Not a hero but a brother!

Page

Next Last

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

why is everyone seeing that Shivaay is the one of the male hero?

why is everyone only seeing that Shivaay is being an asshole to the girl he's going later to fall in love with?

right now at this instance, love doesnt count at all...

right now it's only frustration and anger of one brother at having been unable to protect his other brother?

He's angry because he actually saw the mess his family are going through, he actually saw his brother lying lifeless in that pool! he saw his brother again trying to take his life!

I dont know about money or sex here, but I would definitely want to beat or even kill the person i suspect in this case!

Circumstances show Anika as villain, and we all are humans, when we are angry, none have any power over our thoughts and anger... definitely not our first reactions anyway! Maybe when we have calmed down, then our brain will work...

What we would understand is that we must separate the brother Shivaay from the rude romantic hero Shivaay in this episode!

I saw only a brother hurling insults and trying to hurt back the person who in his eyes drove his brother to suicide, and i saw a girl who didnt not cower in fear!

There wasnt any romance at all today, it was pure and simple hatred and anger!

PS: i would have killed or beaten anyone who ever hurt my family, despite my being a girl, with or without the money aspect! well this would definitely have been my first uncontrolled reaction at least!😊

Quote

Frequent Posters

Kriti

@KRITII

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

I don't think that when Shivay will Calm down , then also he'll be able to think Properly.

According to him whatever is correct,is Correct.

No ifs and buts.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sourmisery

@sourmisery

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 9 years ago

Which circumstances showed Anika as the villain, pray tell me that? He overheard a half conversation she was having on the phone and made an entire story in his head when someone mentioned a girl being linked to all this. Did he even bother to find out WHICH girl it was? Poori dunya mein ek Anika hi hai?

And all this brother just looking out for his brother is basic BS. No amount of decency will let any educated man treat a woman like the way he treated her. He could've easily chucked Anika to the police again, after all the great Shivaay Singh Oberoi has the power to do that. The moment he took matters in his own hands and not only physically but verbally abused&tortured Anika, Shivaay stopped being the victim and became a culprit.

There's a way to deal with things and Shivaay doesn't know that. End of story. If someone was targeting my family like that, I'd at least have the common sense to narrow down to the actual root of the problem rather than going after the first person who comes in my head just on an impulse. And you can't separate Shivaay into neat sections and not blame his entire self when he does horrendous. All this violence, rudeness, arrogance, basic badtameezi he shows towards Anika ARE who Shivaay is. We can't blindly deny them and say that's not who he is, asli Shivaay tou jee buss Om aur Rudra ka bhai hai..

Quote

popeye

@popeye

Dazzler

+ 6

Posted: 9 years ago

why is everyone seeing that Shivaay is the one of the male hero?

why is everyone only seeing that Shivaay is being an asshole to the girl he's going later to fall in love with?

right now at this instance, love doesnt count at all...

right now it's only frustration and anger of one brother at having been unable to protect his other brother?

He's angry because he actually saw the mess his family are going through, he actually saw his brother lying lifeless in that pool! he saw his brother again trying to take his life!

I dont know about money or sex here, but I would definitely want to beat or even kill the person i suspect in this case!

What we would understand is that we must separate the brother Shivaay from the rude romantic hero Shivaay in this episode!

I saw only a brother hurling insults and trying to hurt back the person who in his eyes drove his brother to suicide, and i saw a girl who didnt not cower in fear!

There wasnt any romance at all today, it was pure and simple hatred and anger!

[/QUOTE

I agree with u.. today Shivaay was different from being the usual rude and arrogant and that just stems from his love for Omkara and seeing him lifeless in the pool. He was hurting deeply from within and he was venting

Quote

crazylazyvicky

@crazylazyvicky

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

U may be right being brother one can do anything bt shivaay has been like this from starting so this excuse don't validate here may be in future same thing will going to happen n I m sure about it may be with rudra or priyanka or etc n he will act same bt the way he did was over

Seeing his characterization he is not sort of person who manhandle anyone

If here he is actinh as brother than wat will u say to the lady officer who misbehave with anika as she too doing her duty here shivaay didn't it was anika n that time that lady officer didn't knew anika mosi was lying so its look same

Don't get me wrong u will say I m nakul hater n all well not I m here for bromance(Shivomrudra) thing n I even knew without romance shows don't work out bt everything has line

Quote

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: KRITII
I don't think that when Shivay will Calm down , then also he'll be able to think Properly.
According to him whatever is correct,is Correct.
No ifs and buts.

the fact is this is nothing but a show😛

in real life, when we calm down we re-analyse every aspect of a problem, but given this is a show, and the great Shivaay thinks he's right and Anika has hurt him in his ego, well definitely he's not gonna calm down and will try to destroy her😛

But we all know Gul's shows( i've watched IPKKND), she had to give a valid reason for Shivaay to hate Anika, only then she can proceed with her usual type 'rude man-poor girl' love stories! This was only important for her to carry their angry dark love story forward.

what can i say except girls should know how to differentiate between real and reel love stories👍🏼

Quote

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: lostmymusic.
Which circumstances showed Anika as the villain, pray tell me that? He overheard a half conversation she was having on the phone and made an entire story in his head when someone mentioned a girl being linked to all this. Did he even bother to find out WHICH girl it was? Poori dunya mein ek Anika hi hai?

And all this brother just looking out for his brother is basic BS. No amount of decency will let any educated man treat a woman like the way he treated her. He could've easily chucked Anika to the police again, after all the great Shivaay Singh Oberoi has the power to do that. The moment he took matters in his own hands and not only physically but verbally abused&tortured Anika, Shivaay stopped being the victim and became a culprit.

There's a way to deal with things and Shivaay doesn't know that. End of story. If someone was targeting my family like that, I'd at least have the common sense to narrow down to the actual root of the problem rather than going after the first person who comes in my head just on an impulse. And you can't separate Shivaay into neat sections and not blame his entire self when he does horrendous. All this violence, rudeness, arrogance, basic badtameezi he shows towards Anika ARE who Shivaay is. We can't blindly deny them and say that's not who he is, asli Shivaay tou jee buss Om aur Rudra ka bhai hai..

@bold:

sorry but any psychiatrist or equivalent doctors can explain better people's reactions when they are in danger or see someone they love committing suicide!

We humans arent calm and always good people, besides it has already been proved in several studies that each and every human being is capable of killing in dire circumstances or when uncontrollable in anger!

Anger management is a serious issue which exists in over 90% of people in this world!

I'm not separating Shivaay here as a person or character, but i'm definitely separating his actions depending on situations here!

Quote

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: popeye

i know and understand his actions, though i dont agree with them

Quote

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: crazylazyvicky
U may be right being brother one can do anything bt shivaay has been like this from starting so this excuse don't validate here may be in future same thing will going to happen n I m sure about it may be with rudra or priyanka or etc n he will act same bt the way he did was over

Seeing his characterization he is not sort of person who manhandle anyone

If here he is actinh as brother than wat will u say to the lady officer who misbehave with anika as she too doing her duty here shivaay didn't it was anika n that time that lady officer didn't knew anika mosi was lying so its look same

Don't get me wrong u will say I m nakul hater n all well not I m here for bromance(Shivomrudra) thing n I even knew without romance shows don't work out bt everything has line

well Shivaay has always been an arrogant, proud, rude and selfish asshole in all his meetings with Anika!

but today it was different, today it wasnt his ego which was hurt, it was his brother!

He did go way beyond the limits of decency and violence, but only because he judged and condemned Anika on impulse.

i can separate these two Shivaay because i dont believe any human being to be a saint and always in control of their actions and anger!

Quote

SStephy

@SStephy

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

If he is being a brother, he should do what a regular brother would do - stay by his brother's side, support him and the family. Surely taking his anger against someone is not more important than being with the brother and giving him hope to get through the situation. And if he really needs to show his anger, it should be on Tej because he is the reason for all this.

Quote

1 2

Not a hero but a brother!

Related Topics

Explore Topics