Originally posted by: COLOGY
Quite evidently it a attack on member which doesn't go with forum C&C
And you asked about sensible things... well there is nothing sensible in NB, not even Ridhi's dance. I don't see anyone dancing REALLY well expect Ritwik n Gurmeet.
And about Sajid's Support my opinion is the same... if there was any1 whom he was favouring from begining it has been Rakesh n Ridhi apart from GC-DB. There are many times where he has given elaborate marks to them. E.g: Cat act... seriously did it deserved tat many marks frm Sajid ?, if i'm not wrong ,sajid went on saying he tot of giving a standing ovation...
There are many times where he went overboard with marks for contestants not just his fav... he has been cruelly bad sometimes n too generous sometimes.
Btw it felt good to hear your approval on Barfi's marks :)) But i still don understand what you said abt avg contempory dance! If 4 ppl said it was a bad act n got 25 it was way beyond correct but that doesn't hold for others ryt? If you have problem with Sajid pour all your frustration on him not GurBina...
I wouldn't even talk about other contestants unless some posts here unnecessarily drag GurBina out of no where.
No, dint have much problem with gurbina...
but hated sajid to the core...
that is one thing ...
i never mentioned in the comment about anything bad ...
did i offend you ?????
if so then sorry ... really
because i couldnt find what was offending in it ...
if anything is very offending please let me know... i would edit it out
and i from a neutral point suggested that contemprary act was not good...
gurmeet was in form but i felt debina felt flat ...she was loosing form
it was mediocre ...even the choreo graphy ...
it was of 24 to 27 range ...
if you beleive they deserved more may be you have your own justification which may not be wrong...
and we can agree to disagree ...
agree about gurmeet and rithvik being good dancers...even vinod is a good dancer
but i felt that ridhi,shivangi and asha are really good in female bunch ...
and rakesh has improved tremendously ...
agaIN MY OPINION ...
AND CAT ACT ...
i liked it ...
it lacked perfection ...
but it was good... again in my opinion ...
and i dont know how cat acts are done ...
and in your opinion it was bad ...
your opinion may be correct also ...
again i am sorry if i offended you but ...😭
i dont get were i attacked you ...
my intention was not that 😭
sorry
regards ...
dear ,
i
my question above was that
Was there any act performed by gurbina which was sooo good that you expect a standing ovation but still dint get marks because of stupid reasons like ...no concept,
no story , not properly choreographed...
or not entertaining...
answer would be no?
and my problem is not that gurbina are getting marks ...or gurbina are or arent performing well
but my problem is again with the fact that why judges underscore others for acts which are iconic and perfect
like under water act by bruna and omar ,
ashviqs saree ke fall sa, aerial act, , emotional act which all deserved full marks ...
radhis oso act ,past 2 weeks act ... deserved a 31 or 32 atleast
rishis ...munni badnaam deserved 33 ,jive ,mere bebaasi ... deserved 28 atleast
the list gos on and on
when acts like behanee de, tango are performed by gurmeet and debina they are given marks quite leneantly ... like 30 when act deserves 27 at max...
this is what i felt ...
now why do good dancers like them need so much encouragement and marks ...????????????
again i repeat no problem with gurmeet and deb...or their performance ...
but why cant all be treated equally ... by judges ...
but may be you know more about this and
may be you are right if you say gc db deserve the marks ...
sorry if this offended you again ...
this is purely my opinion on scoring by judges ...
if it offended any body please let me know ...
Edited by kannansangee - 11 years ago