Nurse Aruna Shanbaug dies

Padfoot_Prongs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Aruna Shanbaug (67), former nurse of Mumbai's Kings Edward Memorial (KEM) Hospital who was in a coma for 42 years after a sexual assault by a wardboy in 1973, was declared dead on Monday morning.

Shanbaug was diagnosed with pneumonia last week and was put on ventilator support. On Sunday, doctors said her condition had improved slightly but she continued to remain on life support.

Shanbaug was being taken care off by a group of KEM hospital nurses and doctors for the last four decades. Hospital authorities have appealed to Shanbaug's family members to step forward to claim her remains for last rites.

On November 27, 1973, Shanbaug who then worked as a junior nurse at the Kings Edward Memorial Hospital in Mumbai, was brutally assaulted and raped by a wardboy-cum-sweeper of the hospital, Sohanlal Bharta Valmiki, after throttling her with a dog chain. The brutal assault cut off blood and oxygen supply to key parts of her brain. Ms. Shanbaug had been in a vegetative state since and confined to a bed at the KEM hospital where nurses and the hospital staff take care of her.

"The demise of Aruna Shanbaug is a jolt for any sensitive mind. It is ironical and a cruel turn of fate that someone who dreamed of dedicating her life to medical care as a nurse should remain bed-ridden. She continue to fight Destiny bravely and her struggle will remain immortal," State Congress Chief and former Maharashtra Chief Minister Ashok Chavan said in a condolence message.

Euthanasia plea

Shanbaug's case had triggered a national debate on mercy killing. In 2011, the Supreme Court responded to a plea for euthanasia filed by journalist Pinki Virani but turned down the mercy killing petition. In her petition, Ms. Virani, who penned the book Aruna's Story, had urged the court to grant euthanasia arguing that the former nurse was "virtually a dead person."

42 years in vegetative state. wud it have been better to let her die?

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

554

Users

4

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

_Angie_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: MissBahanji

Euthanasia plea

Shanbaug's case had triggered a national debate on mercy killing. In 2011, the Supreme Court responded to a plea for euthanasia filed by journalist Pinki Virani but turned down the mercy killing petition. In her petition, Ms. Virani, who penned the book Aruna's Story, had urged the court to grant euthanasia arguing that the former nurse was "virtually a dead person."

42 years in vegetative state. wud it have been better to let her die?


Depends on who is being asked.
- Family who would have to care for her and bear the medical expenses for 42 long years.
- The resident doctor she was to marry , who initially visited regularly and who under parental pressure eventually married after 10 years.
- The successive groups of nurses who voluntarily and selflessly took her under their full care.
- The hospital authorities whose bed she continued to occupy with little or no hope for recovery.
- Other patients who were denied treatment due to unavailability of hospital bed.
- Doctors or researchers with academic interest.
- Aruna herself ?

QuietlyLoud thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: MissBahanji


Euthanasia plea

Shanbaug's case had triggered a national debate on mercy killing. In 2011, the Supreme Court responded to a plea for euthanasia filed by journalist Pinki Virani but turned down the mercy killing petition. In her petition, Ms. Virani, who penned the book Aruna's Story, had urged the court to grant euthanasia arguing that the former nurse was "virtually a dead person."

42 years in vegetative state. wud it have been better to let her die?


It seems that she was not in a full vegetative state.Irreversible brain damage,but not brain dead.
It is been said that she used to smile at familiar caretakers and when given her favourite food.She would expresss her dislike through movements when people crowd her room and music calms her.If such responses were indeed true,it suggests some level of consciousness was still intact.
Though,perhaps there was no way to know her opinion as to whether she wished to live on that way or wanted to die, it would have been unethical to consider euthanasia without her consent.
qwertyesque thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
this shouldnt have been debated...its diculous to keep her aliv for 40+ years..not sure why this case is getting so much attention!! It was unfortunate but then in last 40 years more despicable things have happened including the delhi rape case!!
Padfoot_Prongs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: qwertyesque

this shouldnt have been debated...its diculous to keep her aliv for 40+ years..not sure why this case is getting so much attention!! It was unfortunate but then in last 40 years more despicable things have happened including the delhi rape case!!

this case was not just about the rape. he sodomised her not raped her and hence not punished for that becoz at tat time it was not included in definition of Rape.. He was tried for attempt to murder and theft only.
The reason why this case is famous becoz of euthanasia case. It was debated for long for her passive euthanasia. becoz of this case, guidelines were issued by SC for passive euthanasia.

Related Topics

Debate Mansion thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 3 months ago

https://x.com/TheTreeni/status/1984861828388962790

https://x.com/TheTreeni/status/1984861828388962790
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".