Drop in the quality of the show.

BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

I am not sure if I am the only one who feels this way but I feel like the quality of the show has definitely dropped in this week's episodes. Or maybe I am just being too critical about this show due to the high expectations I built up based on the past 12 episodes.

1. What is with Aaliya's new hairstyle & the high heels she was wearing in the hospital? Suddenly Aaliya just doesn't seem like Aaliya. Please can we have her old hairstyle & old dressing in jeans & shirt back, at least when she is in the hospital.

2. Dr Veer - firstly Kushal can't act to save his life. Secondly, is there a need for him to act like some typical angry young man? Thirdly, no matter what his agenda is, what's with moving into Aaliya's apartment without her consent & further ordering her around? And what's with the overdose of Veer/Aaliya scenes, esp when they are just filler & didn't do much in exploring Veer's motivations or his character in general

3. Whats with Sahil & Aaliya dressing up that way to solve some mystery? They were not even behaving like doctors. How can they have so much free time to run around cosplaying when they are supposed to be on duty.

4. And am I the only one who thinks that Aaliya is over-reacting. Its not that Ishaan doesn't trust her. He does. All he wants is some evidence before they take this whole thing further. I don't see how the trust issue arises. If the CVs are going to use this to develop a misunderstanding between Ishaan/Aaliya, then I think its a bad idea. Its not working, at least for me.

I just hope this show is not turning into Sanjeevani part2. That show was EPIC in its own way & they do not need to re-create it with Zindagi Wins. The love triangle between Ishaan/Aaliya/Malvika so far is being handled nicely & there is a fresh feel to it, but I hope that the show is not going to center around it. This is a drama on doctors & I hope it stays that way. I am missing the positivity & subtelty this show had.

Do share your thoughts!


Cheers,
Samridhi
Edited by prc_fan1 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.5k

Users

12

Likes

55

Frequent Posters

Star_girl thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I agree with everything you said. The entry of Veer coincided with the drop of the quality. I will tackle this with the points given by you,
1. Aliya looks ridiculous. She's not Malvika. Abigail, at best, is an average looking cute girl who was lovely in her own jhalli way. She cannot carry off an elaborate hairstyle like that. It looks ridiculous on her and doesn't go with her character at all. She looks like a kid playing dress up. Horrible styling.
2. Kushal is effin terrible. Especially in comparison to the rest of actors. Kiran is such an effortless performer that Kushal's disjointed acting comes as a rude shock. I am fine with his angry-young-man attitude but I need some proper clues regarding his character. Also, who ever thought casting Kushal Punjabi beside a performer like Kiran was a good idea? Of all the stupid ideas, honestly. -_-
3. That cosplaying annoyed the hell outta me. Is this Clowns Mil Gaye season two? Because tell me now so I can get out. Aliya is super annoying with her pointless interest in everything. Like, who even does that? Why does this show need to glorify the heroine this much? Haven't we had enough similar shows already? Create good character, not righteous annoyances.
4. Ishaan is, frankly, as close to a perfect hero as it gets. If people legit think Ishaan should've randomly trusted Aliya making such a nonsensical and massive accusation with ZERO concrete proof, then they are insane. Aliya, I thought, was sadder about Ishaan wanting to talk about Malvika than "not trusting" her or whatever. Nobody would trust her random accusations.
IDK, I feel like this is turning into Dil Mil Gaye nonsense already and I am SO NOT here for it. Kiran is a fabulous performer and deserves better IMO. I liked the episode last night but tonight was beyond ridiculous. Veer is ridiculous and Aliya is becoming a caricature.
Jessicarh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Dont know why they are changing aliya's character in such a ridiculous way. I want my aliya back. I dont like her hairstyle at all..these days. She looked the best with her old look itself❤️ i feel too much of makeup n styling doesnt suit her!! Plz..plz..i dont want this show to go like dmg, it became worst later🤢
kiran is an amazing actor❤️ kushal can definetely not match up to his level. Truly effortless acting👍🏼 At no point of time it was ever felt that he was trying do some scenes forcefully. The way he acts as a doctor..dealing with his patients, or be it romantic scenes with malvika/aliya..it does everything perfectly❤️❤️ i wish kushal improves as the show progresses!
I WANT MY ALIYA BACK! O GOD..HER HAIRSTYLE🤢
BepannaahPyaar thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Goddamn!!
I so agree with u all.
Well, abt Ishaan not trusting Aaliya n not being with her, I felt bad only coz it was an overdose of Ishaan-Malvika scene
N abt Veer-Aaliya, it was over the top! Veer acts as if he has swallowed concentrated Acid!! Seriously Kushal, please learn how to act!
I can say that the show was good until Dr. Veer's entry!
N I hate Aaliya's wig too! Makes her look like a bimbo🤢
EkPagliLadki thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Completely agree with you.
I found yesterday's episode a deja vu of DMG stupidity. Sorry to say but I feel the popularity of the show has led to this. The show is becoming popular and the makers are using old tricks to sustain that but they are not realising that it is already backfiring. I wish they realise this soon and correct their mistakes.
Points I didn't like yesterday or in general
1. Why does a girl always falls for the guy? They can still stay friends and enjoy. It is normal for a girl and guy to be friend in real life but not in TV shows. Somehow the girl always ends up falling and I hate this. I loved the friendship between Aliya and Ishaan but they end up the same way.
2. Abigail's look didn't go with the character in the last epi. Aliya was never a stylish sort of a girl and now suddenly she has long hair with curls with so much make up on her face that it looks fake. The skirt and the heels didn't seem right.
3. Kushal can't ACT. And I have seen his work before so I was a bit apprehensive about his entry in the show. I didn't want him in the show at all when I read those articles. But thats what the makers wanted.And his trying to be angry looked so fake. He looks so bad when compared to Kiran. And the part where he decides to live with Aliya and tells Sarika and Sahil about that was so DMG like. Stupidity at the next level. Who does that? And nobody allows a stranger to stay with them
4. All those stupid acts that Aliya took part in with Sahil.
5. Aliya becoming the savior of the world. Why does the herione have to be everywhere? And save everybody single handedly?
6. Aliya-Ishaan-trust angle. Come on lady. Nobody would believe you just like that on such a big issue. You need to prove it. And thank God Ishaan was not a part of her childish antics.
7. And many more things.

I know people would hate me for this but I feel Ishaan Malvika getting back together is pretty normal. We all try to give one more chance to our relationships to see if it works out. I loved it when Ishaan confessed to Aliya that he is confused about it.
** And I don't hate Aliya. Its just that I found her annoying yesterday.
dsupriya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
I agree with all of your points. I did feel bad about Ishaan not trusting heras I felt he need not trust blindly but give some benefit of doubt. But when I think back he was right as suspecting a senor doctor without proof is foolishness. I also though felt that Aaliya and sahil in that get up was OTT. I was rather expecting her to show the report to someone and take the opinion.
I also wanted to make a separate post that why should it be a love triangle always. If they want to patch up ishaan and malavika then so be it. They need not have bought in Aaliya falling in love with Ishaan. Or if they wanted friends to lovers then show malavika moving on. Ishaan also I felt was oblivious to Aaliya feelings was not realistic. Come on even in friendships you draw a line and you can sense when someone is serious about you. You automatically back off if you feel you are being misconstrued. I was bit surprised by that as Ishaan on account of his profession is not able to sense it.
Dr Veer the way he was ordering about can be bought to line in this corporate world. I am a professional working woman and I know that last thing you do is take orders from your boss like that. Everything was OTT. And of course his acting is awful and please they are demeaning people in defence by showing that OTT stance. I have my cousins in defence and yes they are very much normal. They do not boss around but yes they tend to dominate at times
To be honest I felt aal the characterization got butchered for sake of love triangle and spice. Dr Malavika also to some extent yesterday I felt was artificial. Do not know what it was
personally I feel Aaliya and Ishaan are good but for me it is old Aaliya. And as a woman I hate it when a woman has to go for a makeover to ensure a romantic interest. Which all the serials love to do. For once would have loved if they had shown love developing out of friendship for simple cute Aaliya without that wig or heavy makeup.That trademark of zindagi wins was missing in last 2 episodes.I want my old characters back. Hope we get them soon

Edited by dsupriya - 10 years ago
Illuminati07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
I agree on all the points here and I will not vent out my frustration any further by playing the same old record that has already been covered by everyone so beautifully.
Some one mentioned Ishaan Malvika.. Honestly I for one am happy that they decided to give their relationship another chance (though privately i think they were always ill matched but lets go into that sme other time.. ) Sometimes it is important to get back tto know if the relationship was worth fighting for and sometimes it is important to get back to simply get a closure.

So as I was saying, I liked that they gave their relationship another chance but they reduced Malvika to a hysterical begging mess to achieve it and that was one bitter pill to swallow specially after she hasnt left a single chance of insulting Ishaan in public.

Secondly Malvika acting like a petulant child wasn't expected from character sketched as a sophisticated perfectionist. She had previously always fair to Aliya despite of not liking her vivacious nature. And suddenly she is shown being petty. I am talking about her behaviour during the match. Yes jealousy brings weird reactions in people but can we have a little bit maturity in showing the green monster please??

Edited by aashti - 10 years ago
Jessicarh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Honestly..i like the way veer interacted with aliya,kept staring at her,talked to her, n think it was really cute when he smiled at her after coming out of the operation theatre..i dont know why but i liked them..n looking forward to their budding relationship❤️
I didnt like ishaan-malvika scene..i dont want them to be back together❤️
sehar mehrotra thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
I totally agree with all your points!! I thought I'm the only one with such a view 😳

The moment I saw Aaliya in that skirt and heels and make up, I was like "What the hell did they turn her into??". No doubt Abigail lukd beautiful but it just wasn't Aaliya. I thought Malvika lukd really pretty in that braid yesterday.

Dr Veer is supposed to be an army guy. I know plenty army guys and they don't walk around making the females feel like an inferior sex. What is with his "stop acting like a dumb girl" or from the promo he was literally twisting Aaliya's arms.

Ishaan and Malvika, they should really make up their minds about what they want in life and should set their priorities straight. Now that they've started dating again Ishaan should perhaps stop holding Aaliya so close or hugging her every chance he gets. Every time he hugs her the poor girl who's already heartbroken sinks further. 😭😭

I've no idea what's up with Aaliya and Sahil's fancy dress drama, for all we know they are just interns and residents and not well recognized doctors, why couldn't they just put up goggles or different clothes for their disguise. There was no need for a burqa and a beard.

I've seen several shows go down the sewer in terms of storyline just for the heck of bloody TRPs. I'd hate to see this one bite the dust as well.
Jessicarh thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: dsupriya

I agree with all of your points. I did feel bad about Ishaan not trusting heras I felt he need not trust blindly but give some benefit of doubt. But when I think back he was right as suspecting a senor doctor without proof is foolishness. I also though felt that Aaliya and sahil in that get up was OTT. I was rather expecting her to show the report to someone and take the opinion.

I also wanted to make a separate post that why should it be a love triangle always. If they want to patch up ishaan and malavika then so be it. They need not have bought in Aaliya falling in love with Ishaan. Or if they wanted friends to lovers then show malavika moving on. Ishaan also I felt was oblivious to Aaliya feelings was not realistic. Come on even in friendships you draw a line and you can sense when someone is serious about you. You automatically back off if you feel you are being misconstrued. I was bit surprised by that as Ishaan on account of his profession is able to sense it.
Dr Veer the way he was ordering about can be bought to line in this corporate world. I am a professional working woman and I know that last thing you do is take orders from your boss like that. Everything was OTT. And of course his acting is awful and please they are demeaning people in defence by showing that OTT stance. I have my cousins in defence and yes they are very much normal. They do not boss around but yes they tend to dominate at times
To be honest I felt aal the characterization got butchered for sake of love triangle and spice. Dr Malavika also to some extent yesterday I felt was artificial. Do not know what it was.pe
personally I feel Aaliya and Ishaan are good but for me it is old Aaliya. And as a woman I hate it when a woman has to go for a makeover to ensure a romantic interest. Which all the serials love to do. For once would have loved if they had shown love developing out of friendship for simple cute Aaliya without that wig or heavy makeup.That trademark of zindagi wins was missing in last 2 episodes.I want my old characters back. Hope we get them soon




same feelings!!
Being a psychiatrist..he should have sensed it much before that aliya likes him..not as a friend but she is developing a different kind of a feeling for him. Her behavioural changes n her body language..everything toh changed! This is really surprising that he could actually not sense it!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".