Ranveer look more like a side actor in Dhurandhar? So I was under the impression that Ranveer was playing the main lead in...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · a day ago

https://www.mid-day.com/entertainment/bollywood-news/article/mary-kom-fame-veteran-nepali-actor-sunil-thapa-passes-away-at-68-23615548

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: mintyblue · 2 days ago

Ranbir Kapoor has been there, done that. From an angst-ridden child man in Tamasha to the violent, toxic caricature of patriarchy in Animal...he...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 8 days ago

Bollywood Hungama best actor awards https://www.instagram.com/p/DUIhFHNCHYk/?igsh=MTNiaDkyNjRwZHA0OQ==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DUIhFHNCHYk/
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 11 months ago

https://youtu.be/SI_PhNII7Mc https://x.com/MovieTamil4/status/1896159227447750974

https://youtu.be/SI_PhNII7Mc
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".