Personality competition, not singing

Based on the contestants who land in the bottom 4 and who are eliminated (Past and Present Indian Idols), it looks like the janta is voting for who has the best personality not for the best singer...good job👏

actually I think not only thr personality they also go for looks 😭 😭

but charu has a good personality..why was she eliminated then?

because she is a GIRL.....

I'm so mad ..I just wish that they would have separte Idols for both genders I mean that would be fairer 😡 two male idols already and then by the looks of it another male coming in...and this is not just in Idol also in SRGMP last year NOT ONE talented girl made it to the top 3 😡 😡 😡

pehle ladkiyan jayengi phir jab they will be content ki ladki nahi bachi then they will aim at removin talent....aur jab wo puraa hoga to pata hai II kaun banega...............one more sandeep.

i think everyone needs to calm down now...itna gussa bhi thik nahi its ok yaar...we can vote and we did that..ab we cant vote for the whole of india naa...so relax guys...

Originally posted by: ManaliS

i think everyone needs to calm down now...itna gussa bhi thik nahi its ok yaar...we can vote and we did that..ab we cant vote for the whole of india naa...so relax guys...

😆yep you're right...anyways I'm forgetting about II right now..have to read HP7!😃 but I still feel sad for the gals of II😭

Don't get me wrong but in this talk to prove that a girl should win we are overlooking really good talent which is there among the boys as well, Don't you guys agree that Emon and Amit are really talented as well and should have the chance of winning. I love Deepali and i think if a girl should win it should be her, but i won't say a girl has to win. the best person may it be a girl or a boy shoul be the winner in the end. I may be wrong but if we have better talent in the boys why wouldn't we want one of them to win.
After saying that, i do believe that this competition is unfair on the girls, they are better than most of the boys are they deserve a chance to come to the top 5 and then top 3 and if they are the best take home the crown. but not based on the merit of a being a girl but based on the merit of being a wonderful singer. I don't mean to offend anyone and i hope no one takes any offence.

Originally posted by: ManaliS

but charu has a good personality..why was she eliminated then?

personality bole tho all factors excluding singing😛