Was It Really Uncalled For?????

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

anni80

@anni80

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#61

Originally posted by: FieryHeart

@Red - She was wrong on that account. But sometimes the best of us fail to act when it is really needed because we panic. And she was horribly wrong there which I wont deny.

As for her not blaming Manik for trying to patch up her and Dhruv, yes she should have said that. But when she said Manik did not pay any attention to her problems focusing on his love life was she wrong entirely? Aryamann who had joined the group a few days ago could see that something was wrong with her while her own friends were absorbed in their own world to ignore her. Sometimes we need to pull ourselves together but when u have ppl who claim they have ur back is it wrong to expect them to support you?

@BOLD... if all have failed to understand her condition ... why the hell she blamed Manik only??? she should have blamed all... IMO u r contradicting yourself... and its not like that no body tried to support her... mukti was always there asking her 100 times to speak up but alya chose to keep mum... so she was at fault too...

Quote

Sayali_23

@Sayali_23

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#62

well I read all the possible justifications / explanations for Alya... and it's so amusing to see so many opinions for the same situations...

to answer to your question of Was It Really Uncalled For...

My Answer is YES... Alya accusing Manik for being with Nandini and giving FAB5 second priority was uncalled for... when she herself has priorities her own personal life above FAB5... She asking Manik to chose between Nandini or her and dragging the matter for FAB5 vote... She asking FAB5 to forgive Harshad or else she don't believe in FAB5... She is the one for whom a petty album deal was important then a human life (Nandini in hospitable due to Soha) and blames Manik for choosing a life over an album deal...

I would have stand by her and defend her if she would have blasted Manik for pushing Dhruv towards her without asking what she wants...

I would have supported her if she has accused Cabir and Mukti along with Manik for not being their for her as a friend... why single out Manik??

I would have supported her if I haven't seen Mukti asking Alya number of times to talk...

Alya is always quick to point a finger at others but she forgets when you do that three fingers are also pointing towards you...