HP Film series..

Page

Next Last

Poll

Which movie according to you was the best one among the series?

983175

Suspended

Posted: 10 years ago

I have always wanted to ask this question to my fellow Potterheads.. which according to you was the best film in the Potter series?.. you can base it on your general likeness with your own reasons or you can base the decision on how much the film was able to do justice to the book..

As for me, I ll vote for Sorcerer's Stone, Chamber of Secrets & Goblet of fire..if I had to choose one, I ll say Chamber of Secrets..However, PoA, OoTP, DH-1 & DH-2 were fairly good..but the worst one according to me was The Half Blood Prince..🤢..I absolutely hate that film , it was the farthest thing from the book..its not really their fault either, the book dealt with Tom Riddle's past in detail & the movie makers probably couldn't afford to go that deep story wise..well that's just my opinion...

Would like to know your opinions about the same..😊

Edited by Quixotic5 - 10 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Cutecj

@Cutecj

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

I loved DH2 because when i read the book i always wanted to see the battle between Harry and Voldy as the Epic battle and they did meet my expectations to quite a level plus it was in 3D so yah it was the one that topped my list.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

983175

Suspended

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Cutecj
I loved DH2 because when i read the book i always wanted to see the battle between Harry and Voldy as the Epic battle and they did meet my expectations to quite a level plus it was in 3D so yah it was the one that topped my list.

Cool..unfortunately for me, that was the only thing in DH2 that didnt work, the rest of the movie was a precise replica of my imagination ..especially, the Gringotts fiasco & the dragon therein was exactly as I had imagined it ( although i did imagine Bellatrix's Vault a little differently) , so that was spot-on.. however, the final battle sequence was different from what i had imagined, most importantly, it wasn't fought in the Great Hall as mentioned in the book, so that didnt go down very well with me.. the way i had imagined would have probably cost a lot of money for the makers..😆

Edited by Quixotic5 - 10 years ago

Quote

Cutecj

@Cutecj

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Quixotic5
Cool..unfortunately for me, that was the only thing in DH2 that didnt work, the rest of the movie was a precise replica of my imagination ..especially, the Gringotts fiasco & the dragon therein was exactly as I had imagined it ( although i did imagine Bellatrix's Vault a little differently) , so that was spot-on.. however, the final battle sequence was different from what i had imagined, most importantly, it wasn't fought in the Great Hall as mentioned in the book, so that didnt go down very well with me.. the way i had imagined would have probably cost a lot of money for the makers..😆

LOL it wasn't as per my imagination but i loved it because the makers gave it a different touch and the main point of the movie was the ending of battle and the disposal of the elder wand. i have to admit they could have made voldy a bit more desperate and shocked looking at the swing of the wand but it was great scenes.

personally i like it that they didn't follow the books as a spiritual script but as a guideline, that way everyone has a different view of the magical world😉