A Female's Dignity

thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

Sigh. I have no idea why I am even bothering to type this out. I am not a women-have-to-maintain-the-decorum fan but today, Navya reached out to me pretty well. That is sick of me, sure but the show's kind of helping me understand the queer and illogical restrictions my girl-friends are exposed to. So, way to go, writers, dun mess up the show please!

Navya was concerned about Sonia and she's brainy, so we'd not like to believe she had an idea, Sonia despised and treated her like a parasite or something. Anyhow, Navya behaved in a not-so-dignified manner, inquiring about her health in that hour of the night. Dignity is dignity, like a constant number - in any of its dimensions; it shall be the same then why is that two insults of different natures act on Navya's dignity differently?

Navya even confronted Sonia and believed it was her duty to conceal the truth regarding Sonia's disappearance. And tonight, when she was subjected to embarrassment right in the middle of the class - she burst into tears. All her friends, and Anant also whose sister happened to mess his CD thing and put him through that went out running for her.

Being concerned about somebody gets you their wrath and you're insulted but you do not mind whereas when something such as this happens wherein your new-found friend's sister burns his mischief on a CD and he mistakenly submits it as his project and you know he's a lad who's most likely never to do that to you, you run out of the class, with tears welded to your eyes and you are totally embarrassment-ridden.

I agree, the nature of both these insults is in contrast. But somehow, they highlight our society's double standards, or decently-speaking, how a female tends to be in our nation. Her dignity is several things to her. She'd compromise with it for the sake of compassion but she'd never let understanding or even truth come in her way to feel offended and shaken of what somebody, such as a male put her through. Exclusively a male, I should say. Her dignity is several things to her.

Your views?


-Kankshita

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

2.3k

Users

10

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

madhu_sridhar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
that was quite thought-provoking kankster😊...i'm still thinkin how 2 frame my opinion ...so i'm just gonna take some time..but i'll post my reply asap...
rituloveskmh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
HEy Kanshita,
I agree and disagree with your post!
well, I understand your stand wen it comes to how Navya must have felt and what made her take this entire "scene" on the level of dignity..
but at the same time, I feel that she did not need to take it to that level!
I think she should have stayed back, got up and questioned Anant right there wat and how did he end up showing taht cd in class!
I think that wud have been a much better approach!Not only wud it shut up those crackpots who were having a laugh session for free, but it wud also let the girl power rule!
Ritz was right wen she said..come back to the classroom, its not your fault!
I wud have loved if Navya wud have listened to Ritz..
she shd have had the guts to get back, and face the situation..coz it was obviously not her fault!
Anyways, I can even relate to your analysis!good job!
Love,
Ritz!
thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: rituloveskmh

HEy Kanshita,
I agree and disagree with your post!
well, I understand your stand wen it comes to how Navya must have felt and what made her take this entire "scene" on the level of dignity..
but at the same time, I feel that she did not need to take it to that level!
I think she should have stayed back, got up and questioned Anant right there wat and how did he end up showing taht cd in class!
I think that wud have been a much better approach!Not only wud it shut up those crackpots who were having a laugh session for free, but it wud also let the girl power rule!
Ritz was right wen she said..come back to the classroom, its not your fault!
I wud have loved if Navya wud have listened to Ritz..
she shd have had the guts to get back, and face the situation..coz it was obviously not her fault!
Anyways, I can even relate to your analysis!good job!
Love,
Ritz!


Ritu, hey. Yes, you're right on your part and I wouldn't object. But she's a fragile substance, you know and I quite like observing and calculating the mechanism of females like her in real. I do, and today I realized the most interesting aspect of their nature is their dignity.
Athena. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Interesting view on the situation but I don't concur.

For one, Navya did not compromise her dignity in the first case. She felt a sense of responsibility towards Sonia's wellbeing as it was her duty to get the CD to reach Anant at the right time. Having failed to do so, although this not being her fault, and adding to this her nature of compassion led her to go to the hospital. However, even so, she did not go alone. She asked her father and went with him. It's an other matter that she did not tell the truth about Sonia cutting herself to him. It's worthy of notice though that once she told her parents the full truth, they also did not have an objection to her going to visit her friend so late in the hour. They were concerned about the types of friends she mixed with.

If you say that Navya lost her dignity by wanting to help Sonia, then I really do not agree. Nobody loses dignity by trying to save one's life - let that even be your enemy. Navya hardly knows Anant or Sonia; how could she predict whether Sonia really did not try to kill herself? Even from the audience POV, we all predicted that Sonia loves herself too much to do anything, yet she did cut herself once Anant reached there. What's so brainy about this? What if Anant did not actually care and just left - she would have lost her life!

About the CD incident. Navya is not aware that Anant's sis did this. In fact, even Anant does not know. It's true that she thinks Anant's a good guy but you also have to see it from her view that her parents have brought her up away from any contacts with boys. We, as an audience having seen everything, are aware that Anant is innocent. But would it be this easy in real life? Could you really judge somebody so easily?

From personal experience, my parents would throw me out of the house if I took a picture with a guy. Perhaps Navya was worried about this incidence reaching to her parents. She maybe thought that the teacher or just by word of mouth her parents would find out. Navya's father is already concerned about Navya's friends after the Valentine's day fiasco. What if he found out that she took a pic with Anant? That she was becoming friends with him?

Awaiting your reply; would be nice to know how you still perceive the situation :)

-Anushka
thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: madhu_sridhar

that was quite thought-provoking kankster😊...i'm still thinkin how 2 frame my opinion ...so i'm just gonna take some time..but i'll post my reply asap...


Aw. Too cool. I like provoking thoughts, thanks - will wait.
Athena. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: rituloveskmh

HEy Kanshita,
I agree and disagree with your post!
well, I understand your stand wen it comes to how Navya must have felt and what made her take this entire "scene" on the level of dignity..
but at the same time, I feel that she did not need to take it to that level!
I think she should have stayed back, got up and questioned Anant right there wat and how did he end up showing taht cd in class!
I think that wud have been a much better approach!Not only wud it shut up those crackpots who were having a laugh session for free, but it wud also let the girl power rule!
Ritz was right wen she said..come back to the classroom, its not your fault!
I wud have loved if Navya wud have listened to Ritz..
she shd have had the guts to get back, and face the situation..coz it was obviously not her fault!
Anyways, I can even relate to your analysis!good job!
Love,
Ritz!


Really agree with your post! That would have been a much better approach.
That being said, I am really looking forward to witness the growth of her character! Up till now, I assume she has never been put in such a situation before so I completely understand why she ran away. Sadly, I think I would do the same thing :/ I'll probably run away to think, ha! I think I need to grow up too :P

Also, although it was not her fault, if she goes back and tries to defend herself people may just say 'oh it's true.. that's why ur acting so defensive'. Sometimes, I feel, it's best to let things cool down and act after finding out what really happened :)

-Anushka
Athena. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Kanky-



Well, I dun object on that. I liked how she managed the thing as well.

Lady, that is not what I talked about in the post. See, I'm a help-you die-hard as well and it is noble and nice and all that. Basically, I put forth in the comparison that Navya did not mind being held responsible for Sonia's businesses even after she was mighty rude to her in the hospital, I was talking solely about that insult which in my opinion is a dignity-shaker.

Fair enough. I agree. The way Sonia treated her in hospital was extremely rude but I guess it's in Navya's nature to forgive or to just move on?

For the kind of person I am, I might get up and clap and whistle and tell the boy the pictures were amazing right there. But somehow, Navya is not me - she is like my girl-friends, mostly so I understand the drift.

😆 When I read the first line I was feeling bad about the fact that I can't whistle no matter how hard I practise :(

My parents would find the idea of throwing me out really offering but uh, I am not a photo-session-with-hunks fan, though if I get pictures clicked with my guy-friends, I would not mind and if others would, I'd already know I dun give a shit. Navya has been brought up like many many gals I know and I second you on that. I am expected to grow into a lady like her as well, but I know I am a young woman with no such intentions. So, I think I will really have to be her or you or a random friend of mine to understand this whole issue.

My say was just that our society is funnily oppressive and the female here is a complicated element.

ha, your quite a character then, aren't you? I don't think Navya's trying to behave like a lady though; after all, a lady would never run in public :P Just kidding :) I think if you just keep up your analysis of her in the show, you'll be able to understand her. That's if the CVs stick to their guns and portray what they have set out to portray. But understanding an issue from all POV may be quite a task to achieve for anybody. At least your open to trying to understand, which is a big deal for any young woman! :)

Yes, society is more judgmental about females and it plays a huge role on the way we behave whether we like it or not. I guess, that's why Navya is so complicated (and so are you by the way lol). I would say that many girls in this day of age are pushing against the limitations set by society.

My perception is still the same, or maybe a tad bit tricky. Anyway, it was nice to yours. I await your reply too now. =]

Twas nice speaking to you :)
Hope to interact with you in many more topics to come ;)

-Anushka

Edited by Athena. - 14 years ago
rituloveskmh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
Really agree with your post! That would have been a much better approach.
That being said, I am really looking forward to witness the growth of her character! Up till now, I assume she has never been put in such a situation before so I completely understand why she ran away. Sadly, I think I would do the same thing :/ I'll probably run away to think, ha! I think I need to grow up too :P

Also, although it was not her fault, if she goes back and tries to defend herself people may just say 'oh it's true.. that's why ur acting so defensive'. Sometimes, I feel, it's best to let things cool down and act after finding out what really happened :)

-Anushka


Thanks Anushka..
Yeah, maybe you are right..maybe the world will take her "right" if she gets up, cries and runs away!
But I wud still choose to face the problem rather than running away!
Some people wud appreciate even that gesture!
Though, the way Navya's cahracter has been carved, it wud look very unusual for her to do something as bold as staying and facing!
So characterwise, I agree with ya!😳
tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
my question is if navya became joke of class then anant also plus first time anant opened with another girl other then his sister ,he also became the joke of class,plus he also belongs to strict family then he dint look embarised like navya ,???????????????

do only girls have dignity ,boys dont have??????????????????
Edited by tanvismile - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".