amita sethi upset with judges-article

Amita Sethi upset with the judges

Amita Sethi says that she is upset with the three Nach Baliye judges because she feels that although the judges always appreciate her and hubby Vikas' performance when it comes to giving marks they aren't being fair.

"I can't understand if the judges are praising and saying that your dance is growing round by round but still we are in 20 to 25," complains Amita.

So we decided to put together the comments and that Vikas and Amita received in episode 1 & 2 for you to decide if Amita is right.

Episode 1
Song: You're My Love


Comments:
Isha: Appreciated that Vikas helped Amita dance and said, "When love can move mountains, what is dance?"
Vaibhavi: Vikas is a trained dancer and has a very positive and encouraging energy towards his partner.
David: Lots of energy in Vikas's performance and good chemistry between them.

Marks: 6 + 7 + 7 = 20


Episode 2
Song: Sholo Sholo Si

Comments
Isha: You have performed well as compared to your first performance she told Amita.
Vaibhavi: You have done lots of hard work despite your injury. She also appreciated the classical mudra.
David: Good work.


Marks: 8 + 8 + 8 = 24

Well hopefully the third round will be better for you Amita!

Dhanashri Kulkarni

Thursday, October 04, 2007

source: www.indya.com

Well from the first two rounds I don't think the judges were very unfair to them. Amita was pretty bad in the first round, and in the second round the concept was good but the dance wasn't excellent, could have been better. Amita should not complain and instead concentrate on honing her dancing skills.

i think first episode marks were fine..in sec episode they cud have got 25-27..but i think it was nothing like unfair as technically she still needs to improve..

i feel tat the judges gave wat they deserved.........
i feel tat the performance in first was bad but they improved in second round hope is tat they do well in third.......... 😉 😉
i love the third round theme ched chaad....... 😆 😆 😆
i saw the promo and it was funny yaar and aamir gives a kiss on cheek of sanjeeda.......... 😳 😳 😳

Well to sum extent i agree wid her dat judges are there nt only to praise but also point out some mistakes.. The judges are nt pointing out much mistakes but rather just praising them and den giving the marks.. Only den can a jodi improve wen the judges tell dem where they are weak..

Yet again i feel dat while in the 1st round dey deserved a little more bec their concept and the whole overall feel 2 the song was good, the score for the 2nd round were well deserved bec amita some mistakes and her movements were nt stiff enough! 😳

I totally agree with this... 😛 I felt the same, they had got such great comments in round 2, but when it came to marks they got just 24... But I dont think Amita comes across as someone who would make any statement about it or complaint... Looks like too much is being made of it...

True I felt the judges gave them more than they actually deserved ............she dances like a duck so it can't get better than that 😉

I think they got what they deserved. They weren't outstanding in their performances.

thanks a lot. hopefully they will get better marks.

stop complaining and do a much better performance next time i dont knw wht on earth vikas saw in you nah im playing just doo much better next time so da judges can stand up and giv u a standing ovation