*~DOTW - A Day in the Life of...~*

Page

Ammu

@ammmu

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

Bonjourrr HPians!! 🤗

Yes yes yes, time to start another Discussion of the Week! Let's get right to it...

Suppose you were in Winky's shoes, in Goblet of Fire. Would you act the same way - timid, afraid, loyal to Mr. Crouch - or stand up for yourself? And how would you react to what happened when Mr. Crouch's truth was revealed?

As you know, throughout the HP series, we've had numerous truths revealed. Instead of discussing about things we've talked over before, let's talk about Winky and Mr. Crouch.

We better see some good replies from you all or big dandas for all of you!!😛

Have fun,
Love, HP Dev Team
Sam, Manshi, Harshu, Misha, Ammu

Edited by ammmu - 17 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

bitasta

@tukz_REmix

Rocker

Posted: 17 years ago

c house-elves r mad in such a way dat dey r loyal 2 deir masters...its in deir masters...b d mstr is a bad or gud prsn(dere r exceptions like dobby)..so i thnk i wud hav behaved d same way as dobby cuz i wud hav grown up seein my race obeyin wizards n bein loyal 2 dem..if i wudnt b loyal den i myslf wil feel guilty..so i thnk i wud hva behavd as winky...n aftr her mstrs truth was revealed i thnk i shud hav sed srry 2 evry1..but stll luv my mstr n make him promise not 2 do ne such thngs.. 😳

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Vaishnavi (YSH)

@~Sirius*Ysh~

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

Would you act the same way - timid, afraid, loyal to Mr. Crouch - or stand up for yourself?

Well to answet that, firstly putting myself in the shoes of winky, i would have reacted like her... but not that teary... i would have been more of defraiant and tired to prove my case... but in winkys case, thats her charector... not all house elves are dobbys and we all know dat 😃...

And how would you react to what happened when Mr. Crouch's truth was revealed?
as me, i would be shocked and well surprised that barty coruch jr was giving his dad away, but after wht dat sr crouch did to me i wouldnt hv cared a damn...

Quote

Big Story..

@Mini786

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

Me? I would react kind of the same way...I mean its like Ysh said, House elves are not all like Dobby, but i would try to prove myself.
If i found out abt Crouch, I would b shocked and use my elfish magic to turn him into a cattipillar! No,I guess i would just b mad a little...I mean after getting kicked out soo ehemly...
😃

-Mahak-

Quote

Misha

@-misha

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

As I a house-elf i would live up to my duty and obey my masters rule and would never spill out his secrets...not making my my master embarrased! 😉 😳

I would do exactly what Blinky did, as this would seem right! 😛