Main Manto Nahin Hoon (ARY) - Humayun Saeed, Sajal Ali - Page 16

Show Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

182

Views

24.4k

Users

23

Likes

130

Frequent Posters

hypnotoad thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: heavenlybliss

Have trust in Nadeem Baig, even MPTH was a good watch due to his direction

I don't think this will be anything like SMD.

It feels more like a social satire/social commentary. More along GM lines than SMD.

It will definitely be a ML-centric story unlike SMD.

I think it will be the story of a guy who is meek, cowardly, fearful, who cannot stand for his rights or rights of others, who takes abuse and disrespect from others because he is weak. So the opposite of Manto. I think the story will be about his evolution. How he goes from being a coward to someone who exposes the underbelly of society. Learns to take a stand. Puts aside his fears to become the voice of the oppressed. So beco.e a Manto. There will be a love track but I think the crux of the story will not be ishq mashooqi.

I saw a review where the reviewers said they spoke to Mohammad Ahmad recently (who played Mirza Naamdar in SMD). He is in Manto as well. He told them that Manto is a very strong and good script unlike SMD which was a very poor script.

I also feel Humayun and Nadeem will have more control in changing around the script this time.

I really think Manto will be critically acclaimed. People will call it KRQ's comeback.

Edited by hypnotoad - 4 months ago
Zennia thumbnail
Most Posts (December 2024) Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7

Sajal Aly

Posted: 4 months ago

Some of the good bits of the bts leaks

https://x.com/Scholarnaina_/status/1902426106147541267

Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: hypnotoad

I don't think this will be anything like SMD.

It feels more like a social satire/social commentary. More along GM lines than SMD.

It will definitely be a ML-centric story unlike SMD.

I think it will be the story of a guy who is meek, cowardly, fearful, who cannot stand for his rights or rights of others, who takes abuse and disrespect from others because he is weak. So the opposite of Manto. I think the story will be about his evolution. How he goes from being a coward to someone who exposes the underbelly of society. Learns to take a stand. Puts aside his fears to become the voice of the oppressed. So beco.e a Manto. There will be a love track but I think the crux of the story will not be ishq mashooqi.

I saw a review where the reviewers said they spoke to Mohammad Ahmad recently (who played Mirza Naamdar in SMD). He is in Manto as well. He told them that Manto is a very strong and good script unlike SMD which was a very poor script.

I also feel Humayun and Nadeem will have more control in changing around the script this time.

I really think Manto will be critically acclaimed. People will call it KRQ's comeback.

SMD ki script itni kharab thi then why did he take it up?smiley36

hypnotoad thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: heavenlybliss

SMD ki script itni kharab thi then why did he take it up?smiley36

Supporting actors esp. of his age pick many dramas because of money and not script quality or even the role. But as a seasoned writer himself (who wrote Kuch Ankahi) he knows what is good vs bad script. Also, his role as Naamdar sb was actually good in SMD and even though it was just 4 episodes.

hypnotoad thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: hypnotoad

I don't think this will be anything like SMD.

It feels more like a social satire/social commentary. More along GM lines than SMD.

It will definitely be a ML-centric story unlike SMD.

I think it will be the story of a guy who is meek, cowardly, fearful, who cannot stand for his rights or rights of others, who takes abuse and disrespect from others because he is weak. So the opposite of Manto. I think the story will be about his evolution. How he goes from being a coward to someone who exposes the underbelly of society. Learns to take a stand. Puts aside his fears to become the voice of the oppressed. So beco.e a Manto. There will be a love track but I think the crux of the story will not be ishq mashooqi.

I saw a review where the reviewers said they spoke to Mohammad Ahmad recently (who played Mirza Naamdar in SMD). He is in Manto as well. He told them that Manto is a very strong and good script unlike SMD which was a very poor script.

I also feel Humayun and Nadeem will have more control in changing around the script this time.

I really think Manto will be critically acclaimed. People will call it KRQ's comeback.

In Nameer's iv today he talked a bit about Manto.

He said it's a show about rivalries - good vs bad guys. This is what I thought too that this will be more along the lines of GM (that was about ghunda vs gentleman) than smd, which is about love.

I still stand by what I said. Humayun will eventually lead a group of people to fight some injustice even though he is shown to be a cowardly fearful person at the beginning afraid to fight the bad guys. His name will be Manto but his personality will be the opposite. But he will eventually transform into a bold social warrior not afraid to call out what is wrong, like Manto.


Nameer also said they have been shooting this for last 1.5 years and some shoots are still left. But he thinks it should air by end April or in May. Do you think it will replace Aye Dil?

Edited by hypnotoad - 4 months ago
Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: hypnotoad

I don't think this will be anything like SMD.

It feels more like a social satire/social commentary. More along GM lines than SMD.

It will definitely be a ML-centric story unlike SMD.

I think it will be the story of a guy who is meek, cowardly, fearful, who cannot stand for his rights or rights of others, who takes abuse and disrespect from others because he is weak. So the opposite of Manto. I think the story will be about his evolution. How he goes from being a coward to someone who exposes the underbelly of society. Learns to take a stand. Puts aside his fears to become the voice of the oppressed. So beco.e a Manto. There will be a love track but I think the crux of the story will not be ishq mashooqi.

I saw a review where the reviewers said they spoke to Mohammad Ahmad recently (who played Mirza Naamdar in SMD). He is in Manto as well. He told them that Manto is a very strong and good script unlike SMD which was a very poor script.

I also feel Humayun and Nadeem will have more control in changing around the script this time.

I really think Manto will be critically acclaimed. People will call it KRQ's comeback.

Hopefully aisa hi hoo

Sajal mostly picks strong scripts, same goes for nadeem baig.

Looking forward to it.

Posted: 4 months ago

Pdp trps said it might replace Dastak

mala06 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 4

#EmAar (Radd)

Posted: 4 months ago

Originally posted by: G259

Pdp trps said it might replace Dastak

Then there is still some time.

Related Topics

Pakistani Serials Thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur

1 years ago

Faraar (GREEN) - Hamza Ali Abbasi, Sohai Ali Abro, Ahmed Ali Akbar

Hamza Ali Abbasi and Sajal Ali To Pair Up For A New Drama Titled Farar after 5 years 👇🏻👇🏻...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials Thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur

7 months ago

Dastak (ARY) - Ali Raza, Feroz Qadri, Sohai Ali Abro

Ali Raza and Sohai Ali Abro to do a New Drama titled Dastak Directed by Marina Khan and Produced by Humayun Saeed Through Six Sigma...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials Thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur

5 months ago

Sunn Mere Dil (GEO) #13 - Wahaj Ali, Maya Ali, Hira Mani Sunn Mere Dil (GEO) #13 - Wahaj Ali, Maya Ali, Hira Mani

This is The Part 13 Thread For Geo's Hit Drama Sunn Mere Dil...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials Thumbnail

Posted by: awida

2 years ago

The Pink Shirt (Zee5) - Wahaj Ali, Sajal Ali

#JustIn after giving us superhit shows like #DarrSiJatiHaiSila and #RaqeebSe The writer-director duo #BeeGul and #KashifNisar paired up for...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials Thumbnail

Posted by: NutellaWaffle

6 months ago

Sunn Mere Dil (GEO) #12 - Wahaj Ali, Maya Ali, Hira Mani Sunn Mere Dil (GEO) #12 - Wahaj Ali, Maya Ali, Hira Mani

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/pakistani-serials/5366933/sunn-mere-dil-geo-11-wahaj-ali-maya-ali-hira-mani Welcome to the new thread

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".