Jodha Akbar 170-174: The magic of Camelot - Page 17

Originally posted by: karkuzhali

Dear Shyamala,

Please see my remix poem of "Que sera sera" on p61 of Shagun's "Jalal'sDiary" thread.

Yours

Saraswathi akka.

Originally posted by: sashashyam

I have seen it, Akka,and commented on it too, two days ago. It is you who have not seen that response. Please do!

Shyamala

Originally posted by: karkuzhali

Dear Shyamala,

I already saw your comment and hit the like button then itself. Probably, you had missed it.

Yours

Saraswathi akka.

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

Aunty (and other Potter fans),

Just a few doubts in the series...😃...(happened to re-read them)

1. When Hermoine could be given a time turner to attend classes, why doesn't the ministry use the same to solve crimes? Why not check if Sirius was right about Peter? Why torture Igor Karakoff for names? Why not just peep into the past and check for Voldemort's allies? Why not check if there were dementors in Little Whinging? Why trials and witnesses?

Why not prevent accidents and murders? Why not save Sirius falling beyond the veil? Why not stop Voldemort from killing James and Lily? Why not Dumbledore check up whose curse killed Ariana?

2. The Weasely twins have the Marauder's map right from their first year when they stole it from Filch's office. After Ron came to the school, didn't they ever spot Peter Pettigrew in the map always around their brother? How come they did not wonder how a Peter Pettigrew slept in Ron's bed?

3. Harry could see thestrals since his fifth year after he saw Cedric's death. But he had seen his mom die right when he was a baby like Luna. So how were thestrals invisible to him for his first four years in Hogwarts while Luna could see them from her first year?

4. What was so important about Slughorn's memory that Dumbledore struggled to retrieve it? And why was Slughorn particular not to divulge it? Afterall he hadn't given any important information to Voldemort that wasn't available in a library book, albeit a restricted one. And what did Dumbledore learn from the memory that he didn't know earlier? Dumbledore zeroed in on the idea of the horcruxes only after he saw the diary. But why did he ask Slughorn for the memory even prior to that and how did he know that the memory was related to horcruxes?

5. What was it about Harry's blood used by Voldemort to re-create himself that tethered him to life? And how did it help him 'come back'? And why was Dumbledore particular that 'Voldemort must do it himself (killing harry)'?

6. When portraits at Hogwarts could move about and be spoken to, why was Harry not able to talk to his parents' pictures? Was it a privilege of Hogwarts headmasters alone? But Ariana's portrait could go and fetch Neville. The fat lady could scream and travel between frames. Then why couldn't Sirius or James talk to Harry?

7. Why was Snape's portrain NOT in the headmaster's room in the final scene? Why only Dumbledore's? Wasn't Snape headmaster too for a brief period?😡 . The poor man is always shortchanged.😭 Just like poor Jalal.😭

(If we were to prepare a list of whys and how comes in JA the list would be long and long and endless like Hanuman ki poonch...😲😆)