Saloni is responsible for Pia's Rape - Page 2

no one is reponsible for pia getting raped except the rapist himself..........yes pia was foolish to go out alone at night...but does that mean she deserves to get raped?......is brijesh to be blamed?..........he should be blamed for not being a more responsible brother.......but is he responsible for pia's rape incident?.........of course not.........nothing justifies a man raping a woman. I agree!! It is so absurd to even think that Someone other than the rapist would be responsible.

How Absurd!!!! 😡

Originally posted by: mainkaun

- If She would not have forced Pia to come then..
- If she could convince Brijesh to invite her, they she should have convinced him to give her ride
- Saloni knew about Ranjit bothering Pia still she let her go alone
- Saloni knew Sridhar not happy with Pia, still she let her go alone

Just my point of view, so please do not get offended.

I am not offended... a bit put off yes, but not offended. The blame lies with the rapist. How can anyone cause or prevent anyone's rape?! If the criminal wants to get his way, he will pick any time or place. Such a sad s/l... and I personally find this post/thread lacking in understanding of what rape is... a power play.

Shaista

I won't say Saloni is responsible for the rape....but there are some things that irk me in Saloni's character.Anything in excess is bad.There is this adage " Too much is too bad". Similarly Saloni's character is overly- good,someone who never makes mistakes and also something which we cannot relate to in real world.
It irritates all the more when only she is shown as the 'smart' one in the show....all the rest make mistakes at some point or the other......purely my opinion...no offence please 😊

Well i dont think that saloni or anyone else in family could be blamed for this mishappening but then i wuld surley say that both saloni and brijeh made a mistake. first saloni hide all about piya as she wanted to take all the credits .. Saloni Mata is the youngest in teh family but she never bother to share it with anyone..
I just hate when someone behave not humanly but super naturally.. evryone tend to commit mistake but saloni thinks that whatever she does or think, is right.

and brijesh.. wat can i say about him. he instead of understandig piya's feeling and circumstances and try to help her, he left her alone.. i think he was over protective for her on second thought not over protective but over possessive and when piya refused to hear him he got mad and left piya alone to fight her own battle of life.

but still u cant blame anyone for this incident coz haadse kabhi bhi kahin bhi kaise bhi ho sakte hain...

Originally posted by: tripler

no one is reponsible for pia getting raped except the rapist himself..........yes pia was foolish to go out alone at night...but does that mean she deserves to get raped?......is brijesh to be blamed?..........he should be blamed for not being a more responsible brother.......but is he responsible for pia's rape incident?.........of course not.........nothing justifies a man raping a woman.

I also agree. No one can be held responsible except the rapist beause only he knew that he would rape Pia. I mean, how can we hold Saloni or Brijesh responsible? I mean sure, Brijesh had a little riff with Pia and Saloni let her go by herself, but none of them knew that she would get raped, so how can anyone else be responsible?

Originally posted by: noreen1

I absolutely agree with the original poster - Saloni is a 110% responsible - why shouldn't she be? Just because she has a lead role in the drama - i think not! She has the joy of interfering and "helping" others out - but sometimes these "good" qualities can pose for the worst.

Lets just hope Pia gets better and has a more positive and bright future ahead of her.

I'm sorry..i don't understand what Saloni being the lead of the serial has anything to do with pia being raped?
She is not at fault. It's pia who chose to go alone, despite knowing someone was after her before too, and still refusing company...and brijesh's for being a stubborn headed pig and letting his ego get the better of his brains--- that is the reaons for most of the family's problems anyways... when brijesh makes a stubborn headed decision, and the resat of the family has to rough it out...

as for invitng pia to the pooja..she is their sister. it ws her right to attend or at least be invited. Saloni was the only one who could convinve Brijesh, but that doesn't mean she is the only one who wanted pia there....all of the other ladies requested Piya's attendance...
so please....if u (noreen) have a problem with saloni being the lead of the show, please don't use that as an excuse to blame her for whatever happens to another character in the show.

thanks.

p.s- this is my p.o.v, i am not saying u must agree.

npe.. i dnt think its pooor salonis fault 😳