Not a hero but a brother! - Page 2

Originally posted by: S.Stephy

If he is being a brother, he should do what a regular brother would do - stay by his brother's side, support him and the family. Surely taking his anger against someone is not more important than being with the brother and giving him hope to get through the situation. And if he really needs to show his anger, it should be on Tej because he is the reason for all this.

Originally posted by: Felicity1234

Hmmm well i have several reasons to justify why he did so:

1) In all shows, men tend to always ignore the real causes of problems in their families, they run away from the root and tend to punish easy targets!

if you have seen Shivaay interactions with Tej, you can easily see he never or very rarely says anything against his bade papa!

2) He feels helpless and wants to hurt his prime suspect

3) It's a Gul show, she needs a reason to make Shivaay be an asshole😛

4) we shouldnt judge someone by the way we will act in a situation, we all are different in our thoughts and actions! One would have stayed with family, one would have committed suicide with the brother, one would have killed Tej, one would have called the police, while some would have looked for an easy prey to throw their anger on

I don't think barging into someone's home, threatening them and man-handling them can have any justification. I can understand Shivaay suspecting Anika and even being angry at her. But going all the way to her house for yet another round of man-handling was crossing the line.

True, we cannot judge someone's reaction... but only when the reaction doesn't cross certain limits. Once certain bounds are crossed, even the law gets to judge us and even condemn us. And Shivaay's reaction today did cross the line that shouldn't be crossed by any decent human being.

yeh I read shivays face expression today and wen he said tume pata he aaj mere sath kya hua he I felt his pain don't know but his voice seem to me crying like, why abt u guys??did u feel it??

I'm not saying what Shivaay did is right. But what the CVs are trying to show here is that Shivaay has MASSIVE anger management issues.
When Shivaay saw his brother dying, his mind immediately sought the reason behind it and the culprit. Since he already doesn't hold Anika in high regard, he latched onto the excuse to blame her. Finding Anika as the apparent reason for Om's state, Shivaay flew in a blind rage.

When a person is blinded by anger, THERE IS NO LOGIC IN THEIR ACTIONS. They are ruled by the anger. So Shivaay, in this case, wasn't thinking about right or wrong, he was just exacting his vengeance - driven by anger.

Originally posted by: S.Stephy

I don't think barging into someone's home, threatening them and man-handling them can have any justification. I can understand Shivaay suspecting Anika and even being angry at her. But going all the way to her house for yet another round of man-handling was crossing the line.

True, we cannot judge someone's reaction... but only when the reaction doesn't cross certain limits. Once certain bounds are crossed, even the law gets to judge us and even condemn us. And Shivaay's reaction today did cross the line that shouldn't be crossed by any decent human being.

[QUOTE=Felicit Ya i agree with you.

Bang on post... I don't understand y everyone is bashing shivay so badly... From shivay' point of view anika is wrong as he has seen his brother suffering again because of her...if shivay had twisted her hand she pushed him as well and she also knows how to give him back verbally she is no abla nari...and it is not it happened first time in fiction show it has shown in many other shows especially 4 lions.

I totall agree with Felicity1234.

I agree to this, he could not see his brother in that state and decided to do whatever he could, yes he could have gone against Tej and in fact he did shout onto him, but Shivaaye Singh Oberoi is not that powerful (at least as on date) that he could create even a minutest of harm to Tej Singh Oberoi, so the only other person who could be hated was the one who leaked the video and he couldn't think of anyone but Anika I really find his actions justified today, but then I just wanted that this scene should have been postponed to tomorrow, today it should have been an emotional turmoil episode

The episode lacked the shock, the support which was anticipated after such a big revelation

Anika as villain 😆