Controversial decisions in WC 2015.

AllBlacks1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
So, this topic is about controversies in general, mostly the decision makings by umpires/captains, fued between players/ teams, technical aspects of the game as well as human errors... anything that raise the eyebrow or keeps us speechless or angry... lets put all that in this thread. 😊
So far, I will pick few incidents in brief.

- Adharmasena the umpire... when umpire given out to an LBW appeal, the ball becomes dead so runout is out of question. After DRS, the LBW was turned down but he still gave the batsman out for runout ? What? He had ample time to consult his fellow umpire and 3rd umpire but still ... This MF shud be kicked out if he dont retire. I dont want see him in any India game untill then.

- Indo pak match. Akmal was caught behind with faintest of edge, the sniko wasnt conclusive but the ball deviated... acc to commentators, it was 50/50, benefit of the doubt shud go to batsman.. but its wasnt to be. Afterall Dhoni asked for the review.. the reputation.

- Same game, Dhawan was given runout, his bat was on the line when the bell lit up... but hang on, bells has to be dislodged and thats the frame U shud freeze to see if the bat is over the line. Just one frame. The problem with these light up stumps and bells is they lit up at first strike and blurr the vision if the bells r in the air or not. Anyways, Dhawan had to go.

- I hate BCCI for being so cocky, why the f**k they didnt allow Hot spot technology? Its much more reliable than sniko and in conjunction with both, so many caught beind and LBW decisions can be certain.

So, U guys can add any issues U think worth mentioning as the WC progresses. So that those issues dont get burried in locked up threads. 😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

3.4k

Users

12

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

BeingBlunt thumbnail

WPL Wizzards

Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: AllBlacks1

So, this topic is about controversies in general, mostly the decision makings by umpires/captains, fued between players/ teams, technical aspects of the game as well as human errors... anything that raise the eyebrow or keeps us speechless or angry... lets put all that in this thread. 😊

So far, I will pick few incidents in brief.

- Adharmasena the umpire... when umpire given out to an LBW appeal, the ball becomes dead so runout is out of question. After DRS, the LBW was turned down but he still gave the batsman out for runout ? What? He had ample time to consult his fellow umpire and 3rd umpire but still ... This MF shud be kicked out if he dont retire. I dont want see him in any India game untill then.

- Indo pak match. Akmal was caught behind with faintest of edge, the sniko wasnt conclusive but the ball deviated... acc to commentators, it was 50/50, benefit of the doubt shud go to batsman.. but its wasnt to be. Afterall Dhoni asked for the review.. the reputation.

- Same game, Dhawan was given runout, his bat was on the line when the bell lit up... but hang on, bells has to be dislodged and thats the frame U shud freeze to see if the bat is over the line. Just one frame. The problem with these light up stumps and bells is they lit up at first strike and blurr the vision if the bells r in the air or not. Anyways, Dhawan had to go.

- I hate BCCI for being so cocky, why the f**k they didnt allow Hot spot technology? Its much more reliable than sniko and in conjunction with both, so many caught beind and LBW decisions can be certain.

So, U guys can add any issues U think worth mentioning as the WC progresses. So that those issues dont get burried in locked up threads. 😊

BCCI does not have to do anything with Hot Spot. 😆 ICC didn't have the ample amount of cameras needed to use Hot Spot for such a Big Tournament.
And i completely agree, Adharmasena has to Go. 🥱

And one more thing "Benefit of the Doubt" has become non existent in today's Cricket. 😆
AllBlacks1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
BCCI does not have to do anything with Hot Spot. 😆 ICC didn't have the ample amount of cameras needed to use Hot Spot for such a Big Tournament.
Ohok, I stand corrected. It's just BCCI has always problems with Hotspot technology. Well, they have problems with DRS is general and coz of them its not allowed in Indian test matches. And what I have seen, India have suffered more than the opposition teams.


BeingBlunt thumbnail

WPL Wizzards

Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: AllBlacks1

BCCI does not have to do anything with Hot Spot. 😆 ICC didn't have the ample amount of cameras needed to use Hot Spot for such a Big Tournament.


Ohok, I stand corrected. It's just BCCI has always problems with Hotspot technology. Well, they have problems with DRS is general and coz of them its not allowed in Indian test matches. And what I have seen, India have suffered more than the opposition teams.


Yes. BCCI is adamant on not using DRS. You know Sometimes i feel that Umpire now days are giving bad decisions deliberately so that BCCI are forced to accept DRS. 🥱😆
One more telling stat is that India has 100% Record in successful DRS appeals. In ICC WC 2011, In ICC CT 2013, And here in the first match still i dont know what is BCCI's problem. 🥱
AllBlacks1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
- Today WI Vs Pak... a leg side ball rubs the pad of the batsman and goes for 4 bys and umpire gives it wide.. 😆
- btw, I wud really love to know the words exchanged between Virat and Wahab.. wahab was pissed and Misbah had to calm him down and asked to bat... Kohli was laughing.
Anachronist thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AllBlacks1

- Today WI Vs Pak... a leg side ball rubs the pad of the batsman and goes for 4 bys and umpire gives it wide.. 😆

- btw, I wud really love to know the words exchanged between Virat and Wahab.. wahab was pissed and Misbah had to calm him down and asked to bat... Kohli was laughing.

tht was sohail khan😆
AllBlacks1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mahatma123

tht was sohail khan😆


Oh yeah, Sohail said " Kohli hoga apne ghar me" 😆
990853 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Akamal was out, snicko showed deflection may be it was soft touch but that's out
990853 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
I forgot one match but batsman was appealed for LBW and then he was given run out. The ball was dead but he was given run out and he missed 100
BeingBlunt thumbnail

WPL Wizzards

Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: 9tanki

I forgot one match but batsman was appealed for LBW and then he was given run out. The ball was dead but he was given run out and he missed 100

James Taylor of England v Australia. That was a typical Brainfart from Adharmasena. 🥱

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".