Qarz E Jaan (HUM) #5 - Usama Khan, Nameer Khan, Yumna Zaidi - Page 7

Originally posted by: pilot100

This is what confuses me. Why does Burhan have to defend Ammar to free Nashwa? First of all. Nashwa doesn't need his help nor did she ask him for any help to free him. And this is somewhat twisted. If he really wants to free Nashwa, then he should try his best to send him and even Bakhtiyar to jail. In this way Nashwa will automatically be freed.

Sorry, but Burhan defending Ammar for his own personal agenda, is not acceptable. If he takes this case as a normal case , then it's fine. But if he Going to make some deal with Bakhtiyar to get Nashwa for himself, he will stoop really low. Also what makes him think, that Nashwa will accept him, when she comes to know about this deal. Is she some toy ? She is Aldready mad at him, this will make her hate him even more. Plus how can he trust Bakhtiyar. What is the guarantee that he will free Nashwa, once he wins the case.

This case is almost an open and shut case. That is why no lawyer is taking up this case. Why Is Burhan ready to risk his reputation and career for a case where the chances of him losing his case is more

Plus he will fall in everyone's eyes.

Some people are predicting, that he will play his game in the end and deliberately lose. This logic also I don't understand 😐 . Why would he risk his career to that.

Nah, deliberately losing sounds bizzare n far-fetched. This show hasn't been that stupid to show such bollywoodish gimmick. I think this would be done out of desperation to save or free Nashwa. Sometimes even the most intelligent person can make stupid mistakes out of desperation . He's in love with her, so probably he just wants to take a chance even though he very well knows bade abbu could still play him at the end.He probably just wants to do everything he can to get nashwa out of this situation. Let's wait till the next week to see his justification for taking up the case.

Originally posted by: zooni.blue

What a tragic watch ...

The beenish trauma is so difficult to watch ..

Wanted more of Ammar than just his silence ... He was completely unhinged after murder no remorse... Are they trying to show that just a day in jail has him feel remorse n proper punishment early on could shape him better

I think they are trying to show how these criminals realise the consequences of their actions quite late -when they are behind the bars, surrounded by other criminals , uncertainty,scared n filth all around. There are multiple scenarios where we see criminals breaking down in court n they understand the gravity of the situation only after court proceedings n when they are sentenced or punished.Probably, writer wanted to showcase that side.

​

https://x.com/elonmushk_/status/1911501979127595033?t=AyMmQaGA9UPoRgZmOzT2Fw&s=19

Read this for a better understanding of Burhan's actions before the reddit mods take it down.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PAKCELEBGOSSIP/s/OtOlj9Yp3p

Originally posted by: Farin3545

Yumna not that great in terms of acting!!!

But yes,Nameer obviously gonna get breakthrough from this.

Yumna as an actress did good job. I don't get the criticism on her acting. But to each their own.

Originally posted by: nightingale1234

Nah, deliberately losing sounds bizzare n far-fetched. This show hasn't been that stupid to show such bollywoodish gimmick. I think this would be done out of desperation to save or free Nashwa. Sometimes even the most intelligent person can make stupid mistakes out of desperation . He's in love with her, so probably he just wants to take a chance even though he very well knows bade abbu could still play him at the end.He probably just wants to do everything he can to get nashwa out of this situation. Let's wait till the next week to see his justification for taking up the case.

Again my question remains the same. Why does he have to defend Ammar to free Nashwa. In case he wins the case, Nashwa will continue to be Ammar wife. She will never Marry him even if Ammar Divorce her. Which he kind of knows too. But by sending Ammar to jail, she will only binded to that house. Atleast she won't be Ammar wife. She might be his widow. By sending Ammar to jail, not only justice will be served but even Bakhtiyar will be punished. Nashwa will be free automatically.

Nashwa and his mistakes cannot be compared. Nashwa was sacrificing her life for her mother. By marrying Ammar, she was only doing injustice to herself. But by Defending Ammar, Burhan is doing injustice to so many other lives and even to himself by killing his morality, consciousness and reputation

Originally posted by: pilot100

Again my question remains the same. Why does he have to defend Ammar to free Nashwa. In case he wins the case, Nashwa will continue to be Ammar wife. She will never Marry him even if Ammar Divorce her. Which he kind of knows too. But by sending Ammar to jail, she will only binded to that house. Atleast she won't be Ammar wife. She might be his widow. By sending Ammar to jail, not only justice will be served but even Bakhtiyar will be punished. Nashwa will be free automatically.

Nashwa and his mistakes cannot be compared. Nashwa was sacrificing her life for her mother. By marrying Ammar, she was only doing injustice to herself. But by Defending Ammar, Burhan is doing injustice to so many other lives and even to himself by killing his morality, consciousness and reputation

I have been thinking the same

Nashwa did this to save her innocent mom. It is not at all the same thing. He is using it against Beenish who he didn't even go to see. I thought they had a bond. He kind of just ignored and is cold towards beenish as he was to Faryal when it comes to getting nashwa. So Burhan has grey shades. He cannot think beyond his love. Nashwa is like a case and he never lost a case. He wants to win her. In his head he is right and he kind of makes sense to me....but I'm kind of freaked out by how pushy he is

On X people are making up excuses for him. Saying that it is the same thing - the deal. They also feel it's fun to be unjust and not provide fair trial. It is not wrong to take the case. Anyone can take any case. Lawyers are not morally obligated to do anything other than their job. But personally, he knows Beenish so that's one thing.

Doesn't by doing nothing he still does a lot? Also, can people fight personal cases? Against family members? Doesn't setting up trials take years? I guess they can expedite this one.

I think we will have to wait and hear what Burhan says and does. Maybe there is one last twist? I wonder what happens in the end.

Originally posted by: Alizba63

I have been thinking the same

Nashwa did this to save her innocent mom. It is not at all the same thing. He is using it against Beenish who he didn't even go to see. I thought they had a bond. He kind of just ignored and is cold towards beenish as he was to Faryal when it comes to getting nashwa. So Burhan has grey shades. He cannot think beyond his love. Nashwa is like a case and he never lost a case. He wants to win her. In his head he is right and he kind of makes sense to me....but I'm kind of freaked out by how pushy he is

On X people are making up excuses for him. Saying that it is the same thing - the deal. They also feel it's fun to be unjust and not provide fair trial. It is not wrong to take the case. Anyone can take any case. Lawyers are not morally obligated to do anything other than their job. But personally, he knows Beenish so that's one thing.

Doesn't by doing nothing he still does a lot? Also, can people fight personal cases? Against family members? Doesn't setting up trials take years? I guess they can expedite this one.

I think we will have to wait and hear what Burhan says and does. Maybe there is one last twist? I wonder what happens in the end.

I can't blame him for his cold behavior towards faryal, because he was never interested in her. Like how Nashwa is behaving with him, he was with Faryal, but he has never been rude to her. I really don't think,his love for Nashwa because of his ego. He genuinely cares for her and is a little bit selfish when it comes to Nashwa. But to tell that he is treating Nashwa as a case, that's wrong. And whatever he says, it is fact. His advice on taking Ammar to rehab was indeed very wrong of Nashwa which made him more aggressive. Plus yest what he told about Bisma and Beenish fate was also true. He just spills the fact.

My mother is also telling, that he is not wrong in taking the case. It is his job to put a fair trial to his client. Also incase he is making a deal, it will be only to free Nashwa and not to get her for himself. Instead of taking money, he is asking for Nashwa freedom. He is Just taking a chance. As far as Beenish is concerned, my mom says why should he bother about her,when she didn't help him to get Nashwa even after promising him. Plus even Beenish has been selfish throughout only by bothered about herself and her life.. Plus she is Bakhtiyar daughter too. He may not hate her but he doesn't have sympathy either. And what he says is also true. Beenish could have lost her mental stability and could have indeed harmed her. He is only practical.

And my mom is neither a Nashwa/ Yumna fan nor Burhan/ Usama fan. She is just a neutral viewer.

She says Nashwa was more wrong in Marrying Ammar, when she knew about his criminal history and Maheen case. She doesn't buy this theory of getting blackmailed by Bakhtiyar. And now she is doing another mistake by fighting against Ammar. She says Burhan is no longer interested in getting Nashwa and Neither Nashwa loves him. But yes he is concerned for her and wants her to be free from that house

Originally posted by: pilot100

I can't blame him for his cold behavior towards faryal, because he was never interested in her. Like how Nashwa is behaving with him, he was with Faryal, but he has never been rude to her. I really don't think,his love for Nashwa because of his ego. He genuinely cares for her and is a little bit selfish when it comes to Nashwa. But to tell that he is treating Nashwa as a case, that's wrong. And whatever he says, it is fact. His advice on taking Ammar to rehab was indeed very wrong of Nashwa which made him more aggressive. Plus yest what he told about Bisma and Beenish fate was also true. He just spills the fact.

My mother is also telling, that he is not wrong in taking the case. It is his job to put a fair trial to his client. Also incase he is making a deal, it will be only to free Nashwa and not to get her for himself. Instead of taking money, he is asking for Nashwa freedom. He is Just taking a chance. As far as Beenish is concerned, my mom says why should he bother about her,when she didn't help him to get Nashwa even after promising him. Plus even Beenish has been selfish throughout only by bothered about herself and her life.. Plus she is Bakhtiyar daughter too. He may not hate her but he doesn't have sympathy either. And what he says is also true. Beenish could have lost her mental stability and could have indeed harmed her. He is only practical

Yes, he is quite practical. Matter of fact kind of person. Though sometimes he sounds a little cold. But regardless, it is true that he is not the most empathetic towards Beenish at this point. He doesn't have to be but it's kind of how they set him up that he cares for all.

We will get to know if he is doing it only for Nashwa or not. I mean that's the most likely but will wait to see how it all unfolds

Burhan doesn't seem the type to not be fair to a case. If he takes the case to free Nashwa that is fine as well. But I wonder what the deal is...take the case and free her or win the case and free her. What does the Taya say? Taya is honestly dumb.

I think all the guess work is done. I believe we just wait and see how it ends. Do you think there are 4 episodes or 2?

I don't want them to rush.

Originally posted by: Alizba63

Yes, he is quite practical. Matter of fact kind of person. Though sometimes he sounds a little cold. But regardless, it is true that he is not the most empathetic towards Beenish at this point. He doesn't have to be but it's kind of how they set him up that he cares for all.

We will get to know if he is doing it only for Nashwa or not. I mean that's the most likely but will wait to see how it all unfolds

Burhan doesn't seem the type to not be fair to a case. If he takes the case to free Nashwa that is fine as well. But I wonder what the deal is...take the case and free her or win the case and free her. What does the Taya say? Taya is honestly dumb.

I think all the guess work is done. I believe we just wait and see how it ends. Do you think there are 4 episodes or 2?

I don't want them to rush.

I think 3 or 4 max. But definitely not 2.

My mom says, Burhan knows that taya is playing with him and also he knows he can never get Nashwa now whether he wins or lose. But since Bakhtiyar himself has come with this offer , he is grabbing the opportunity. He knows even by losing the case,Nashwa will be freed but not entirely.. But incase he wins,Atleast Nashwa will be free from that house . Nashwa freedom is his fees for this case. My mom says though it is open and shut case, but a good lawyer can twist the case by proving Ammar as mentally unstable and send him to rehab instead of jail, which is exactly Burhan is going to do. He might try to get a lesser punishment for him. I think Burhan will lose the case because AMMAR will himself confess his crimes