Indian Idol Vs Other reality show

I feel II3 performances are not as fine tuned as Voice of India or Sa re Ga Ma

My analysis :

1. Age of contenstants : II3 performers are realitively Younger,

2. Judges : II3 judges look partial e.g alisha and suhit, Javed and Ankita. Compare them with Asha in Sa re ga ma or Alka in VOI

3. Selection procedure : Foregin contenstant's of II3 vs sa re ga ma , e.g. Mauli's songs in Sa re ga ma

4. Participants are involved in other activities, e.g. Advertising Maruti's new car, participating in military camps and so on.

5. Ram Shakar Vs other matured trainers in Sa re ga ma

6. Anchor, Mini Vs Shan or Aditya

II3 lacks in all sides ... what do you think?

Recording of VOI and Sa re ga ma has some echo which makes little better.. isnt that the reason it soundz good.. I mean just sound settings

E.g, compare emon's performance with Thoshi for piya re (Video is on youtube serach for owrd Thoshi) **I am newbie :(

4.

😍 keep going dude survey is great

also notice the ii3 is more dramatic rather than serious singing competition

is II3 more polular than sa re ga ma or VOI ??

Originally posted by: yjner

I feel II3 performances are not as fine tuned as Voice of India or Sa re Ga Ma

My analysis :

1. Age of contenstants : II3 performers are realitively Younger,

2. Judges : II3 judges look partial e.g alisha and suhit, Javed and Ankita. Compare them with Asha in Sa re ga ma or Alka in VOI

3. Selection procedure : Foregin contenstant's of II3 vs sa re ga ma , e.g. Mauli's songs in Sa re ga ma

4. Participants are involved in other activities, e.g. Advertising Maruti's new car, participating in military camps and so on.

5. Ram Shakar Vs other matured trainers in Sa re ga ma

6. Anchor, Mini Vs Shan or Aditya

II3 lacks in all sides ... what do you think?

E.g, compare emon's performance with Thoshi for piya re (Video is on youtube serach for owrd Thoshi) **I am newbie :(

4.

Thanks so much for the information. 😃 I watch VOI online and couldn't hear the entire performance.

Originally posted by: yjner

is II3 more polular than sa re ga ma or VOI ??

No, SRGMP enjoys the higest TRP, though VOI lacks behind II3

Ya, VOI seems like great show, atleast they have couple of very good performers, II3 lacks good singers ...

indian idol is nothing compared to the talent on voice of india 👏

Originally posted by: prabal_cog

No, SRGMP enjoys the higest TRP, though VOI lacks behind II3

I think its VOI which is leading now. But who knows how real the TRPs are...😕

did you guys see Mauli Dave's Maiyya Maiya .. it in my opinion better than original