Originally posted by: ktopden
I HAVE AN HONEST QUESTIONS, SHANKAR always got lowest public votes. to get to finales, you need some public votes, how did shankar get to finale with lowest public votes?
i don't understand this. public vote count was a joke and points mattered more to GAJJI?
Didn't Himesh get second or highest public vote in prefinale show even though HR kept telling public not to vote for him?
some one explain without biased opinion, thank you.
Trying to explain un-biasedly .....
Himesh got highest public votes from - Mumbai, UP (really strange, this is Harshit's area), Gujarat (obhivios .. Aishwarya home state), Rajasthan (again strange .. Toshi's state) ... he was leading more than double than others form these areas
In overall public voting (whole India) .. highest vote was received by Shaan ... so with his 3 points + hightest votes ... straight to finale (Yipeee)
Now Himesh was 2nd in public votes .. this is what they told ... what they did not revealed was who was 3rd ... was it Shreya or Shankar .... so that part remains still unclear. If Shankar was 3rd in public votes (more than Shreya 😲) then with his 4 points + 3rd position he is straught in finale and Himesh stay back due to 2 points + 2nd position ... Also the gap between Himesh and Shankar's total votes was not revealed .... hmmmm so that's the dodgy area
One more dodgy area was about Shreya ... she was confirmed to perform in US shows ... which happens on 17th/ 18th .... Some of my friends also went there for performing (band) ... so it was known before the voting result came up that Shreya is going there ... now no one talked about Shreya's vote bank this time ... All Shreya, Abhas and Aneek has a huge vote bank. I can guess Aneek's vote was divoded for Shaan's team due to Anwesha and Debo .. .but Abhas is hugely popular in his area and also gets votes (he was 3rd in Star VOI) .... so was it that Shreya pusposely backed put from the show due to other commitment????
That's the whole explanation as I have understood ...
Now personally I was looking for Shaan vs. Shreya (for Shreya, Abhas and Anneek's song) or Shaan vs. Himesh (for more of Aishwarya, Raja and Vineet) .... but alas would have to listen to more of Shankar M's song only as he would comming and singing all the time ... only Rahul may get some chance to sing ...
Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago