Amaya faking her identity- right or not?

I think Amaya's lie about being Nidhi Sharma was a big stupidity. It was absolutely pointless. You had helped the man Amu! You could simply leave when his family came and everyone would have been happy. Why faking name and all?

Gajanji regused 2 take.help of amaya

We know Chaubeyji and Dinesh are highly egoistic persons and how much they hate Mathurs and in fact, he refused Amaya's help even in that situation, so it is good that Amaya does not reveal herself helping him. She has admitted him in the hospital and maybe once his family arrives there, she will leave from there. Otherwise, this is going to pressurize Chaubeyji and he may in fact get more serious thinking he was helped by Amaya.

Originally posted by: kriyansh_tanya

Gajanji regused 2 take.help of amaya

So.i.guess she changed namw so wen he gains consciousness

He wud freak out

While I do agree with your point but she could have left before he regained consciousness.

Originally posted by: b2011

We know Chaubeyji and Dinesh are highly egoistic persons and how much they hate Mathurs and in fact, he refused Amaya's help even in that situation, so it is good that Amaya does not reveal herself helping him. She has admitted him in the hospital and maybe once his family arrives there, she will leave from there. Otherwise, this is going to pressurize Chaubeyji and he may in fact get more serious thinking he was helped by Amaya.

I know that Dinesh and Chaubeyji are egoistic but I think this will complicate matter even more. I am sure now Chaubeyji will be praising and Nidhi day and night (even if he has not seen her!) and he will taunt Amaya saying that she did not help him even in such a critical condition (even if he rejected her help himself!).

Originally posted by: Angela_Grokes

I know that Dinesh and Chaubeyji are egoistic but I think this will complicate matter even more. I am sure now Chaubeyji will be praising and Nidhi day and night (even if he has not seen her!) and he will taunt Amaya saying that she did not help him even in such a critical condition (even if he rejected her help himself!).

Originally posted by: ..Evanescent..

On large I guess, Amaya likes to act selfless 😛

That is what I don't like. They are making Chaubeyji BhabhiMa part 2 and Amaya Akshara part 2. 😆

Originally posted by: frenz4u

I was actually confused whether she did right or not in hiding her identity??😕🤔
In that emergency situation, she managed to give fake identity...
She dint wanted to disclose herself in front of Chaubey family...especially after GN threatened that he dont want her help in any way and all...She will hide from Chaubey family in order to avoid the awkward situation...

I m even doubtful now whether she wil disclose to Rachi - Jazz that she was in hospital??? I dont want Amaya to hide that from sisters...
And with further ManYa romance she will be disappeared for even a long time...hope she informs them both before ManYa scenes...

I really did not like the whole - 'Stay incognito-Be virtuous'. Believe me U like Amaya very much since she had reformed but I think she should not have done that. Hiding her identity will do more harm than good.

I think she did the right thing, bc like others have mentioned, Chaubey ji completely rejected her help even though he was dying, bc of who she was. So who's to say Dhanesh wouldn't have reacted the same way? or if Chaubey ji created some sort of nonsense bc of his ego, even though Amaya saved her life.

There's also the fact that Chaubey has disowned Sneha and her family completely, and Sneha and the girls don't want them in their lives either, at least not now, so Amaya might not want things to get more complicated bc the 2 families don't feel comfortable around e/o

She did the right and good thing without expecting anything in return, it's not necessarily being selfless bc after all he is her grandfather, and i think any of us would do the same. In fact, it's humanity to help someone who's basically dying right in front of you. And (i hope) many of us wouldn't expect anything in return for helping someone.

I think things would have become more complicated if Amaya has revealed herself. It's easier to let the Chaubeys think some stranger helped them.

But I do hope she tells Jazz and Rachita the whole truth of everything that happened! I don't want her to hide anything from her sisters either ><