Mahakumbh 41-44: Mostly treading water

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Folks,

For starters, my apologies for being a day late with this one. We had a domestic crisis yesterday that took all my time and energy to fix, and even today, I am a bit preoccupied with it.

Next, a statutory warning. This piece has been written mostly in a satirical vein, tongue firmly in cheek. Please do keep that in mind as you read it, and do not take me to task for anything!

Now for the title. I, to my longstanding regret, am not a swimmer, my efforts to start learning after I turned 40 having resulted only in my swallowing excessive quantities of chlorinated water😉. Still, I did learn what treading water means. During the last week, Mahakumbh was, for the most part, treading water. The tale hardly moved forward, while at the same striving mightily to produce an impression of progress by agitating the water.

Large chunks of the telecast time were taken up with, in that order:

-Rudra mooning around the Mahakumbh camp - by now he must be as familiar with every nook and cranny of the place as a London cabbie with every cul de sac in that city😉 - and, when he tires of the exercise, lying down in the sand for a long nap.

Perhaps he was expecting that as once before, Maimuyi would resurface in his dreams, especially since she had told him she would be back. I do not blame Rudra for sleeping in hope, for I myself am by now desperate for Maimuyi to turn up once more. But perhaps Chandrabhan is making up for all that lost time😉, so no such luck!

Thus all we got was a brief flashback of Maimuyi, Siddharth (whom I miss almost as much as I miss her. His talent is hardly being properly exploited in Ashoka, highlighting the cardinal importance of the script and the director for even the best of actors), and the bhindi ki sabzi , before the camera switched back to, what else, a weepy Rudra with his hum (s)mashan ko saath leke chalte hain and sab mujhe chod ke chale jaate hain line.

The irony of his having found such an ever indulgent Daadi, with a ready shoulder for her pota's tears even as he was bemoaning his losses, clearly escapes both Rudra and Utkarsh, or whoever is it writes these lines for Rudra!

I adore Daadi, with her queenly self-assurance and her wonderfully mobile face, for all that she sets my teeth on edge periodically. She is like Humpty Dumpty in Alice in Wonderland: A word means what I say it means, no more and no less!! And that goes for aastha, seva, paramarth, amar.. the list is a long one! 😉And I am very fond of Rudra, for all that he has been driving me up the wall this last fortnight with his Devdas obsession. But when they get together, which they did twice this last week, the net result is exasperating.

When she is not lamenting his man ka bojh, which is like a patthar ki bori, she is pronouncing non sequiters such as Jab tak sukhaant nahin hota, tab tak kahani ka anth nahin hota. She has clearly never heard of Laila-Majnun or Shirin-Farhad,even if one leaves Romeo-Juliet aside! 😉

Nor could I quite understand what she meant by Rudra and Maya being linked together by a karm ka bandhan, which was stronger than a prem ka bandhan. Though I must say that I sat up when she actually said that she agreed with Shivanand on this last, and I love her occasionally natty one liners, such as Agar door jaane se hi mukti mil jaati, to saare bhanware (bhagode? If that is correct, apologies, and thanks to Shubha!) mukti paa jaate!

-Maya doing seva, in tiny bytes, in the Kalpataru Seva Ashram. During this lo..ong segment, Maya seemed to be on the lookout for shawls to be adjusted, patients to be made to lie down, a jhadoo to be deployed till the asli jhadoowali rushed up to reclaim it, photos to be picked up and restored to, as it turned out Rudra' mother (I protest formally at this point: why was there no roll of drums to herald her resurrection?) , kids to be given sweets, food packets+bottled water to be handed out to any unwary passerby😉. And finally, errands to run for anyone standing around, in this last case Rudra's mom again, who promptly launched into a mini-pravachan about how all that she wanted would be found at this Mahakumbh.

When none of the aforesaid was ready at hand, Maya coped by gazing at Rudra, his lost-little-boy-yearning-for-something-in- the-candy- store look firmly in place, out of the corner of her eye. At times it even looked as though she had eyes at the back of her head! She kept this up till Rudra remembered her Maimuyi ki kasam, and ambled away, just in time for her to spot another shawl to be adjusted!😉

It all looked very far from convincing. By Thursday night, I was so fed up with this ersatz amar prem kahani that the precap came as a great relief ! Because there, standing besides Maya in kaan pakadna mode in front of Rudra, Daadi (who has a lot riding on Rudra's obsession with Maya overriding the counterpull of Shivanand's mission) intoned solemnly : Rudra ke jeevan mein aur koyi saath de ya na de (surely she is not counting herself in here?) lekin tumhara aur uska rishta uske jeevan ke har naye purane rishte se kahin bada hoga...A roll of drums was needed to herald this momentous pronouncement, but it was not forthcoming😉.

Daadi cheered me up no end with this obiter dictum. At least now we need have no more of this moping and mooning around, I rejoiced. But then my heart sank as it hit me that in Mahakumbh, a precap is merely a statement of intent, which may materialize only a week or more down the road. Oh Lord, when will I stop harking back to Saras and Kumud (the wonderfully romantic lead pair of Saraswatichandra, in which Gautam Rode played Saras, whence the comparison) ?

- The Kaliyug ka Shravan Kumar, complete with the classic basket doli for a blind mother. He was actually only one quarter of the original Shravan Kumar, who carried both his blind parents on his shoulders, whereas this chap needs his brother to help carry just their mother.

The issue dealt with concerned a very sad facet of human nature, especially in today's materialistic existence. That some of us, mercifully a small minority, sink so far as to abandon those who gave us life, and nurtured us to adulthood with love and care, to misery, deprivation and death is horrible even to think about. So well deserved moral outrage among the viewers is guaranteed. But it was difficult to understand why so much time, over 8 minutes, was devoted to this disconnected segment, which did not seem to have any significance in terms of plot development. It was not even to bring Rudra to the Kalpataru Seva Ashram, for thanks to Charles and his Mission Maya, Rudra has already seen her there. So why??

A few stray advances: I say mostly treading water because there was some forward movement in a few areas:

- Rudra's mother resurfaces: As noted above, Rudra's unmissed (sic) mother (I have noted earlier how strange it is that Rudra, after learning from Daadi that she was not in the ashram when it was attacked in 1989, still makes no attempt to trace his mother) made a surprisingly low key reappearance. This was , even if only indirectly, courtesy Maya (Shruthi may take a bow for having explained this is advance). She did seem to be in fairly good shape, thus testifying to the strength of the social service network in Allahabad, which appears to have kept her safe for all of 24 years, as she apparently had no family.

She seems to make a habit of wandering around of a morning clutching her family photos, not in an album, but held loose😉. When Maya picks up a stray one and restores it to her, it is pointedly held up for the camera, so that we can get confirmation of who the lady with the photos is (not that we needed it, for Shruti Ulfat looks exactly the same as in 1989). But Maya also carefully avoids looking at it. But why? She has not seen any baby photo of Rudra's and she would hardly recognize him from this photo!

-The Saraswati tracker: Prof. Rao has got hold of a "state of the art"gizmo to track the vilupt Saraswati, and has coaxed Shivanand to use it under the Saraswati Kund. As he puts it somewhat mystifyingly: Hum Saraswati Kund ke zameen ke neeche paani ke jeevan ka ansh dhoondenge. Agar wo humein milta hai, phir dhoondenge pani ka sroth kya hai, aur uska Sector 53 se kya talluk hai.

NB: The mystery of Sector 53: a recap: The problem sector for the Project Ganga is Sector 53, the one which was allocated to Professor Rao, an allocation that was then ferociously opposed by Balivesh, clearly ignorant of the strength of the Rao-DM Tiwari connection. Now , Prof. Rao tells the DM to organise that sector, and use the funds that will soon be available for the Project Ganga, for their own secret work in that sector. Which he proceeds to do, for when Shivanand calls him to check whether it was not Tiwari in the Brahma Nisht Panth tent (where his Garuda Locator has spotted 2 garuds with Rudra), he is actually holding a meeting in Sector 53, in Daraganj.

That is also the sector about which Balivesh is still pressurising Tiwari, to give it to the Sri Santh Panth. Before his conversation with Rudra, he was telling a sidekick to tell the DM that the permission was needed immediately, and if it was not forthcoming, he would go to the DM's office not with an anurodh, but with an aagnya!
_________________________________________________________________________

Professor Rao, citing a highly confidential ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) survey report on the course of the river Saraswati, notes that it arose from the Himalayas, traversed Haryana, Rajasthan and Gujarat, to end up in the Gulf of Kutch. I did not know that the ISRO spends valuable satellite survey time on such esoteric pursuits, but I am sure the good professor has a devoted past student, another Tiwari, tucked away there as well😉. He moves in the top official circles, does our professor; note that he got that gizmo thru a Lieutenant General!

Now Prof. Rao wants to make sure that this vilupt Saraswati has migrated to where he needs her, at the Triveni Sangam in Prayag, in time for this once in 144 years Mahakumbh. Whence his pep talk to an unwilling Shivanand, who, unsurprisingly, wants to concentrate on his hunt for the missing garudas. An of course on his struggle to put some merudand into the recalcitrant garuda pramukh, ie Rudra, who right now seems to have spaghetti in place of the aforesaid body part. 😉

Rao manages to bring Shivanand round, it is not for nothing that his ex-students adore him and touch his feet without fail every time they meet him!

Shivanand's deep set eyes now gleam at the wonderful prospect: Ab Saraswati Kund phir se jeevit ho uthega.7 garud bhi ek honge.Aur amrit bhi humein hi milega.

Clearly, he has not yet thought of what would happen to him when he is actually digging underneath the Saraswati Kund in the ruined Brahma Nisht Panth ashram, and is caught red-handed by his mother. That is a prospect too fearful to contemplate!😉

No amrit grab by Rao-Shivanand in the works : Now, I am not one of those who, after hearing such comments from Prof. Rao and Shivanand, seem to have started harboring dark suspicions that the duo are after an amrit grab. The mission of the sapta garudas is to keep the amrit from being seized by evil forces who will misuse it horrendously. How best can this be done?Why, by getting it themselves, and hiding it in an ultra safe place where it will be protected from the dark forces out to get it. That is what Rao and Shivanand mean, and we need not tie ourselves in knots with unwarranted worries! At least this is what I feel.

-The Dark Garuda. Aka Kill Bill Katherine, the Greek girl at No. 23 in Interpol's list of suspects to be watched at the Mahakumbh, and the only one of those not yet investigated satisfactorily.

She clearly is a Garuda, for Rudra sees her garuda chinna in his vision. But what could be called a Dark Garuda for now, since one presumes she does not yet know exactly what the elaborate sign on her lower back signifies and implies, for all that she asserts rebelliously to Greyerson, when he suggests that she should she should tell Shivanand her secret, ie that she is also a garuda: That was not part of the plan..There is a reason why I am the chosen one. I will not do this.Rebellion that is instantly squashed by Greyeron with a veiled threat Yaad karo kaun hai tumhare swami (presumably His Eminence the Cardinal)..I will not give this gyaan again..Kuch bhi ho sakta hai.

As and when she does get to learn all about the unique mission of a garuda, she might turn, and become a garuda mole in the Greyerson camp.

Incidentally, the way in which she was sticking spycams into the straw of the roof and the walls was also very funny. They could fall out in a strong wind, or if a passing cow took a fancy to the straw and decided to brunch off it!😉😉 Morever, they were all facing inwards into the room she was occupying!

She is one tough girl, is our Katherine. I loved her sassiness and her almost off hand putting down of the Veshes. And true to type, Naanu did not resent that, unlike the angry MCP Balivesh, but actually praised her for her rann neeti.

Round and round: So now we have an odd scenario: Katharine keeping an eye on Shivanand and trying to win his confidence on the one hand, and on the other, Shivanand planning to do the same with her. Not only because Prof. Rao asks him to do so, fearing that she might be a danger to the garudas, but also because Katharine par nazar rakhne ke liye hamare pas ek aur wajah bhi hai. But what other reason can he have?

The merudand fiasco: There is no Take 5 this time, but just a Take 1, and it was good enough for at least 3 standard issue scenes, if not 5! This is the one in Shivanand's underground retreat, to which he takes Rudra after a moving conversation in the mela grounds.

That conversation, by the way, put paid to any feeling that Shivanand is not a loving father. He lays his heart bare to his son: 24 varsh apnon se door raha. Ekaant vaas mein kayi yatanayen sahin, par toote nahin, kyonki tumse milne ki ummeed abhi baaki thi. Vishwas tha ki is Mahakumbh mein tumse avashya milenge, aur 24 saal ke ghaav ek hi kshan mein bhar jayenge.

And he feels so much for Rudra's sufferings during these years that he says Yahan aakar tumse milkar jaana ki humse bade hain ghaav tumhare.

Even when he seeks Rudra's help in his mission, he is not authoritarian, he explains and requests. Humari kuch apekshayen hain jinhein keval tum poorna kar sakte ho. .Is kshan keval itna socho beta,ki tumhein apne uddeshya ki or badna hai,Kayi varsh humne is din ki pratiksha mein bitaye ki tum apne is pita ki varshon ki pratignya ko poorna karne mein sahayata karoge.

To Shivanand's delight, Rudra responds: Ji, Baba. Alas, he cannot keep this word of his.

To begin with, Rudra who, outside at the mela campgrounds, did not even ask his father where he had been held prisoner for 24 years, is barely interested in the fascinating celestial display put up inside Shiva's lab. Anyone else would have peppered Shiva with questions, but not Rudra. He is still marooned in the midst of an ocean of misery.

I was more in despair than Shivanand when Rudra barely responds to Shivanand's pep talk: Panchi ko udna aur sher ke bachche ko shikar sikhana nahin padta (clearly Shivanand has never seen any of David Attenborough's marvellous wild life films!)..Tumhare bheetar wo gyan sanchit hai jiska tumhein anumaan nahin hai...Samay aa gaya hai ki tum apne sanchit karma ko apna prarabdha karma, yani apna bhagya bana lo..

The sole exception, and that too involuntary, came when Shivanand tells him that the chinna that he sees within the cloud floating overhead is wo satya jise moorkh nahin dekh sakte, wo hi dekh sakte hain jinke pas gyaan drishti ho.. Vimoodha na pashyanti.. When Rudra involuntarily completes the quote with a sudden Pashyanti gyaanachakshushaha, Shivanand looks down at his son with pride and quiet triumph.

But this does not last. Having gazed with only mild curiosity at the celestial display, Rudra is more alarmed than captivated by his father's exhortations: Apni smritiyon ki bhulakar bas rakshakon par dhyan do..Satya dekhne ke liye tumhein maya ke pare dekhna hoga..Maya mithya hai, jhoot hai..Satya ko pehchaano..

Clinging to his sole obsession these days, Maya, he declares that maya is not, as Shivanand asserts, mithya, jhoot, but hamare liye sabse bada sach. He does not understand that when referring to Maya, he and his father were both talking of different things.

Like a skittish colt that is afraid of the bridle, Rudra jibs and refuses - Humse nahin hoga - and, finally, bolts. To cap it all, he leaves the secret entrance to the underground refuge open.😡

In Shivanand's place I would have been tearing my hair and climbing the wall, but he merely sighs and takes a long look around his room. His lament, however, reflects the deep despair that is beginning to haunt him: Jab tak tumhein ekagrata nahin aati, Rudra, baki sab (garuds) ek nahin ho paayenge.Aur agar hum ek nahin ho paye, to pralay aa jaayega..

No wonder that when he next meets his guru, Prof. Rao, Shivanand voices his fears about the tendency towards emotional weakness that has always affected the performance of the garudas , and which was now crippling his son, and thus the mission where he is the garuda pramukh. For the first time ever, this iron man betrays, with this bout of depression, that he is all too human.

The stark difference between the outlooks of the father and the son was never more clearly brought out than when Rudra pleads later with his father: Apne parivaar ki raksha ke liye, daadi ki ichcha ka maan rakh lijiye naa! Shivanand's response - Parivaron ke rakshak hote hain, rakshakon k parivaar nahin hote - is a classic of its kind. Thus does a soldier think and act, for the greater cause, not that of his own family. If not, he could never go to war to protect his country. And here, what is at stake is the future of all of humanity.

But this is what neither Rudra nor his Daadi can grasp.

Incidentally, Rudra's plea put paid to the argument advanced here after he sided openly with Daadi against his father, that it was merely a tactic that he had adopted in order to effect a reconciliation between Daadi and his Baba. It was clearly no such thing. Rudra is on the same page as Daadi, and he has, as of now, no stomach for or interest in his father's mission.

I suppose another dozen episodes, if not more, will be consumed in getting Rudra to swivel by 180 degrees on this issue, for the pace is far too slow and has been so all this week. That will bring us to near the mid-point of 60 episodes.

A mental block: Coming back to Daadi - whose ultra erect carriage would have delighted Miss Marple - entirely by chance, I stumbled on her exhortations to Shiva in his youth, as a voiceover when Shivanand is wandering over their ruined ashram (in Episode 32). I had not paid as much attention to it when I watched that episode. Her lines are very revealing as to her relationship with him, which, it is clear, depends on how far he is prepared to fit in with the Brahma Nisht Panth tradition of nishkaama seva, and to follow strictly in the footsteps of his forefathers.

She wants him to remember that he is the next uttaradhikari of the Brahma Nisht Panth, with the duty to protect and serve all those who seek their help. You are working too hard, she adds with unexpected solicitude, you should look after yourself as well (so that the seva can be done without any break).

Then there is the bit about the need for him, and for his children after him, to keep the Saraswati Kund flowing, akshunna. In this context, your interpretation that by ek boond of amrit, she means Rudra, is very interesting and imaginative.

Unsaid, but implied in all this relatively gentle and almost affectionate monologue (for there is no indication of any response from Shivanand, at least as far as he remembers the scene) is that he has to adhere to the age old traditions and beliefs on his ancestors, and carry on their good work without any break, or any questioning of its rationale.

But of course he does not comply, and so Daadi's attitude goes to the other extreme, of sarcastic disapproval, almost hostility, and public snubs and putdowns. Above all, she exerts herself to distance Rudra from his father, and his father's "dangerous" ideas.

Given this mental block, she cannot understand that just because they and their Panth want time to stand still, it will not do so. And if they do not recognise the mortal danger threatening all of mankind, not just their Panth, and move fast to checkmate it, there will be no Panth and no traditions to be maintained either. That is pure ostrich-like behaviour, and she wants to make a baby ostrich out of her morose, clueless pota as well.

So folks, this is it. I am leaving out Charles, who is getting less irritating and more appealing by the episode, and DM Tiwari as well. As for Naanu, the pity is that he left himself out, bar that scene of the dressing down from Katharine!😉

Shyamala B.Cowsik

PS: Something I forgot. There is some surprise in the forum about Charles calling Rudra Mahabali. This was the title Charles gave the teenage Rudra after he won that impossibly tough bout against the champion in the akhada. He has simply revived the title now.

Edited by sashashyam - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

83

Views

7.1k

Users

22

Likes

328

Frequent Posters

Swetha-Sai thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
^ Excellent analysis of the episodes of Mahakumbh by u, Shyamala di! 👏🤗
Hope.. ur knee problem has improved.. 👍🏼.
As the saying goes.. "This too shall pass" --> i hope that ur domestic crisis will also pass away!
SingaporeFan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Oh finally Shyamaladi...was waiting eagerly for your post And the wait was worth it...

Am also totally fed up with Rudra and his Maya obsession...and his 'humse nahi hoga' was totally unheroic! But I guess a Reluctant Hero makes for great storytelling ...but his character is so annoying and frustrating now... Was so ironic that he is scolding random people for abandoning their Mother while his own Mother is missing and he is making no effort or even a thought to finding her!!

Loving Shvanand and yes Charles is growing on me too...


Edited by SingaporeFan - 10 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Shymaladi I was waiting for your analysis to put forth my points. I knew what will be your analysis on Shiva and Rudra and you had not disappointment me. You have wrote it exactly the way I had anticipated it😆. Especially Shiva as a loving father and that dialogue rakshok ke parivaar nahin hote hain. I am fine with all your other takes especially Katherine. I am loving her. I am even loving Dr Rao and his meticulous way of doing things. Now let me play the devil's advocate for Shiva and Rudra.
First I will start with Shiva. Well he had lived all the 24 years in anticipation of meeting his son Rudra. Fine no issues about that for me. But I have some other issues with him. I need answers satisfactorily to these questions.
- Well it is now that Shiva had heard his wife has died. What when he was in captivity. At that point he didn't know what happened to her right. So why no thought about seeing her. Even when Shiva was in captivity his memories were about Rudra, when he came home it was again about Rudra. Why his wife not once came into the picture. Don't you think it is abnormal for a married man. I am not expecting him to be majnu, but a single thought atleast the moment in which the child was born and they cherished it as a couple.
- Now again he knows she died. Again I don't want him to take bottles and run around the streets calling meri patni, but a single drop of tear, a private moment in memory of the woman who shared his life. No I didn't see that.
The total absence of his wife's presence in his memories make me think that Rudra's mother was only a means for Shiva to get the sarvashresth Garud. He knew by reading books his son will be sarvashesth Garud and to get the Garud he needed a wife. For Dadi she was the means to take vansh forward, for Shiva a means for his so called Amrit saving mission. She never had an identity in that house apart from being Rudra's mother
Now coming to the most important point Parivaron ke Rakshak hote hain, Rakshak ke parivaar nahin.
According to you the intrapration is families have protectors, but a true protector has no family. If this is the intrapretation I want to ask some more questions
-Understand most of the mission freak people like Bhagat Singh, APJ, and Mother Theresa were single people. . The letter Bhagat Singh writes to his mother in the movie Rang De Basanti comes to my mind. Though not the exact words but the content goes like this. " Mother I know you want to bring a bride for me. But understand the soil of Bharat is my bride". This man lived and died for Bharat whom he called his bride and his love.
- But Shiva married. In front of the sacred fire he made a promise to the woman that he in his best of his abilities will protect her. I want to know what he has done to keep this promise. Because as I said above I don't see her presence in any of his memories. And if anyone wants to say he has a bigger role of protecting Amrit let me tell you one thing. World would have been deprived of one of its greatest protector if a man hadn't pleaded before an evil king for his wife and underwent the unimaginable torture of watching his 6 babies killed in the most brutal manner. If he had run away that day allowing his wife to the fate, think of the fate of this world. I am not mentioning the names as by reading it you will know whom I am referring to.
Now coming to my intrapretation of what I make out of those lines. If only I tell that I can ask more questions.
According to me everyone tries to save their families. But for a true protector he has to protect people who are required to establish Dharma in the world. In other words the choice of the protector has to be based on Dharma. To explain it more clearly in a given situation he should never give undue to privilege to the member of his family, neither he should discard them. Whether the person is within family or outside family the choice of protection has to be done solely on the basis of dharma. It is a very tough task as it is painful also because there will be times you will have let go of your family member, at the same time you have to hear the flak that you protected a family member out of favourtism. A true protector needs to be emotionally strong to bear this and do his duty so that dharma can be protected.
Now having said that I want to ask Shiva he read a lot. He knew his son was the sarvashesth Garud. So what measures did he take to protect the child till he was in a position to handle things of his own.
By the look of it I feel nothing was done. It seems he was expecting Sarvashesth Garud to start fighting from the day he was born 😆😆😆. No precautions for saving himself and his child. How did he expect Amrit to be saved without the 2 Garuds.
Now again don't come back and tell me destiny knew it, destiny took protection in its hands as Garud is needed to protect Amrit etc..if Destiny could do that many things then no need for Shiva or Rudra to do anything. Destiny will simply help them save Amrit. Sit in a corner.
So for me I see Shiva as a failed husband and also a failed protector as far as the information I have at this point. Also his understanding of that line is very much skewed.
So I stop with Shiva and now coming to Rudra. Rudra to me is suffering from guilt pangs. He doesn't love Maya. But he is guilty of the fact that he didn't trust Maimui enough. That guilt is eating him through. Unfortuantely its manifestation is coming out as love for Maya, whereas the true guilt feeling lies buried. Given the circumstances especially Dadi, Shiva and other people harping on Maya the illusion is strengthened whereas the truth is getting buried deeper and deeper. Coming to his feelings for mom. For him at this point the word Mother is connected to Maimui only and especially with this guilt of not trusting her judgement he is unable to think about anything.
Now coming to Dadi and her Karm se bandhe dialogue. I have also told earlier Dadi is manipulative and wants to hold the power. Like many woman who doesn't want their sons to trust their wives because if they trust their wives they fear they will lose power. She wants Maya only to take the vansh forward, not for Rudra to trust her. In other words she is harping on Rudra's moh which she doesn't want to turn into Prem. Because Moh is only an attraction which weaknes a person but can give the physical union and give what Dadi wants. But Prem is much a deeper emotion. It is not based on just physical union but based on mutual trust and understanding between partners . Prem or true love can never be someone's weakness, it can only be a strength.
Dadi knows this and she does not want Rudra out of her control. So this big big dialogues of karma ka bandhan, prem ka bandhan nahi,not sure whether Maya ka pyaar sacha blah blah.
But for me there is hope for Rudra. Though at this point he is disoriented from his goal due to the moh of Maya he is not deaf and blind. The protector in him can hear a hungry voice and see the painful situation an old blind lady is put into. A man who can feed the hungry in their hour of need and provide shelter for the abandoned in their hour of need can of course save humanity if his protective instinct is given the correct direction or rather I say mentoring.
For that most probably Dadi and Shiva will have bow down in front of one woman. Ganga the woman who so very much is invisible to them. Without her naa Brahma Nisht pant ka na duniya ka udhar hoga
Long winding post, but hope it is interesting for you to read.
Edited by shruthiravi - 10 years ago
berrysweet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
And hello yet again!
That was a good, funny read . Now, I have a husband shaking his head over his giggling wife. I enjoyed it all.. every bit . Mostly I love your ' treading in water" . Treading indeed... through out the week ... ...absolutely tiring.

I still do miss the young Rudra . He was captivating. However , I would refrain from comparing big Rudra and little Rudra. I am not healthy enough to do that. The girls will throw me out of this forum. I love this forum too much, to risk it!!!!

When I read your post , and all the replies you get, I am convinced that I am surrounded by scholars of all subjects, Do you know how daunting it is? I have decided that I will not even dare try to sound intelligent. I would calmly remain the jester and enjoy it all.

Let me tell you, only this today. Rudra was annoying. I felt like giving him a slap . Actually, I should be more sympathetic because I know that when they are young, love is the biggest problem EVER! Who cares about the world rotting away, being in love and all its little problems are all that matters. I am old enough and thus have the license to say " Young People!"😉

As for domestic crisis . Thank God for them. It just means that life is going on.😛

Thank you for tirelessly entertaining us . Love Bash












happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

EDIT - In my hurry, forgot to say I thoroughly enjoyed reading your post...😊 Must say the domestic crisis did not hamper your style at all.,. 😉

I thought there was some progress made this week, although at a less-than breakneck pace(!) - One was the steady deepening of fissures in both camps - between Dadi & Siva on the BNP side, and between Greyerson & Veshes on the other; the tension between Greyerson & Kat was also intriguing.

Introduction of Rudr's Ma (who I hear is called Ganga - another Name there!) and the revelation of details of Rao's plans for Mission Amrit - the pardafaarsh of Kat - all of this happened, but mostly we floundered in the sea of Rudr's sorrows!😉

I loved that cameo of Greyerson as palm-reader - it was quite hilarious and I dont quite know why but it reminded me of Kipling's Kim!

The "Piya tora..." that formed the BGM for Rudr's riverside vigil is a favourite number of mine - I'm afraid it's been a bit damaged for me by this inappropriate picturisation...😡

I have always had a soft corner for Charles, and now I watch him coming into his own with a bit of proprietorial pride, I must say!! And Charles has begun to address our Hero as "Mahaabali" Rudr! I feel he may have used that term when they first met as teenagers and is now resurrecting it as a token of friendship and admiration, for the grownup Rudr has in past week done nothing to merit that title... TM too used that Name when speaking to Rudr "ye kha le, Mahaabali ban ja!"

I guess that things will soon change on that front! Waiting on it...😃

Phew. Made it to page 1...😊 Shutting down now. Mission Accomplished...🥳

Originally posted by: sashashyam

.... The tale hardly moved forward, while at the same striving mightily to produce an impression of progress by agitating the water. Large chunks of the telecast time was taken up with, in that order:-Rudra mooning around the Mahakumbh camp -Maya doing seva, in tiny bytes, in the Kalpataru Seva Ashram. - The Kaliyug ka Shravan Kumar - Succinct!

...The irony of his having found such an ever indulgent Daadi, with a ready shoulder for her pota's tears even as he was bemoaning his losses, clearly escapes both Rudra and Utkarsh, or whoever is it writes these lines for Rudra! Hehe the irony escaped me as well, thanks for pointing it out!! ...

...Nor could I quite understand what she meant by Rudra and Maya being linked together by a karm ka bandhan, which was stronger than a prem ka bandhan. Though I must say that I sat up when she actually said that she agreed with Shivanand on this last, and I love her occasionally natty one liners, such as Agar door jaane se hi mukti mil jaati, to saare bhanware (I thought she said bhagode) mukti paa jaate! Just occasionally, Dadi reminds me of the Dowager Duchess in Downton Abbey.. This was definitely one of those.

... But then my heart sank as it hit me that in Mahakumbh, a precap is merely a statement of intent, which may materialize only a week or more down the road. Oh I so totally empathise with that, After last week's exemplary record, they were totally off-track again with the pre caps! Oh Lord, when will I stop harking back to Saras and Kumud! What on earth do you mean??????

... When Maya picks up a stray one and restores it to her, it is pointedly held up for the camera, so that we can get confirmation of who the lady with the photos is (not that we needed it, for Shruti Ulfat looks exactly the same as in 1989). But Maya also carefully avoids looking at it. But why? She has not seen any baby photo of Rudra's and she would hardly recognize him from this photo! The day Rudr and Maya land up in Allahabad, Nanu asks Maya to fetch Rudr's family photo from his bedside table - that was roughly the same picture as this dropped photo

-The Saraswati tracker: This whole track is intended to confuse. Satellite evidence of a westward-flowing river presented to show its connection with Allahabad? Traces of water below Saraswatikund, and mystical connection with Sector 53...

...Shivanand's deep set eyes now gleam at the wonderful prospect: Ab Saraswati Kund phir se jeevit ho uthega.7 garud bhi ek honge.Aur amrit bhi humein hi milega. Clearly, he has not yet thought of what would happen to him when he is actually digging underneath the Saraswati Kund in the ruined Brahma Nisht Panth ashram, and is caught red-handed by his mother. That is a prospect too fearful to contemplate!😉 I like that mental picture. Wicked!

No amrit grab by Rao-Shivanand in the works : Now, I am not one of those who, after hearing such comments from Prof. Rao and Shivanand, seem to have started harboring dark suspicions that the duo are after an amrit grab. The mission of the sapta garudas is to keep the amrit from being seized by evil forces who will misuse it horrendously. How best can this be done?Why, by getting it themselves, and hiding it in an ultra safe place where it will be protected from the dark forces out to get it. That is what Rao and Shivanand mean, and we need not tie ourselves in knots with unwarranted worries! At least this is what I feel. Roger, Roger!

...She is one tough girl, is our Katherine. I loved her sassiness and her almost off hand putting down of the Veshes. And true to type, Naanu did not resent that, unlike the angry MCP Balivesh, but actually praised her for her ranneeti. Oh Nanu was definitely the more sanguine of the two, but I thought he was praising Greyerson not Kat

Round and round (...the Brahmanisht flagpole!): So now we have an odd scenario: Katharine keeping an eye on Shivanand and trying to win his confidence on the one hand, and on the other, Shivanand planning to do the same with her. Not only because Prof. Rao asks him to do so, fearing that she might be a danger to the garudas, but also because Katharine par nazar rakhne ke liye hamare pas ek aur wajah bhi hai. But what other reason can he have? I too, wondered about that!

... Having gazed with only mild curiosity at the celestial display, Rudra is more alarmed than captivated by his father's exhortations: Apni smritiyon ki bhulakar bas rakshakon par dhyan do..Satya dekhne ke liye tumhein maya ke pare dekhna hoga..Maya mithya hai, jhoot hai..Satya ko pehchaano...Clinging to his sole obsession these days, Maya, he declares that maya is not, as Shivanand asserts, mithya, jhoot, but hamare liye sabse bada sach. He does not understand that when referring to Maya, he and his father were both talking of different things. Imagine how difficult this scene would have been if Maya was differently-named!😆

...Like a skittish colt that is afraid of the bridle, Rudra jibs and refuses - Humse nahin hoga - and, finally, bolts. ...😆

...To cap it all, he leaves the secret entrance to the underground refuge open.Yeah I have had this foreboding about that place too, This week when they showed Siva/ Rudr entering/leaving the baoli they used overhead shots as if from the PoV of someone spying on them, maybe Kat - she really does seem to be 'sarvavyaapi'! 😳

...The stark difference between the outlooks of the father and the son was never more clearly brought out than when Rudra pleads later with his father: Apne parivaar ki raksha ke liye, daadi ki ichcha ka maan rakh lijiye naa! Shivanand's response - Parivaron ke rakshak hote hain, rakshakon k parivaar nahin hote - is a classic of its kind. This was in a precap, wasnt it? ...

Edited by happychappy - 10 years ago
Arijit007 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
great, rudra ko fillhaal apne vyathit hriday aur uljhe mashishk ke saath chodke baaki vishyaon ki charchaa karte hain. kat and shiva started a cat and mous game in today's epi, and shyamla i like the name you have given kat , 'the dark garuda'. i think dadi may learn about her mistake soon.
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Arijit007

great, rudra ko fillhaal apne vyathit hriday aur uljhe mashishk ke saath chodke baaki vishyaon ki charchaa karte hain. kat and shiva started a cat and mous game in today's epi, and shyamla i like the name you have given kat , 'the dark garuda'. i think dadi may learn about her mistake soon.


Arijit, I just wrote cat and mouse game in my post - what coincidence


Shyamala,

I thoroughly enjoyed your satirical post! Treading on water it was

But I still have my reservations about shiva and prof Rao

By recreating sangam and making amrit reappear, aren't they going to create a situation that will lead to war?

And shiva - who wants amrit to fulfill his mother's wish - doesn't he realise what a dangerous game that is?

And I am even more upset with his 'love' for his son then - he wants Rudra then to dedicate his whole life to protect amrit then

For jahan amrit hoga wahan usko chahne wale bhi bahut honge

Poora jeevan Rudra ko uski raksha mein lagana hoga

Is shiva right in his quest?

I don't think so!

Is Rudra entitled to be in love and not wanting his dad to seek amrit, becasue it will jeopardize their lives

- yes!
annu123.happy thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Nice post Shyamala di . In this Maya saga , mk seems to have temporarily lost its grip . And my untrained eyes and mind refuse to accept the current Rudra . As one of my friends said "sher ka role tha aur memna bana kar rakha hai " . To me rudra looks more dejected and depressed rather than in love . I know this is only transitional but these days Manish wadhwa looks like larger than life superhero . And this dadi as u said has no mobiliityon her face with the same hard wooden expression. I know Maya part is crucial but this love story is really irritating . To me maya - rudra love story is the weakest link in mk and it has completely failed to make a connect . In contrast to his son , shivanand is completely emotionally blunt. Hopefully this phase is only transitory and the former pace and thrill of mk would be back soon
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sashashyam


Next, a statutory warning. This piece has been written mostly in a satirical vein, tongue firmly in cheek. Please do keep that in mind as you read it, and do not take me to task for anything!

What else did the week's episodes deserve? Ambling like a bullock cart driven by a reluctant bullock..😳

-Rudra mooning around the Mahakumbh camp - by now he must be as familiar with every nook and cranny of the place as a London cabbie with every cul de sac in that city😉 - and, when he tires of the exercise, lying down in the sand for a long nap.

William Davies did not meet this Rudr before he penned the lines

What is this life if, full of care,

We have no time to stand and stare.

No time to stand beneath the boughs

And stare as long as sheep or cows.


Our Rudr has all the time in the world to stand and stare that too with all the tears.



I adore Daadi, with her queenly self-assurance and her wonderfully mobile face, for all that she sets my teeth on edge periodically. She is like Humpty Dumpty in Alice in Wonderland: A word means what I say it means, no more and no less!! And that goes for aastha, seva, paramarth, amar.. the list is a long one! 😉

Daadi can give tough competition to our begumsa for sure.



When she is not lamenting his man ka bojh, which is like a patthar ki bori, she is pronouncing non sequiters such as Jab tak sukhaant nahin hota, tab tak kahani ka anth nahin hota. She has clearly never heard of Laila-Majnun or Shirin-Farhad,even if one leaves Romeo-Juliet aside! 😉


She has probably seen Om Shanti Om recently and thinks that our Devdas Rudr canbe easy manipulated with such hopeful dialogues From her own version even Daadaji didn't seem to have had any sukhaant. Let alone sukhaant, i wonder if he would have had any sukhaarambh or sukhmadhya with his Mrs.Ostrich.

Nor could I quite understand what she meant by Rudra and Maya being linked together by a karm ka bandhan, which was stronger than a prem ka bandhan.

Boo! Nothing more than another manipulative dialogue using highsouding words like the village school master.🤣


-Maya doing seva, in tiny bytes, in the Kalpataru Seva Ashram. During this lo..ong segment, Maya seemed to be on the lookout for shawls to be adjusted, patients to be made to lie down, a jhadoo to be deployed till the asli jhadoowali rushed up to reclaim it, photos to be picked up and restored to, as it turned out Rudra' mother (I protest formally at this point: why was there no roll of drums to herald her resurrection?) , kids to be given sweets, food packets+bottled water to be handed out to any unwary passerby😉. And finally, errands to run for anyone standing around, in this last case Rudra's mom again, who promptly launched into a mini-pravachan about how all that she wanted would be found at this Mahakumbh.

🤣

When none of the aforesaid was ready at hand, Maya coped by gazing at Rudra, his lost-little-boy-yearning-for-something-in- the-candy- store look firmly in place, out of the corner of her eye. At times it even looked as though she had eyes at the back of her head! She kept this up till Rudra remembered her Maimuyi ki kasam, and ambled away, just in time for her to spot another shawl to be adjusted!😉

Her seva routine also includes supporting people who can anyway walk by themselves too, looking more sorrowful than those in distress so they they may forget their own sorrows and try to console her.


Daadi cheered me up no end with this obiter dictum. At least now we need have no more of this moping and mooning around, I rejoiced. But then my heart sank as it hit me that in Mahakumbh, a precap is merely a statement of intent, which may materialize only a week or more down the road.

Ashoka has also taken cue from mk in its precap idea.

- The Kaliyug ka Shravan Kumar, complete with the classic basket doli for a blind mother. He was actually only one quarter of the original Shravan Kumar, who carried both his blind parents on his shoulders, whereas this chap needs his brother to help carry just their mother.

Aunty, now Shravan Kumar is really going to get upset with you for calling the rat king by his name.🤣


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".