Tangled Web of Relationships - Mihir and Shagun

btalwar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Day before yesterday's episode as we all know by now, acted as a preamble to many mini/mega tracks. Although, I admit that my tired sleepy mind did miss the usual banter between our favourite couple, however, by morning a new thought had laid its foundation in my mind.

Before I begin, I request you to read the post called "Ties that Bind or Bonds That Tie". It is by RedWine1(Ruby) who happens to be one of my favourite writers on this forum.

Now on to my post ... As she has brilliantly described the reason behind apt title, Yeh Hain Mohabbatein, I will like to take the same thought further, but ... in a different light.

The word Mohabbatein immediately brings the evergreen love stories of Laila Majnu, Romeo Juliet, Heer Ranjha, Jack - Rose (Titanic is the modern day Romeo Juliet .. I cry every time when Rose leaves Jack's hand at the end.)

Yet, at the same time, Mohabbatein has many more meanings. It is love which makes the mother hold the hands of her children when they cross the road, It is the love of a brother who picks his sister from her extra class, it is the love which makes a friend travel thousands of miles at one go to be there for a friend in the time of need. Mohabbatein has many a meanings.

One such relationship is the love between siblings ... love between brother and sister ... love between Mihir and Shagun.

/* Disclaimer: At least in mind my I am pretty clear Shagun and Mihir are siblings. It will honestly be a shocker for me if it turns out otherwise. */

It is Shagun's love for Mihir which makes her send Rakhi to him even when he has denounced her as his sister. On the other hand, it is Mihir's love for Shagun which did not let him throw the Rakhi in trash. Instead, he keeps it extremely safe along with other confidential documents. It is love.

Love also has some more meanings. One of them is hurt. Mihir is severely hurt, rather damaged by his sister's actions. Going by the apparent age difference between them, it is evident that Shagun got married to Raman when Mihir was in his teens. The real Raman, who had married Shagun only wanted love in his life. It is not difficult to imagine how much love he would have showered on his teenage brother-in-law. An eternal bond was formed, a beautiful relation of mutual respect and admiration. A happy family, a doting Jeeju, a beautiful nephew. From a Mhir's point of view, the world couldn't get better for his sister.

Times change and things take an ugly turn between his sister and brother-in-law. Mihir is not in his teens anymore. He is a grown up man who has been a witness to the storm which shattered the life of his sister and brother in law. Worse, the man in him knows that his own sister is at fault. The same sister who he has doted on and has loved eternally for as long as he can remember. The same sister who was like a mother to him, someone he looked upon to for advice everytime he had a problem.

He is forced to make difficult choices. And whatever he chooses, his heart is bound to suffer. He acts like a man and opts for the correct choice, denounces his relationship with his sister and accepts his Jeeju as his Bhai. Equations change. Relationships change. Dynamics change.

He is now Ruhi's Chachu and not Mamu. Life moves on and the world slowly and steadily accepts the new circumstance with each passing moment. His brother gets a new woman in his life, Ruhi gets a new mother. A new ray of hope enters the life of his Bhai and life has never looked better for him.

He falls in love. A girl who is diametrically opposite from him yet brings the best out of him. He is finally able to look at the world in new light, a new ray of hope where there is happiness, peace. He cannot wait to marry her and make her his own. Life has finally become better for him.

Yet, his past yet again haunts him. His association with his sister, it may bring a Tsunami which will not only destroy his own dreams like a house of cards, but also the newly found solace in his Bhai's life. He feels guilty. He tries to run away and hide the facts. Yet, his past does not leave him. It cannot leave him.

I will like to refer to the 7th April episode when Trisha pulls Mihir out in the rains and asks him to enjoy it, Shagun spots him and happily comes towards him. She thinks, "Mihir ki nayi girlfriend."

It is the sister in Shagun who acted like this. The sister who in happier times will have shared so many secrets with the same brother, advised him, doted on him. He replies to her with hurt evident in his eyes, ""Rishta kya hamara? Jo bhi tha vo Bhai ke saath khatam ho gaya."

It is clear. In this scene, its not the brother of Bhai who mocks his sister in law, it's the brother of his sister who is hurt and taunts her by conveying his decision yet again.

Mihir is overall a very calm character, who is always happy being in the background, but in this scene, he orders Trisha forcefully to go up .. his eyes order her, display anger.

But yet again, anger, hurt, hate ... the other side of the coin is ... Love.

Yet, the same Mihir who is extremely hurt, loves his sister and decides to keep the rakhi. Because, somewhere deep down inside, Mihir is still that young child who yearns for the love of his sister. Every time, he meets Shagun, there is a look of hurt on his face. But isn't it true that the only people capable of hurting us the most are the ones we love?

Then there is Shagun. An opportunist woman to the core, who chose a better lifestyle over better ... Life. She grabbed the first opportunity which presented itself in terms of Ashok and happily beckoned the life of a showpiece because ... well that is what she wanted from life.

Yet, having said that, she is a human being first. And going by the famous hierarchy of needs, she first satiated her physiological and safety needs ... which are of course provided by Ashok profusely, but she could still not fulfil her need of belonging - Love, acceptance. Her own family denounced her, mocked her and removed her from their system altogether.

At the end of the day, every human being looks for acceptance and for Shagun, this is the missing piece in the puzzle. Her decisions in life stripped her of not only her husband's family, but her own brother. May be that is what she had not bargained for. May be that is what she had not expected. May be that is what she was not ready for.

Yet, all this happened. Her own kiddo brother denounced all his relations with her and moved ahead in his life with the help of same man she left. In fact, he prays that man as a God, and will do anything under the sun to bring a smile on his face.

Therefore, the elder sister in her still yearns for the acceptance from her brother. A brother who she never thought will leave her.

Referring to the same scene, Shagun actually went up to Mihir and asked him about Trisha. Her eyes conveyed a different meaning altogether and when Mihir openly mocks her, she is angry and she says that he acts totally like Raman that is why people refer to him as a sidekick.

For her, it is difficult to accept that her brother gives importance to someone else over her, someone she left by her own choice. In the further episodes also, Shagun was shown to enquire about Mihir's engagement from Ashok in a twisted manner.

She coaxes Ashok to attend the engagement party because Tandon is a partner, however, in reality, it's the sister who wants to be a part of her brother's happiness in at least some way.

So, she sends him Rakhi inspite of the fact that they are on no talking terms and things can never get back to what they were ... ever ...

Another version of Yeh Hai Mohabbatein ...


Let me know your thoughts.

Cheers
Bhanu 😊
Edited by btalwar - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

7.3k

Users

19

Likes

129

Frequent Posters

Veeann thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Beautifully written and analysed Bhanu.
I agree with you completely - it is evident that there is still deep love between Mihir and a Shagun - Mihir has been deeply hurt by Shagun, and his transfer of loyalty to his Jiju by making him his Bhai means that in his mind at least, Mihir has shut off every avenue for a continued relationship with Shagun. How can his Bhai's ex wife be his sister?

I am really looking forward to seeing how the CVs explain the back story, and the reason for Mihir's mothers estrangement from both her children ( and of course Shagun is Mihir's sister and PP is their mother. No doubts there in my mind)

Thank you for this awesome post 👏
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
sorry this took so long
EDITED
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I like your take on shagun. She maybe a terrible woman but she is a human and like all humans, she is multi-faceted. CV's have so far only portrayed her as a greedy, selfish, manipulative bimbo. we got a small glimpse of her human side, I first saw it in the warmth she displays towards ruhi, her love for adi and that she keeps sending mihir rakhi even though he severed all ties with her. Most Creatives make the mistake of not humanizing their antagonists, but making them more than just vamp actually makes things interesting. She loves her kids in her own way and today, I saw a little longing on her face. Maybe she wished things were different, and that she did not ruin everything with her bare hands.

CV's have great opportunity to show us shagun's backstory, and show us her senstive side which I think exists under her mean streak. I still maintain that shagun is awful but humans are grey shaded, every part of her can't be bad.
Edited by pomegranate - 11 years ago
paru_rox thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
RES

EDITED:

Lovely thoughts Bhanu & beautifully written as usual. The day Shagun left with Ashok she did not only leave her husband , her child & her home. She left behind an array of people shattered in the wake of her decision. Not only Raman's family but her own too. A brother who was so hurst by her decision that he decides to choose the man she left behind than his own sister. What can hurt her more?

We have not seen much of Poornima Prakash till now but it seems that a mother could accept her daughter's decision too especially when she chooses to leave behind a little child & a loving husband for something that is clearly materialistic. Must have made the woman question her own upbringing to her daughter.

Shagun & her relationship with her family is complicated & would love to see it explored further.


Edited by paru_rox - 11 years ago
Oishi_S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Beautiful Bhanu. Very well written analysis.
Shagun for all her problems is capable of love. Something that is visible when it comes to Mihir or Adi. Somewhere in her, like you said! she craves for acceptance. All the times you mentioned of Shagun's display of affection for Mihir was so true. Also, during the engagement part she wss concerned about Mihir, she was wondering if Mihir was marrying out of his own will, even if she might not be aware of Mihika's existence in Mihir's life.
And Mihir, poor Mihir, I just feel bad for him. He must have loved his sister a lot, till does and yet the hurt, anger, betrayal would never let him forgive her.
PS- This days, with the opening of this track I am starting to wish they turn Shagun into a more sensible character one day, someone who would repent for her misdeeds and look for redemption. She still has chance of redeeming herself.
Edited by Oishi_sonu - 11 years ago
Colt.Pixy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Very nice post bhanu.

i liked your angle for shagun. we could defo understand mihir at some level but we hardly tried to understand from angle of sister .
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I agree. Their bond is definitely complicated yet real. Remember how Shagun was worried that Mihir was not happy when he was getting engaged to Trisha? I think there is definitely love there, but her actions and choices ruined that relationship. At that point in time, being with Ashok must have seemed more important than anything else to her and she must have been willing to sacrifice anything for it. As time passed, those sacrifices may come back to haunt her.
Great post and great analysis.

--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
So true n loved ur take on Shagun n Mihir relationship 😊
Mohabbatein is d word for love often misinterpreted (due to our Hindi films) as love between Husband n wife or lovers. Loved how u hv explained Rakhi n its importance from both Mihir n Shaguns POV.
_Dipsi_ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Wow Bhanu...thats beautifully penned..lovely analysis of the brother sister relationship..loved it
Thanks for the pm
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Hey Bhanu! Thanks for your PM for this post.
The title of this show "This is love" depicts the many flavors and expressions of love...as parent, child, friend, lover, relative, employee and many more. The definition of love is subjective and personal. But if we remove all labels to the relationships between the characters, the only way misunderstandings and distance can ever be removed is acceptance. Ultimately the true definition of love is just acceptance of what is, who is and how things are.

Mihir's distanced himself from Shagun because he couldn't accept his sister's choices. To err is human, to forgive divine. I often wondered if Shagun were in mortal danger, would Mihir still refuse to have anything to do with her or come to her aid?

Shagun walked away from Raman and left him to pick up the pieces of his life with Ruhi. Ishita has been the balm to heal Raman's soul and believe in love and trust again. Even Raman who was deeply hurt when Shagun left him for Ashok has stepped up to help her for humanitarian reasons, not as his ex-wife or the mother of his children.

It was love at first sight for Mihir when he met Mihika. Every time he meets Shagun his anger and resentment of the past still simmers below the surface. He avoids her or hurts her with his words. If Mihir doesn't forgive Shagun for her choices and let go of the anger and resentment, they will show up in his own life down the road. Hatred and resentment eats away at the person holding such feelings...no matter how angry Mihir gets at Shagun it hurts him more...enough to impact his marriage.

Mihika now works for Ashok, the very man Shagun chose over Raman and her marriage. Ashok has plans to use Mihika to teach Shagun a lesson and it could become a situation of his words against hers. Will Mihir judge her the same way he judged Shagun? Will his trust in Mihika be shaken because once again Ashok is the reason and he judges Mihika bec' he's reminded of Shagun's betrayal of her husband. Or will Mihir face a situation where his love for Mihika overcomes all hurdles and he finally forgives Shagun? After all this is love, aka yeh hai mohabbatein.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".