Emon is in a no-win situation - Page 2

Originally posted by: lostandfound

In yesterday's Robaroo, Emon was asked who he thinks should be the top 3. This was a very unfair question. No matter which 3 names Emon gives, he is dead.

If he doesn't give Chang's name, then all Chang fans are going to hate him, similarly Ankita fans are targeting him because he did not give her name. And, because he did give his own name, he is now considered arrogant instead of what he truly is, which is gifted and confident. I really think the question to Emon was very unfair.

On the other hand, the question to Prashant was a gift for him and his fans. Because he named himself as over-rated, his fans can say he is humble. Because he named an ex-contestant like Parleen, he is pretty much safe because Parleen fans have probably moved on to supporting Ankita. And naming Chang was also a safe bet because many people do consider Chang over-rated.

So, why did Sony do this? Why give a contestant like Emon such an unfair question and then turn around and give a total "gift" question to Prashant. Doesn't the channel realize that by doing things like this they are virtually guaranteeing that Emon will be out this week? I hate it when the channel plays with these contestants future like this.

Please don't let the channel manipulation sway you from voting for the best. It does not matter if you consider performance more important than singing or vice-versa. The only thing that matters is that you watch the gala each Friday and vote for the best based on the contestants' performance/singing in that gala. Shows like Robaroo and the opinions of ex-contestants like Puja are important, interesting and fun, but when voting, please, please, please, base your vote on who you think is the best in the gala.

Emon ko kaha fasadiya...vaat lag gayee uski

Originally posted by: vishtanny

plz band karo ye topic Its useless

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I agree with the author of this post. It's sad that people start judging someone based on what they see on tv. First Puja's interview and now Emon who didn't mention Ankita. There are a few sensible Ankita fans who do realize that he was just stating his opinion but there are others who feel he didn't mention my favourite so he has a blackheart, is rude, I lost respect for him, he does not deserve the title, etc etc and other idiotic comments.

I think we are all sensible mature people on this forum who do realize that the shows name is Indian Idol and the tagline is woh awaaz joh bharat ki shaan kehla sake. This is what we are looking for. The tagline does not say woh insaan joh bharat ki shaan kehla sake. We are not looking for a prime minister to represent us all, we are looking for a singer whose music we will listen to and enjoy. So once again let's focus on the contestants talent and not their personal lives as none of us know them personally.