Kool's Commentary : Oct 5 PR - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

176

Views

10.3k

Users

32

Likes

515

Frequent Posters

sherma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#11
i am still against d slap,she shld realise he is his bil not sum extra, her sister life wid him, wat if he strts being dirty or torutring vaishu.AND watever he tld archu is d fact and kind of every1 agree to dis in d forum,tat archu has been used by deshmukhs(i read it sumwere).
simmy78 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Kools awesome commentary. I agree with most of your points not the slapping of Dharmesh though.

Archu and Manav are idiotic characters and are responsible of their mess. Archu sucks at her job and together they suck at everything else. So they are in this mess of their own accord.

However that does not mean that Dharmesh, Jay and Satish can walk away scott free. I agree with niki on this point. They too have to face their own wrong doing, just as Archu and Manav should. I am not a PR fan and I absolutely hate Archu and Manav, so hopefully this is not seen as a biased viewpoint.

Vaishu has no right shouting at Archu (if she does) because this same Manav saved her parents butt in her marriage. I am a Marwadi and I know marriages break if the food intazam is not done properly.

Same for Varsha, heck Manav saved her marriage.

Infact things would make lot more sense if Archu walks out on Manav cause he gave her only pain, but her family should support Manav cause he only saved them in times of need and their bahu has ruined his family.

Regarding Archu not slapping Dharmesh because he is her BIL. I thing this messy serial has long crossed these simple reasons. If we look into these accounts, there should have been more than one factory in the entire of Bombay for Manav and Ajit to work 😆, there should have been more than one restarunt in the entire Bombay for Archu and Jay to go on a date 😆. In real life Manav's family would never even look at the Kajrankars for what Manju did to them. So relationship wala reasoning is buried long deep long ago in the messy PR. 😆


Edited by simmy78 - 14 years ago
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Hi Kools

When you quietly said 'OK agreed' I was sure you would be taking up this case later.

Completely disagree with your take on 'human side of Archu'.

When I wrote that Archu slapping Dharmesh was a human reaction, I myself said it was an uncontrolled, impulsive one. Then she didn't think that she is not my husband, or that I don't have rights and all, or that Dharmesh is not that bad, or that he has helped me and been good to me. At that time, he was just the person who had caused serious harm to someone he loved. And even though you may find this pretty dramatic- but pyaar chupaye nahi chupta. It is at these points that it swells and bursts out like a volcano. I don't understand why Savita slapping is understandable but Archu slapping is not. We can say it is not justified, ok, but not understandable????

Plus that slap, as I saw it, came not bcos he said something about pavitra rishta, it came cos Dharmesh said, that Manav is using you. The thought that came first in MY mind when I read this was:

So first he implicated an innocent person in a crime and then he makes such bull excuses like 'Manav is using you????'

Heck, I would have slapped him too if I had been in Archu's place. (even though I am not Manav's wife or anyone related to him at all.) I saw it as pure audacity and silly excuses the motu was making to save his skin for a crime he had committed. Damage control, bas.

Plus what has this pavitra rishta and all got to do with all this at this time, when the question is only whether he trapped Manav for personal gains or not? Pavitra Rishta and all aside, Manav is a human being- a worker. Why does not Dharmesh address that question? Why attack Archana's weak point?

Sorry, but I give a thumbs down to Dharmesh. Two slaps from me to him.

Kools, right or wrong, justified or unjustified, Archu's behavior was highly human. Highly understandable. Introspection can take place later- in all probability our Archu, who bends even before Manju, will herself go and apologize. If she apologizes I would respect her more.

The fact that both MAnav and Archu need slaps from many people is another issue. I agree, they do. I myself would volunteer to do that. But not for this slap incident. Not at all. I haven't gone through all posts, I don't know what others say. But today I'm with Archu.

Disappointed that you did not blast CV's for the 'leaving old parents' issue. Why blast the puppets, why not the puppet player, for showing romantic love in a stale, wrong, filmy way?

She is NOT being human here nor is it a one time thing with her .She is nowdays making a habit of going on a slapping spree when she cANNOT HANDLE THE TRUTH
It has to be remembered when Dharmesh said Manav used u , SHe has YET NO KNOWLEDGE tHAT HE HAS SIGNED DECLARATION FOR HER . So Given that , Partly wat Dharmu said is OH SO BLOODY TRUE . Manav INDEED used her To FURTHER HIS IMAGE AS A MAN OF HIS WORD . ........TO MARRY SHRAVNI HIS ZIMMEDARI . Archu thought he was GOD ..........He was NOT . He is IN LOVE WITH HIS OWN STUPID IDEAS , bas .Even now he is In lOVE WITH YET ONE MORE STUPID IDEA ..........THAT A WOMAN NEEDS A MARRAIGE OR SHE IS DESTROYED . Its for this idea that Manav has shirked AGED parents to go hungry if he doesnt come out .Manavs ego about his decision making ability and his self righteousness is remarkable ...............His WORD to SHRAVNI , HIS FORCE ON ARCHU FOR MARRAIGE TO JAy , HIS SIIGN NOW thinking WITHOUT MARRAIGE A WOMAN CANT SURVIVE , HIS VIEWS ON VIRGINITY ..............his ideas r self righteous and unshakeable .
Thappad toh this Manav shud get and thappad Archu shud get for signing papers without reading and ENDANGERING manavs LIFE . How about accepting some real responsibility here huh ? People cant MAKE u sign .U were not drinking liquour , u were in full HOSH , u signed papers WITHOUT READING ...........A SHEAF of them . If ur carrying ur emotional baggage to work and getting hysterically emotinal all the time ur an UNFIT PERSON period . Ur creating HAVOC in work place , ur slapping workers , ur signing incriminating documents and u go around slapping people framing ur lover ? Who says the world will be exactly the way Archna Karanjkar wishes it to be ?control urself first , do ur job well . No one can then trick u .
All u guys r giving her so many thumbs up for slapping to get point across ......Then Shravni shud have slapped her when she caught her in the rain under umbrella only . But she didnt , she took her own decision .She did not slap either Manav nor Archu , she came home and started packing HER BAGS .
How many of us go around slapping jeejus in real life ?Or brothers or vahinis ? Do u realise how seriously relations will be wrecked ? My sister wont talk to me for LIFE if I do it .Till my DEATH .
Varsha is rite ...........only Manavs parents have rite to get this emotional to SLAP Dharmu . Archna is OUT OF CONTROL . It goes against CULTURE . Even Savita who is kind of a cheapo culture woman , recognises this and does nOT slap even in great anger ..........neither Ajit nor Archu she slapped .
If she intends supporting Manav , throw Jays ring on the floor in front of all and declare engagement is over , that its WAR and that AS SUPERVISOR she will now pull Dharmy JAY to court for tricking her into signing . Thats what was her FAVORITE dialogue anyways .........I AM SUPERVISOR .
Btw if she stands in court and TELLS this to a judge ..that I signed without looking coz i was CHITCHATTING with my fiancee , I SHUDDER TO THINK OF THE JUDGE"S REPRIMAND .
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Yes she made a mistake that she did not look when signing . I hope she will go to the police station and tell them the truth .Tha tthese papers were signed asa genuine mistake and she was not told about them ...whatever punishment awaits her then , I hope she will accept it and go through it .
When ever she has made a mistake she herslef bears the burden of that mistake .She does not let others take the flak for it ..I hope even this time she will go through whatever punishment that awaits her for not looking when signing these papers ...
We all make such mistakes and then as everyone , we get punished and we learn ...
same goes for her too...
Edited by Tanyaz - 14 years ago
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
I seedha started defending Archu withour praising the commentary. 😆

Manohar gets the best jokes in your commentary, always. Good for him, cos he never gets such attention in the serial. God knows after how many days he got a dialogue today.

I'm gradually liking Bhavna now. The family is perfect- only Varsha sticks out as the sore thumb.

I requested yesterday also, requesting today also, please put in just two lines requesting CV's to redeem Manav in the commentary, in the midst of all the demand for Jaywant scenes and demand for manav blashing and slaps for Archana. This is so bcos CVs read your commentary.

sherma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#16
i totally agree wid u kooldi. getting violent wid any1 shld b d last ting in any1 head atleast in d family. THE truth out here d main culprit is prakash sooner or later d truth wil b out,wil she b able to face vaishu or dharmesh, forget facing, dharmesh is in her family will he or any1 forget dis she slapped him in front of d whole family.manju will never let any1 forget dis. it is such a humilating ting to get slapped in ur sasural by ur saali. i giv thumbs down to archu for dis.
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Kools, Dharmesh used the 'Manav is using you' as a line to save himself in front of everyone. Cos HE DOES NOT KNOW THAT MANAV ASKED HER TO GET MARRIED BY USING SHRAVANI CARD.

That infuriarated me.

I never said Archana is RIGHT. I myself said she must apologize later. But sometimes anger gets out of control, especially in case people we love are harmed.

Jasmine10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
Archu should have ended her engagement , which will eventually break anyhow. she should have used her vocal cords & her tear ducts instead of hitting people.

A women hitting a man is a disgracing act and leads to grave consequences . here Archu is slapping her BIL in front of her whole family. he is wrong but Archu's action is also not appropriate .
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
By the way Kools, can I ask you why you agreed with me at that time????😃
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Kools, Dharmesh used the 'Manav is using you' as a line to save himself in front of everyone. Cos HE DOES NOT KNOW THAT MANAV ASKED HER TO GET MARRIED BY USING SHRAVANI CARD.

That infuriarated me.

I never said Archana is RIGHT. I myself said she must apologize later. But sometimes anger gets out of control, especially in case people we love are harmed.

Arre then where was this anger when Manju KILLED Sachin in a moral sense , ha ?That was also framing .Here Dharmu framed Manav purely to SAVE his own butt and business ....manju FRAMED A FAMILY for FUN ! Evil FUN ! And this dame sobbed at Damodars feet to Save Manju ? Coz her BRO shud have a marraige ?
Wat about Vaishus marraige ? How will Marwadi Saas Sasur treat her after seeing their son SLAPPED in sasural ?Did Archu THINK about it ?
What has Vaishu done in this ?Nothing .She and Varsha r unaware of a lot of things just as Archu is .In fact they r at home . Archu is AT WORK and yet unaware ...........so its iinexcusable .
Last two days Im seeing comments .........So bad her sisters r , this that .Why ? What have they done ? They r just being sIBLINGS if u guys see it objectively . They saw their mom getting an ttack due to mental strain due to abnormal behavior of THIS SISTER and just voiced their thoughts whoch was long due .They then apologised and arranged date for her and today a get together to bring some happiness in this house .
Is Archu even bothering to THINK how she will be destroying their life ?If she was this pagal for Manav , why did she divorce ?
Manav heaped mental atrocities on her she didnt slap him once . With what face will she expect Vaishu to go against Dharmu ? At least Dhramu only did professional golmal , he has not treated Vaishu badly on personal level . For that privately she will pull him up ..why wud she stand him being slapped by her sister ? For her EX Archu has such strong feelings then Dharmu toh is Vaishus hUsband .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".