Article: SHAAN: II3 finalist are Amateurs - Page 7

Indian Idol's singing level is like kindergarten level. There is no comparsion to other show...its popular based for personality not on talent. Only Emon and Amit were good, every one else is average. Don't believe me? Please see Raja, Poonam, Mussarat, Amanat, Aneek and Sumedha in Saregamapa 07. Then tell me about amaeutar singing. Indian idol singers are average. As for VOI, its okay, its in the middle

1) Saregama
2) VOI
3) Indian Idol

Originally posted by: parleen.sui_rul

ok..he is trying to VOI contestnats r betta than SRGMP n II ones.....prrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrllllllllleeeeeeeeeeaaaaassssssse eee...wt is wrong with him yaar?..i agree tht SRGMP singers r betta than II singers but but but they r waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyy betta than VOI singers..II ROCKXXXXXXXXXX

I don't get why people are comparing indian idol to sa re ga ma pa. the singers on Indian idol are only from india, unlike sa re ga ma pa so in comparison to svoi, II and sa ra ga ma pa are better but equally good.

there's no point of this disscussion.
whn people have differen views they aint gonna match anyway!

ii3 people might not be as better singers as others but does that realli matter when all of em are individual shows?dont like ii3 , just dont watch it..comparing is hella wrong!

obviously shaan is speaking..so he will support VOI..we shud get tht.. 😳

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

Himesh sings through his nose so even if you rip his vocal cords, he won't stop singing. Yes I agree, everytime I watch Saregama it's like watching a Bharat matromony ad. I heard the girl is out, so now Himesh will turn the show into a Devdas movie.

II in the first two seasons had no drama. Only last season, we had the Amey exit which was justified. This year there was too much drama- Emon's overconfidence, Chang-Deepali relation, Ankita-Deepali fight, Emon- Javed issues, Anu- Alisha issues, Udit-Anu issues, etc etc. It seems like even II is using drama this season to increase their TRP's.

uff the love triangle in SRGMP is sooooooo cheap,eveytime Aneek sings here comes HR comments regarding how love/girl is behind his performance 😡

sometimes I feel the judges & the announcer is more interested in this triangle than the 3.

regarding II3 drama,apart from Deepali/Chang issue others were atleast related to singing.

Originally posted by: *allure*

obviously shaan is speaking..so he will support VOI..we shud get tht.. 😳

😆Thats it!! 😉

Originally posted by: ~@$hm@~

there's no point of this disscussion.
whn people have differen views they aint gonna match anyway!

ii3 people might not be as better singers as others but does that realli matter when all of em are individual shows?dont like ii3 , just dont watch it..comparing is hella wrong!

completely agree👏