LETS COMPARE THEIR ORIGINAL SONGS!!! - Page 2

I am fan of both Amit and Prashant. and for me who ever wins I am happy with it.

but honestly, Prashant's version was much much better. there were more voice modulation and Prashant did put a lot of soul in the song.

I wish they sang it in the last gala, I wanted to hear comments of the judges on each version.

on the whole, I felt Prashant was star of tonight's show. and Amit was too shy and wasn't opening up which he needs to.

HONESTLY.. i rele lyked both
both of the songz had a magic touch in them
amits had the **amit magic** in it
&&
prashant had his **prashantO sweetness** in it
lOl
i enjoyed both 😳 😳 😃

Originally posted by: musica_1

😊

can you please stop doing that; it's called spamming..

Originally posted by: ticks

There was no variety in prashant's rendition. Amit's version had more harkatein and variations. I personally found Prashant's version flat and the same tune was repeated in all the song.. Why is that Prashant's version sounded a bit like Babul Supriyo or Kumar Shanu, but he put in more feel to the simple tune.. which made it appealing I think..

However, AMIT needs to sing his version in another scale I guess. AMIT ko thoda au khool ke gana hai..aur thoda aur feel dalana hai to the composition.... to bring out that khanak.. But i guess AMIT's version is tougher. he has to nail it further more. Wonder why Sony gives him tougher compositions.

Just my personal view no one has to agree.

I noticed onething..Prashant is very good at those falsettos..... Suits his voice.

i agree with u there ticks...
amits rendition was better in terms of voice throw n sur.... where he needs to improve acc to me is in his stage perf where he luks a little uncomfortable (thou he did luk more comfortable than the mumbai concert n also toward the end after he was over with his original song😉).... but im sure given tym n prac he will imprve on that 2...he has the grit n det.. n works on his weaknesses positively....
as 4 the "thoda au khool ke gana hai..aur thoda aur feel dalana hai to the composition."... i think both of them got less tym to prac the song so it affected that aspec of their singin...in it cud b seen in both their perf..

Originally posted by: musica_1

Hey Monica.....you will be left alone if you say so.

I bet, that song was sang much much better by Prashant than Amit. Amit's voice was straining and there was no melody and was flat most of the time.

don't worry about me...truth is always bitter but it remains truth..Amit Paul a great talent is already a winner...

yah i agree with Monica.

Amit is far far far better than that nepali prashanth. 😡

Originally posted by: sahana234

yah i agree with Monica.

Amit is far far far better than that nepali prashanth. 😡

Hey Alien! Has it occured to you that you still don't understand the ways of the Earth? Go learn some basic ettiquite before you are even worth listening to our songs, forget commenting about them. You may even need some ear implants.

chill guys!!^^^^


anyways. I listened to the both versions again. I now love both the versions!! 😳 😳

Amit did sound a little nervous coz of his lyrics. but he was good. his version lacked somthing. maybe a little more soul. but it was good!!

Prashant was at its best!! such soulful singing. totally touched heart!!

and now I dont really care who win. I was fan of both from start but wanted Amit to win. but after today's episode I will be happy in any result!! they both rock!!!

Parsahant was moremelodious and singing with heart.i was a amit fan before but now proudly say if Prashant wins ,i will be the happiest person.