Fair or unfair: Best Debut Awards ' Experience vs Debutant - Page 6

Originally posted by: ishika_sushita

SRK, Vidya Balan also earned a nomination in the best debut category when they entered Bollywood, inspite of having TV experience.If we go by that logic, most actors in Bollywood today, have a theatre/TV background.What do we do then? Who do we nominate in the best debut category?

I sort of agree with both sides of the argument. Another example would be that Deepika Padukone got the best debut awards over Sonam however she had acted in a Kannada film before called Aishwarya.

Originally posted by: ishika_sushita

Well, there is not much of a difference in the way Bollywood works and in the way all the other regional film industries work except the difference in the language.It's the film industry at the end of the day.Whereas, the television industry and the film industry are 2 different industries altogether.TV and films are completely different mediums.The way to go about a daily soap and a movie is very different.One can't really compare the 2 mediums as such since the methodology of both of them are way different from each other.

Having said that, I appreciate the fact that Dhanush had to learn a whole new language for Ranjhanaa and gave a brilliant performance in it.:)

by stating that TV and bollywood r quite similar, i meant that TV actors have a great reach towards the public just as a regular bolly actor has.. for example, every1 is aware of barun sobti and other top tv actors globally, but IF kolaveri di wouldnt happen would they know about Dhanush ? NO, no matter how similarly success ratio is measured in both bollywood and kollywood.
In that way Sushant gets an advantage given that he was the male lead of the topmost tv serial since say 3 years. ppl were aware and confident about his film career, he had an access to the ppl like u and me and many more who knew him since years whereas Dhanush got mocked even the day b4 Raanjhana had released, and guess what even after proving his caliber, his success is measured and rated as a virtue of being Rajnikanth's SIL. thats what is hurtful.

I myself never wanted him to win the best debut award, as the title falls short of his image and caliber, but then the recognition he got for his first hindi film, he deserved it.

and thanks a lot, its nice that u appreciate Dhanush's effort .. 😃

Once i used to hate dhanush like anything i used to think why did Rajni sir SIL is like this? but then i watched 3 in tamil(and i dont understand tamil) i coz i love the song kolaveri and he was so brilliant especially the last letter scene he was just outstanding i was so excited for Ranjhana Only for him.😳

I think it's unfair to them as artistes who have made their mark to be nominated as best debutante... I wanted Dhanush to get the award for best actor in Ranjhana... Farhan was good but the array of emotions and acting displayed by Dhanush in Ranjhana was superb... I think Filmfare wanted Farhan to have it and hence gave Dhanush the best debutante award...