JUDGE SONA

Page

Next Last

Sumanthy

@sumanthy

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

I dont know why this Ms Sona keeping on

give this remark ' professional & ridiculous'

to Nityashree! all the time!

Why take Nityashree in the first place if she

was not a fresh one!

Ms Sona is not popular anymore with us

after this show!

Disgusting

Singapire Viewer

Quote

Frequent Posters

Adtt

@Adtt

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

She brought her whole family to IIJ. Was IIJ a Sona family platform?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ushasis

@ushasis

Inactive

Posted: 10 years ago

She brought her whole family to IIJ. Was IIJ a Sona family platform?

yes i think so.

two reasons for that:

1. because she named ananya as rockstar and every episode whenever ananya came "sona ka rockstar ananya" was the tag.

that is why she became the winner of the title.

2.Sonakshi's mom was present for almost all the important episodes. she also declared nahid to have a song sung in the forth coming film and she forcefully made vishal to agree for it.

Quote

Adtt

@Adtt

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ushasis
She brought her whole family to IIJ. Was IIJ a Sona family platform?
yes i think so.
two reasons for that:
1. because she named ananya as rockstar and every episode whenever ananya came "sona ka rockstar ananya" was the tag.
that is why she became the winner of the title.
2.Sonakshi's mom was present for almost all the important episodes. she also declared nahid to have a song sung in the forth coming film and she forcefully made vishal to agree for it.

She is a complete MISFIT for this musical platfom. Wonder what Sony tV achieved by having her as a judge

Quote

Shwetha

@Shwets1502

Achiever

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

I found all the three judges the same...How was Vishal and Salim any different with their comments from Sonakshi? I didn't have any problems of her being as the judge when none of the judges were judging the performances. Hence..I found the way she encouraged the kids really nice and it was definitely a boost up for the kids.

As for Sona ka rockstar and her bringing her family...I feel we are all forcing ourselves to find some hidden meaning out of everything.

Ananya won...Fair and square...She got the votes. She won. And she is a good singer too, may not be as equal to the others, nevertheless she had sung songs which many would think twice before taking it.

Quote

Sumanthy

@sumanthy

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

Ms Sona should not be a judge!

Nityashree was just 7 years old when
she was in Super Singer in Chennai

Nahid was just 8 years old when
she was Little Champs

Vaishnav & Ananya were also in musical

This was part of their jouneys!

But Nityashree was extraordinary as
she dont know hindi language & yet
has superior talent of singing hindi songs

Intead of saluting Nityashree,
Ms Sona sarcasticed her that ' As a professional &
ridiculous to be in IIJ'

I AM DISGUSTING WITH MS SONA & ALSO
MR VISHAL

THEY ARE NOT TRUE & HONEST

All my relatives & friends even Chinese friends
said 'NOT FAIR'

From
Singapore Viewers

Poor Nityashree! She is so innocent & dont understand
what Ms Sona trying to tell her!

Quote

Dhaa-Ki-Tiki

@Dhaa-Ki-Tiki

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

The good thing I liked about Sona was she was really encouraging the kids and is anyways a hit with kids.Loved the way she used to sit with the wild card contestants on the sofa.
However,she indeed is a misfit when it comes to judging a music reality show.I sometimes feel it's because of her that the show had such choppy editing😆 It's very hard to take in a busy actress and ask her for dates and then keep skipping episodes twice in a row for Piku and PK premiere..I think all this made the shoot very messy.

I honestly want the old judges back next season.

Quote

Shwetha

@Shwets1502

Achiever

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

I think the RIDICULOUS comment was a compliment to Nithyashree...😆 And that was used for many in the show.

Sona was a misfit, I agree...May be she shouldn't be called a judge...But many a times I felt she echoed what a viewer/audience would respond after watching a performance...A non trained musician would respond.

I don't think there were problems with the dates. I think Sony has always given more importance of movies and that's the same case this time too. Also not to forget...It's Sony...😆😆

Quote

Sumanthy

@sumanthy

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

Anyway hope to see IIJ next season

CHEERS

ALL FROM SINGAPORE

Quote

Sonal99

@Sonal99

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

'Ridiculous' means that Nityashree is off the scale in terms of her singing ability, her professionalism ( trying to master singing in a language foreign to her - as far as her age is concerned).

THAT, is the highest compliment anyone can give her. And you find it offensive???

Not all singers can sing all songs. Shreya Ghosal cannot sing a Sunidhi Chauhan song.

Maybe the song that she gave Nahid suited her voice better.

We as humans are not one dimensional beings! We can love many singers at once!

Edited by Sonal99 - 10 years ago