IshRa: A couple which should not have happened in the first plac-DTNT8 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

59

Views

8.4k

Users

29

Likes

327

Frequent Posters

EkPahelii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#51
Interesting topic and one where there are pros and cons to the couple being discussed each valid or invalid in their own way...but at the end of the day it's a person' own choice which counts, what makes them accept and like a couple, a fictional one on TV or in movies where it's the simple mantra - to each their own.

As stated in the cons about what doesn't make IshRa a good couple - they are true, they are awful in those aspects and don't deserve the 'perfect couple' tag ...which I believe could be handed over to a diametically opposite couple which exists on the same channel - Naitik and Akshara - the hubby doesn't insult his wife, neither does she, there are no ex-wives/ex-boyfriends there only loads and loads of celebrations all through the year that the couple and family believe in celebrating, obviously for a show that has completed over 1000 episodes it has to be doing something right and yet there are posts mocking the very couple...there are people who call this sugary, sachharine sweet couple unreal too despite there being no flaws to them like IshRa have and why - because they think that they are too good to be true, they think that a man like Naitik who addresses his wife with an 'aap' even after all these years of marriage and two teenaged kids cant exist - but that's just being narrow minded isn't it? Why can't a husband respectfully address his wife with an 'aap' and what has the number of years they have been married got to do with it? I have also read it's so crazy that they show a couple with two teens romancing at the drop of a hat - because romance is wiped out of a marriage by that time...well I haven't observed many couples who act lovey-dovey with grownup kids but then again it all varies from couple to couple doesn't it? You gotta be young at heart to romance your wife no matter if you are 30 or 60, age is but a number in this case...


Then there are couples worse than IshRa on TV too, yeah those exist too, believe it or not and yet they have fans. There' another Balaji production which is currently among the top 5 shows of the country that runs on a different channel called KKB, I am sure people must be aware of it too and guess what it's utterly unbearable and yet the lead couple of the show is shipped - this despite the fact that the husband has a girlfriend who he sleeps around with despite being married to his wife, the heroine, the wife who knows about the said affair between her husband and the girlfriend and yet falls in love with the man and accepts their relationship, so much so that when she believes the said girlfriend is pregnant with her husband' child she wants them to settle down and get married...oh also the husband has a sister who is forever brainwashing him against his wife and scheming against the wife' sister because apparently she has the hots for the sister' boyfriend/fiance...together this couple is a definition of people who should be locked in a straitjacket and then put in an asylum because the wife is a perpetual doormat and the husband a nincompoop who cannot use his brains or have the basic common sense which should exist in us humans and yet, yet...the show is number one on the channel on which it airs and the couple who as per their fans have an insanely amazing chemistry are the best that they ever saw - some call them their OTP and what not...while Ishita is seen donating her husband' gifts and also bringing his ex and their son home, accepting her husband' children with his ex and raising them as her own...I wonder if they will ever show her being cool if Raman starts sleeping with Shagun again, that is if the man can manage to get over the disgust he feels for her or is inebriated enough ever to make the mistake...also Raman for his lapses as an awful husband and sometimes a ridiculous man as is evident in the current track, doesnt actually always come across as a guy with more brawns than brains to people and I doubt he ever will...


I am not offending the sensibilities of any fan groups I suppose when I mention Abhi-Pragya or Naitik-Akshara, if I do I apologise to them then. However, this post is what one would call an open debate about how IshRa are a rather bad couple or the worst of the lot...well they can't be the worst until and unless comparisions are made now can they be? So yeah compared to Naitik - Akshara, they are awful...its another thing that even those two are labeled as 'unreal' or 'too good to be true' and compared to Abhi-Pragya I'd say they are a lot better after all a wife being cool about her husband sleeping around is quite something man...I am sure Ishita would thrash Raman should he ever do that or even attempt it and if he succeeds, then she will walk out on him and we would see this much loved duo sepearate for x number of years like N number of soaps where perhaps after years and years it may be revealed that Raman never did anything or perhaps he did and Shagun had another child with him, just an illegimate one this time around like Karan from Kyunki and so many others...but thats a bridge we can cross when we come to it.


The point is...are there really any 'ideal' couples at all? I dont think so, hell they cant even exist in real life. The couple that is emulated on most shows, the couple which is said to be the ideal couple who should be worshipped that of Lord Ram and his wife Sita, a god and goddess couldnt be perfect if we look at it - how could they be when after he rescued her from Raavan the first thing she had to undergo was a purity test and yet she had to be banished from her kingdom and her home that too without a word from her husband who asked his younger brother to do the needed for him based on the allegations of a common launderer? When he did find his wife after his sons came to him she chose to return to her mother than live with her husband because her respect had been compromised by him.

If gods and goddesses cannot be perfect, how can mere mortals be? And if REAL people cannot be perfect why is PERFECTION seeked in a 'FICTIONAl' couple? Its pointless and rather silly isnt it? The best and the only option I think available is watching a couple you think you find bearable and love to watch - if you can do that thats great for you isnt it? Why waste time and money over people you cant even like I say?

However it all depends who one chooses to like then - one man' hell can be someone else' paradise, similarly one person' loathed couple can be another person' favorites...its a matter of perspective and choice isnt it, to select which 'UNREAL'/'FICTIONAL' couple you would rather waste your time and money over - the saccharine sweet Naitik Akshara and the likes, the awful and crazy IshRa and the likes or the moronic and silly Abhi Pragya and the likes.
Edited by EkPaheli - 10 years ago
smritishah thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: Nichuss

u said wt im feeling on ishra
even aftr 1yr tey dont knw eahother...
Tey r nt couples...
Tey r just parnters to tc f kids...

Ruhi involvement n ishita response was th worst thing tat happened... Espcly instead f reasoning she was encouraged


cheee


Exactly my view.
beckysharp thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#53
Aani, May I just say beautifully put.
Phoenix- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#54
Thank you all for your replies. I will personally respond to each and everyone. But I'm currently busy in real life, so please bear with me.
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: Alu-

Well then in that case no couple on Indian TV is a real couple? Accepted 😛


Lol...matter of fact none of the India TV Couple are Real. But then there is always something real in them and hence audience somewhere connect with them and Root for their Happiness.

Only because IshRa Fans brought other Couple's in this Topic to Defend IshRa.

Of all the couples I have seen till date or atleast till I have followed the serial I have never rooted for their Separation like I do for Raman-Ishita...simply because though other couples were driven thru some unreal Drama still they had some Realness to their Relationship...something which still made me feel CONNECTED to them and never really found them as a Bad Influence on each other.

Even if they showed mistrust in each other they called their relation enough to come around accept the mistake, learn,respect and start a new beginning.

But well If you feel Your Couple is at-least better than other Couple , then I see no point in Arguing only because You love your Couple based on Comparison with Other and not because You find them Best but Better.

PS : Kindly don't bring other Couples in this Topic. I dont want Their Fans to come here and start a whole diff Angle . This is YHM Forum and Rman-Ishita are part of YHM . Moreover This Topic is Fabulous, I don't want to get it Closed.😳

Edit : I might not be able to reply to you soon since I am busy with Work . But I definitely Will..

Edited by RollingStones - 10 years ago
Panoramic thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: EkPaheli



The point is...are there really any 'ideal' couples at all? I dont think so, hell they cant even exist in real life. The couple that is emulated on most shows, the couple which is said to be the ideal couple who should be worshipped that of Lord Ram and his wife Sita, a god and goddess couldnt be perfect if we look at it - how could they be when after he rescued her from Raavan the first thing she had to undergo was a purity test and yet she had to be banished from her kingdom and her home that too without a word from her husband who asked his younger brother to do the needed for him based on the allegations of a common launderer? When he did find his wife after his sons came to him she chose to return to her mother than live with her husband because her respect had been compromised by him.



See u can go around debating on fictional couples, n making comparisons...
But pls don't bring Shri rama n sitamaa into this... Seriously I don't appreciate this!...

Why ppl do jump on religious thing just TO prove their point?!!

Don't tell me u r comparing trashy ek kapoor characters with the gr8 VALMIKI RAMAYANA epic characters shri ram n sita maa...

Hv u read ever heard of ramcharitmanas?!..GO n read u will get ur answers...

It needs yrs together to write meaning n understanding characters like. The gr8 shriRamSita...
Just in two sentences u passed ur judgement on them... Shocking!




Alu- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: RollingStones


Lol...matter of fact none of the India TV Couple are Real. But then there is always something real in them and hence audience somewhere connect with them and Root for their Happiness.

Only because IshRa Fans brought other Couple's in this Topic to Defend IshRa.

Of all the couples I have seen till date or atleast till I have followed the serial I have never rooted for their Separation like I do for Raman-Ishita...simply because though other couples were driven thru some unreal Drama still they had some Realness to their Relationship...something which still made me feel CONNECTED to them and never really found them as a Bad Influence on each other.

Even if they showed mistrust in each other they called their relation enough to come around accept the mistake, learn,respect and start a new beginning.

But well If you feel Your Couple is Best or Better than other Couple , then I see no point in Arguing only because You love your Couple based on Comparison with Other and not because You find them Best but Better.

PS : Kindly don't bring other Couples in this Topic. I dont want Their Fans to come here and start a whole diff Angle . This is YHM Forum and Rman-Ishita are part of YHM . Moreover This Topic is Fabulous, I don't want to get it Closed.😳

Edit : I might not be able to reply to you soon since I am busy with Work . But I definitely Will..



Only reason i brought in another couples was cause the TM called ishra the worst couple.and hence I wanted to know what couples she found perfect that she considers Ishra the worst and one who is not meant to be😃.

Anyways I guess its about perspective and everyone seeing something different which allows them to connect with the couple.

I have been watching EKTA shows since the age of 7 and for me its always been about the chemistry, intensity passion and romance which kept me watching. Otherwise trust me all the stories have the wives/husbands MU their partner, or perhaps some stupid sacrifice and at that stage its just the cuteness,intensity and passion which keeps me watching.

So my only argument was was with the TM title cause she said they should have never happened in the first place and never emphasized why and secondly she called them the worst couple.

Anyways Like you said, I love my couple and you love yours so arguing won't be of any use.
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Interesting topic and one where there are pros and cons to the couple being discussed each valid or invalid in their own way...but at the end of the day it's a person' own choice which counts, what makes them accept and like a couple, a fictional one on TV or in movies where it's the simple mantra - to each their own.


As stated in the cons about what doesn't make IshRa a good couple - they are true, they are awful in those aspects and don't deserve the 'perfect couple' tag ...which I believe could be handed over to a diametically opposite couple which exists on the same channel - Naitik and Akshara - the hubby doesn't insult his wife, neither does she, there are no ex-wives/ex-boyfriends there only loads and loads of celebrations all through the year that the couple and family believe in celebrating, obviously for a show that has completed over 1000 episodes it has to be doing something right and yet there are posts mocking the very couple...there are people who call this sugary, sachharine sweet couple unreal too despite there being no flaws to them like IshRa have and why - because they think that they are too good to be true, they think that a man like Naitik who addresses his wife with an 'aap' even after all these years of marriage and two teenaged kids cant exist - but that's just being narrow minded isn't it? Why can't a husband respectfully address his wife with an 'aap' and what has the number of years they have been married got to do with it? I have also read it's so crazy that they show a couple with two teens romancing at the drop of a hat - because romance is wiped out of a marriage by that time...well I haven't observed many couples who act lovey-dovey with grownup kids but then again it all varies from couple to couple doesn't it? You gotta be young at heart to romance your wife no matter if you are 30 or 60, age is but a number in this case...


Then there are couples worse than IshRa on TV too, yeah those exist too, believe it or not and yet they have fans. There' another Balaji production which is currently among the top 5 shows of the country that runs on a different channel called KKB, I am sure people must be aware of it too and guess what it's utterly unbearable and yet the lead couple of the show is shipped - this despite the fact that the husband has a girlfriend who he sleeps around with despite being married to his wife, the heroine, the wife who knows about the said affair between her husband and the girlfriend and yet falls in love with the man and accepts their relationship, so much so that when she believes the said girlfriend is pregnant with her husband' child she wants them to settle down and get married...oh also the husband has a sister who is forever brainwashing him against his wife and scheming against the wife' sister because apparently she has the hots for the sister' boyfriend/fiance...together this couple is a definition of people who should be locked in a straitjacket and then put in an asylum because the wife is a perpetual doormat and the husband a nincompoop who cannot use his brains or have the basic common sense which should exist in us humans and yet, yet...the show is number one on the channel on which it airs and the couple who as per their fans have an insanely amazing chemistry are the best that they ever saw - some call them their OTP and what not...while Ishita is seen donating her husband' gifts and also bringing his ex and their son home, accepting her husband' children with his ex and raising them as her own...I wonder if they will ever show her being cool if Raman starts sleeping with Shagun again, that is if the man can manage to get over the disgust he feels for her or is inebriated enough ever to make the mistake...also Raman for his lapses as an awful husband and sometimes a ridiculous man as is evident in the current track, doesnt actually always come across as a guy with more brawns than brains to people and I doubt he ever will...


I am not offending the sensibilities of any fan groups I suppose when I mention Abhi-Pragya or Naitik-Akshara, if I do I apologise to them then. However, this post is what one would call an open debate about how IshRa are a rather bad couple or the worst of the lot...well they can't be the worst until and unless comparisions are made now can they be? So yeah compared to Naitik - Akshara, they are awful...its another thing that even those two are labeled as 'unreal' or 'too good to be true' and compared to Abhi-Pragya I'd say they are a lot better after all a wife being cool about her husband sleeping around is quite something man...I am sure Ishita would thrash Raman should he ever do that or even attempt it and if he succeeds, then she will walk out on him and we would see this much loved duo sepearate for x number of years like N number of soaps where perhaps after years and years it may be revealed that Raman never did anything or perhaps he did and Shagun had another child with him, just an illegimate one this time around like Karan from Kyunki and so many others...but thats a bridge we can cross when we come to it.


The point is...are there really any 'ideal' couples at all? I dont think so, hell they cant even exist in real life. The couple that is emulated on most shows, the couple which is said to be the ideal couple who should be worshipped that of Lord Ram and his wife Sita, a god and goddess couldnt be perfect if we look at it - how could they be when after he rescued her from Raavan the first thing she had to undergo was a purity test and yet she had to be banished from her kingdom and her home that too without a word from her husband who asked his younger brother to do the needed for him based on the allegations of a common launderer? When he did find his wife after his sons came to him she chose to return to her mother than live with her husband because her respect had been compromised by him.

If gods and goddesses cannot be perfect, how can mere mortals be? And if REAL people cannot be perfect why is PERFECTION seeked in a 'FICTIONAl' couple? Its pointless and rather silly isnt it? The best and the only option I think available is watching a couple you think you find bearable and love to watch - if you can do that thats great for you isnt it? Why waste time and money over people you cant even like I say?

However it all depends who one chooses to like then - one man' hell can be someone else' paradise, similarly one person' loathed couple can be another person' favorites...its a matter of perspective and choice isnt it, to select which 'UNREAL'/'FICTIONAL' couple you would rather waste your time and money over - the saccharine sweet Naitik Akshara and the likes, the awful and crazy IshRa and the likes or the moronic and silly Abhi Pragya and the likes.



i HAD TO comment bcoz of this..!!

Aani...v may hv diff opinions...but KUDOS TO u...for actually trying to view diff couples in a non biased manner..!! here many r mockin other couples just to prove IshRa is perfect..!!

Lik a simple thing - FOR EACH HIS/HER OWN...!! thts one thing majority forget n when they compare they dnt knw evn one couple fully...!!

I USED TO BE hardcore IshRa fan...those 11pm days...IshRa ws one of best couples ever...the sheer pleasure i had while makin topics for them celebratin IshRa love-all tht i can never forget..!! n for me 11pm IshRa is ALWAYS PERFECT n 7.30pm IshRa is PATHETIC BEYOND REPAIR now..!! Its such a sad state to see the couple u loved so much..being insulted by CVs-just for the sake of effin TRPs..!!

I hv no more emotional connect with this show..n stickin nw jst for Raman n thtsy i evn comment on epis-once a while..!!

i am happy n content in MaNan land nw..!! I hv watched countless show since 2003 n i can say my whole respect to ky2 CVs for givin MaNan a perfect blend of maturity n teen elements..!! ppl who dnt evn see tht show...generally tend to say all they do is romance..!! but had they evn watch one epi...they can knw truth..!! i can write SO MANY situations to my point right too..!! but again at the end of the day its an individual choice..!!

v hv already hv enough of fightin posts here...raman vs ishita, karan vs dt, old ishra fans vs ppl who still love ishra..!! bt evrythin ws bounded to yhm..!! bt nw look at this post...its gone beyond tht..!!

to show superiority of couple another couple is mocked down n vice versa..!! bt thts one thing i hv seen n its never gonna change..!! not jst to couples..!!

nywz i still req..if this post stick to just IshRa discussions..both frm ppl who agree to this post n ppl who dnt agree to this post..!!

all i can say is i agree with u Aani...tht one whos perfect for some may not look for others and vice versa..!! i wish many here had thoughts lik u...who knw how to agree n disagree GRACEFULLY..👏
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#59
For those who are going off on a tangent here 😛




For the Topic Maker 😛



Edited by -MS- - 10 years ago
-RD- thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Gulaal-e-Jung Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 10 years ago
#60
@TM- Please feel free to open anew thread with the same post as if I clean this thread nothing will be left


@All- If you can debate debate the content and stick to IshRa if you cant defend them on their own base then no need to if u have to bring in comparisons with other leads or the gods and goddesses themselves to glorify and set a pt .Please glorify and defend Ishra on their own basis and NOT WITH COMPARISON..IF you cant debate on IshRa alone and are overwhelmed by your love for them then ignore this topic and participate elsewhere on the forum instyead of attacking and targeting the TM not everyone is gonna love IShRA irrespective of anything..please accept that .


YHM DT


Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Devanshi14

3 months ago

FF: IshRa ISHQ !!

Chapter # 01 Title: “Pehli Baar Ishq Hua” Raman and Ishita had been married for months now—contractually, yes—but slowly, silently, love had...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock

4 months ago

ISHRA OS:- Tumhare bina main adhoora hoon.

It was one of those rare calm nights in Delhi, the kind that carried a soft breeze, the scent of blooming mogra, and a strange kind of silence...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Im_sherlock

4 months ago

IshRa OS: Unspoken Desires.

On the show, we all know how Raman tried to give hints to Ishita about his feelings and desires, by keeping a box of condoms in her drawer. An...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan

4 years ago

YHM DT #8 (Strictly Reserved for IshRa/DivAn)

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

6 months ago

Karan Patel and Divyanka Tripathi BOTH NOT part of Sony TV show

Exclusive:; Harshad Chopda and Shivangi Joshi likely to play leads The Sony TV show produced by Balaji Telefilms has seen major developments...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".